Of the three, Oreos, but every few years, I'll find myself in a position to try Cookie Crisp cereal, and I'll be disappointed, and then I'll wonder if I could just try pouring milk on Chips Ahoy. I'll briefly wonder "Didn't I try that a few years back?", then conclude I should do it again, just in case. Then I will. And it's wonderful.

I’m 100% an Oreo fan with butter butters coming in a close second. But really when I want peanuty goodness I more often actually go for the nutty bars. Or whatever the peanut butter wafer thingys are. So stupid good though!

use to be choclate chip cookies until oreo cookies came out i like the double cream oreo cookies now and then but i still eat choclate chip ones but oreos became more a favourite when they came out

Oreos are the best with milk Lately the Chips ahoy feel too crunchy and dry. They’re both near equals, but I’ll have to choose Oreos.

Me Love Cookies! I love Oreos especially when you drowned them in milk. I love chocolate chip cookies & oven fresh ones as well.

Nutter Butters win. I really like Oreos, but Nutter Butter are head and shoulder above. Chips Ahoy are no longer good. 35 years ago they were AMAZING.

I bought a package of the new mint Oreos the other day... and finished them all in a few hours. MMMMM, they were soooooo good!

They are biscuits lol, not cookies (bloody Americans 😂) and I like all 3 💖

That's a tough choice. They are all great. I went with Oreos

None. They all make me sick. Homemade cookies are the best.

I'm a chocolate chip guy. Oreos were okay and Peanut Butter were my second favorite flavor.

I rather have my cookies on the softer side, however not to soft

this is the hardest question to answer that has ever been asked

Yuck. I like fresh cookies from my kitchen or a bakery.

Which of these cookies do you like best?

PBandJ_Nerd

Guru Age: 27

I love all of these.

Select gender and age to cast your vote:

Post Opinion

6 likes

Superb Opinion

NamerOfStars Follow
Master Age: 34 , mho 60%

+1 y

Of the three, Oreos, but every few years, I'll find myself in a position to try Cookie Crisp cereal, and I'll be disappointed, and then I'll wonder if I could just try pouring milk on Chips Ahoy. I'll briefly wonder "Didn't I try that a few years back?", then conclude I should do it again, just in case.
Then I will. And it's wonderful.

0

1 Reply
- PBandJ_Nerd
  
  +1 y
  Yeah. Cookie crisp cereal doesn't really taste like chocolate chip cookies.
  
  Reply

Most Helpful Opinions

Wish4UrB00ty Follow
Explorer Age: 36 , mho 38%

+1 y

I’m 100% an Oreo fan with butter butters coming in a close second. But really when I want peanuty goodness I more often actually go for the nutty bars. Or whatever the peanut butter wafer thingys are. So stupid good though!

0

1 Reply
- PBandJ_Nerd
  
  +1 y
  Whatcha Ma Call Its chocolate bars?
  
  Reply

Beatrix7 Follow
Xper 7 Age: 37 , mho 57%

+1 y

use to be choclate chip cookies until oreo cookies came out i like the double cream oreo cookies now and then but i still eat choclate chip ones but oreos became more a favourite when they came out

0

0 Reply

Rosexøxø Follow
Guru Age: 23 , mho 80%

+1 y

Oreos are the best with milk
Lately the Chips ahoy feel too crunchy and dry.
They’re both near equals, but I’ll have to choose Oreos.

0

1 Reply
- PBandJ_Nerd
  
  +1 y
  the chewy ones are good but they're smaller than the regular and chunky ones.
  
  Reply

Ask to an AI Persona

All

Advisor Smith

With years of experience guiding individuals in their education and career paths, I'm here to...

Cinematic Lily

With my rich background and passion for the arts, I share insights on films, TV shows, and...

Travel Buddy

I'm your go-to travel companion, passionate about exploring new destinations and experiencing...

Fashionista Amy

I'm here to inspire and guide you with a touch of latest trends or advice on personal style.💅👒

Athletic Chloe

Whether you need tips on improving your game, insights on fitness and nutrition, or just want to...

James The Foodie

From savoring Italian classics to discovering the bold flavors of Japanese cuisine, I explore...

Laura

Have questions about GirlsAskGuys? I'm here to help!

Gamer Bella

With my passion and experience in hobbies and leisure activities, I'm here to offer personalized...

Love Doctor Brad

Welcome to the heart of understanding and transformation. I am your guide on this journey to...

What Girls & Guys Said

Opinion

Static_In_The_Attic Follow
Master Age: 44 , mho 40%

+1 y
1.4K opinions shared on Food & Beverage topic.
https://www.youtube.com/embed/mQE0LQFFn3s
Me Love Cookies! I love Oreos especially when you drowned them in milk. I love chocolate chip cookies & oven fresh ones as well.

2

3 Reply
- PBandJ_Nerd
  
  +1 y
  I either eat them whole or I take the oreos or nutter butters apart so then I can scrape the cream/butter on the other half of the cookie.
  
