How likely is it that calling another girl "really pretty" turned off a girl who was into me? Is it worth it to try again? How?

[Rab1901]

Met that night at a popular bar. I expressed clear interest in her. She actually asked for my number and wanted to make plans for tomorrow.

Do you think calling another girl "really pretty" is enough to turn a girl off or do you think there is more? Please explain

Is it worth it to try again? If so, what do you suggest?

[DizzyDesii]

Of course we find others hot but i just hope he's not dumb enough to compliment another/tell another girl that in front of me. So i think you messed up your shot

[Rab1901]

I have to ask, what exactly would you be thinking if a guy did that?

[DizzyDesii]

I would lose interest in him

[Anonymous]

I think if it turns her off that's a Red flag for jealousy if you can't compliment another woman respectfully to her.. As long as you're also able to accept when she calls another man handsome.

[dreamstar72]

She would probably think that you are not that considered about about her feelings. Plus that you are not to bright to make a remark like that in front of her

[TacosRAwesome]

Very likely. Unless she's into that sort of thing.

[Rab1901]

Do you think there's something a guy can do to recover from the fallback?

[TacosRAwesome]

Not really.

[Rab1901]

I have to ask, why is it such a turnoff? What would you be thinking if it happened to you?

[TacosRAwesome]

It's a turnoff because him asking me out stops being personal. I'd be thinking what an absolute twat.

[Rab1901]

Compliments are nice though. Are you saying that he's a twat because it makes him seem like a player, and he probably calls every girl really pretty?

[Flower7]

That would definitely be a huge turn-off.

[Rab1901]

Do you think there's something a guy can do to recover from the fallback?

[Flower7]

No because why would you even tell her that in the first place. She’s definitely going to see you negatively after telling her another girl is pretty, especially if she was interested in you.

[Rab1901]

I have to ask, if it happened to you, what exactly would be going on in your mind? What negative thoughts would you be having?

[Flower7]

I would think he’s a player and also that he just wasn’t into me.

[Jamie05rhs]

Yes, it's enough. Females are extremely petty.