Tall, nice face, nice body, fit, youthful, etc.
The city where I grew up (the 215/267), genuinely NO ONE was conventionally attractive looking, unless they were an outsider. Almost everyone (me included, by the way) were genuinely UGLY AF, out of shape, homeless-looking, or some mix of those. Only on a few college campuses would you find conventionally attractive looking people; usually girls from the suburbs and out-of-state who came to the city to live on-campus. Most news anchors and gym rats weren't even conventionally good looking. Both of those were typically older people, 40+ years old, for whatever reason; probably because gyms and the time to go to them are reserved for the more wealthy. So about 2-5% of people, AT BEST, were attractive looking in my hometown.