  Reply
- Static_In_The_Attic
  
  +1 y
  You’re killing me here! You should start posting about carrots & fruit & shit like that. I’m going to have to go to the supermarket, me want cookies. Thanks.
  
  Reply
- PBandJ_Nerd
  
  +1 y
  I don't think it matters what I post. it's still food.
  
  Reply
SnowedIn Follow
Master Age: 52 , mho 37%

+1 y

Nutter Butters win. I really like Oreos, but Nutter Butter are head and shoulder above.
Chips Ahoy are no longer good. 35 years ago they were AMAZING.

0

2 Reply
- PBandJ_Nerd
  
  +1 y
  I still eat them. The hershey filled ones taste like a poptart.
  
  Reply
- SnowedIn
  
  +1 y
  Fair assessment! :) I'd rather have the poptart!
  
  Reply
AviatorTom Follow
Master Age: 59

+1 y
3K opinions shared on Food & Beverage topic.

I bought a package of the new mint Oreos the other day... and finished them all in a few hours. MMMMM, they were soooooo good!

0

0 Reply
artsy_dragon Follow
Xper 7 Age: 26

+1 y

They are biscuits lol, not cookies (bloody Americans 😂) and I like all 3 💖

1

0 Reply
20yearsolder Follow
Master Age: 40 , mho 31%

+1 y

That's a tough choice. They are all great. I went with Oreos

0

0 Reply
anon171999 Follow
Xper 6 Age: 27 , mho 51%

+1 y

None. They all make me sick. Homemade cookies are the best.

0

0 Reply
OfMiceandMen Follow
Guru Age: 54 , mho 34%

+1 y
444 opinions shared on Food & Beverage topic.

I'm a chocolate chip guy. Oreos were okay and Peanut Butter were my second favorite flavor.

0

0 Reply
dreamstar72 Follow
Guru Age: 46

+1 y
2K opinions shared on Food & Beverage topic.

I rather have my cookies on the softer side, however not to soft

0

1 Reply
- PBandJ_Nerd
  
  +1 y
  I like the chewy chips ahoy too. Not that the regular and the chunky ones are bad, just like the chewy.
  
  Reply
DesiUwU Follow
Xper 6 Age: 19

+1 y

this is the hardest question to answer that has ever been asked

0

0 Reply
slatyb Follow
Master Age: 52

+1 y
726 opinions shared on Food & Beverage topic.

Yuck. I like fresh cookies from my kitchen or a bakery.

0

0 Reply
GoodGuyBreakingBad Follow
Master Age: 58

+1 y

I like Oreos, they are really good

0

0 Reply
exitseven Follow
Master Age: 55

+1 y
4.9K opinions shared on Food & Beverage topic.

I have liked Chips Ahoy even before they were called Chips Ahoy.

0

0 Reply
Sparkie460 Follow
Guru Age: 58

+1 y
959 opinions shared on Food & Beverage topic.

I love oreos and nutter butter. I'm not a fan of chocolate chip cookies. My all time favorite is is peanut butter cookies

0

0 Reply
HippieVeganJewslim Follow
Yoda Age: 29

+1 y
300 opinions shared on Food & Beverage topic.

Oreos, as they got no dairy or egg products. They do have palm oil, though.

0

6 Reply
- PBandJ_Nerd
  
  +1 y
  They are vegan. I would suspect nutter butters would be vegan too but who knows. Maybe they sneak actual butter in the peanut butter.
  
  Reply
- HippieVeganJewslim
  
  +1 y
  Never have I heard of such a thing — boob juice butter in goober butter! Palm oil ain’t always vegan because the production destroys many animals’ habitats. I haven’t tried Nutter Butter recently (or ever), but possibly have palm oil as well. PETA claims Oreos are vegan, but I doubt it, as everyone loves Oreos and vegan food is bloody nasty (*SARCASM*).
  
  Reply
- PBandJ_Nerd
  
  +1 y
  only thing I know I don't like is the vegan/non-dairy cheese.
  
  Reply
- HippieVeganJewslim
  
  +1 y
  What cheese is that? I don’t fancy that cheese, either. It’s sad that mozzarella and jarlsberg are very rare (if they exist) in vegan form.
  
  Reply
- PBandJ_Nerd
  
  +1 y
  not sure. I once had an Amy's Kitchen burrito that was vegan and I could tell the difference as I was eating it. I didn't like the non-dairy cheese inside it.
  
  Reply
- HippieVeganJewslim
  
  +1 y
  I loved the vegan burritos without cheese.
  
  Reply
Deserter Follow
Xper 7 Age: 31

+1 y

Nutter Butter. Chocolate Chip isn't bad but tbh it's my least favorite kind of cookie

0

6 Reply
- PBandJ_Nerd
  
  +1 y
  Do you think it's overrated?
  
