Do you think this engagement ring is acceptable? Would you propose with it?

[Anonymous]

[Goforit1010]

If that ring isn't acceptable, than what is? WHY does it have to be a ridiculously expensive ring to propose with?

When I proposed to my wife, I had zero ring. Just got down on a knee (we were alone) and asked her. Later that day, she and I went to a restaurant and I cut ✂️ the paper ring that held the silverware in the napkin and gave that to her as an engagement "ring". We both laughed about it, but she kept that paper thingy. When I tried to get her a diamond ring (she was with me), she refused it. She said she would be too afraid to knock the diamond off the setting and lose it. Any rings we looked at, that had the diamond "captured", looked gaudy and unattractive. Sooooo... I did buy her a ring very similar to the one in the picture of this Q. The stone was plastic and the ring overall was really cheap, but she loved it! If anyone complained about that ring, she jumped right down their case about it. Seven months later, we walked down the aisle and said our vows to each other. That was 24+ years ago!

[ohsheeT]

A piece of string a bubble gum machine ring would be acceptable if you love the person it has nothing to do how expensive the ring is it has nothing to do with what it looks like it has something to do with who the person is and what their heart is telling you what your heart feels at that moment if you think that that ring is too small her to Gotti or to anything then that person should not be getting with you is when you can love anything that you get whether it be a rubber band or $5 million ring it does not matter they both equal the same thing how did you receive it what were you doing what was happening in that moment of time because that's the most important part of the whole process if it was coming from somebody's heart and it was a beautiful moment I wouldn't get hair if it was a pin that somebody draw the ring on my finger it's in that moment that's what counts

[Silvermantis]

That ring is beautiful and exactly my style. I would definitely love it.
Also I personally think if you like it- no one else’s opinion on it matters.

[jennifer_bloom]

I love the colour, definitely a dream ring in my eyes.

[NathanDavis]

I will propose with a ring made of foil... lol

and if she does not appreciate it, then I will know she's not the one for me... lol

[jamesgoldman]

Anything is acceptable circumstancually, me in my business I'd probably have to go for a moderate diamond

[slatyb]

I’m not a fan of engagement rings. It’s just a way to sell diamonds.

[Anonymous]

i mean, does it really fucking matter? if it's not acceptable then say why say yes to the proposal?

[roy_ricky09]

Why is that even a question? Does the size matter or the relationship?