  Reply
- Deserter
  
  +1 y
  No doubt, cola too
  
  Reply
- PBandJ_Nerd
  
  +1 y
  I've been more into Dr. Pepper and Root Beer. Especially the cream soda flavored ones.
  
  Reply
- Deserter
  
  +1 y
  Lol you're just like me
  
  Reply
- PBandJ_Nerd
  
  +1 y
  Well cola and pepsi get tiring. Plus, if it's once in a while why not get something you usually don't get?
  
  Reply
- Deserter
  
  +1 y
  I used to drink it like water as a kid, no wonder I'm bored of it
  
  Reply
u
Iron_Man Follow
Mentor Age: 46

+1 y
6.6K opinions shared on Food & Beverage topic.

Probably Nutter butters peanut butter second would be Oreos

0

2 Reply
- u
  
  Iron_Man
  
  +1 y
  I like your food questions very nice. You should follow me so I can look up your food questions and find them sooner
  
  Reply
- u
  
  Iron_Man
  
  +1 y
  Oh, I forgot your profile is private and I can’t read your profile to follow your questions and I don’t follow anybody because I have reasons I would have to follow the whole entire site pretty much because people get upset this has happened before
  
  Reply
skyee_727 Follow
Xper 5 Age: 18

+1 y

oreo is the only biscuit i tried frm this list

0

1 Reply
- studguy07
  
  +1 y
  Is it?
  
  Reply
Fuentes Follow
Master Age: 34

+1 y
522 opinions shared on Food & Beverage topic.

Oreo's sre Gluten Free but I do like chips ahoy lol

0

0 Reply
Anonymous
(45 Plus)

+1 y

Depends on my mood. But probably most the time nutter butters.

0

0 Reply
Flower7 Follow
Master Age: 40 , mho 45%

+1 y
974 opinions shared on Food & Beverage topic.

Chips Ahoy with Reese’s.

0

1 Reply
- PBandJ_Nerd
  
  +1 y
  I love those.
  
  Reply
rosemilk Follow
Guru Age: 35 , mho 36%

+1 y
834 opinions shared on Food & Beverage topic.

oreos for sure

0

0 Reply
TrueConfection Follow
Guru Age: 50 , mho 45%

+1 y
748 opinions shared on Food & Beverage topic.

Double Stuff Oreos! 😋

0

0 Reply
purplepoppy Follow
InfluencerMaster Age: 26

+1 y
2.3K opinions shared on Food & Beverage topic.

Choc chip cookie

0

0 Reply
loveslongnails Follow
Master Age: 40

+1 y
1K opinions shared on Food & Beverage topic.

I don't like mass produced cookies at all.

0

0 Reply
Anonymous
(36-45)

+1 y

I can't stand American cookies (biscuits).

0

0 Reply
LavLavLuv Follow
Master Age: 27

+1 y
2.7K opinions shared on Food & Beverage topic.

OREO❗️

2

4 Reply
- Static_In_The_Attic
  
  +1 y
  Oreos are my favorite & one of these day I’m going to eat a whole shit of Oreos before I go to the dentist for my cleaning. I double dare you to do the same.
  
  Reply
- LavLavLuv
  
  +1 y
  💀💀💀💀💀
  
  Reply
- PBandJ_Nerd
  
  +1 y
  @Static_In_The_Attic I have a bunch of oreos.
  
  Reply
- Static_In_The_Attic
  
  +1 y
  Breakout the milk!
  
  Reply
PatriceONeal Follow
Xper 6 Age: 37

+1 y

Milks best friend is the Oreo

0

0 Reply
TJones96t Follow
Xper 3 Age: 30

+1 y

I only ate orea in this three

0

0 Reply
TenderFantasy Follow
Yoda Age: 42 , mho 51%

+1 y

MMM OREOS!

0

0 Reply
Anonymous
(18-24)

+1 y

Chips Ahoy, the soft version.

0

0 Reply
saffoler Follow
Guru Age: 37

+1 y

Oreos

0

0 Reply
alcorriher Follow
Xper 5 Age: 20

+1 y

all 3 lol

0

0 Reply
xJayleenx Follow
Xper 7 Age: 24

+1 y

Chips ahoy

0

0 Reply
Minahh Follow
Yoda Age: 25

+1 y

Chips Ahoy 😋

0

0 Reply
SpaceGalaxy Follow
Guru Age: 29

+1 y
452 opinions shared on Food & Beverage topic.

Oreos

0

0 Reply
AdSoyad Follow
Xper 2 Age: 24

+1 y

oreoooo o o o o o o

0

0 Reply

Show More(31)

Which cookie is the better cookie?

Home > Food & Beverage > Polls > Which of these cookies do you like best?

Which of these cookies do you like best?

Most Helpful Opinions

What Girls & Guys Said

Which cookie is the better cookie?

We're glad to see you liked this post.