If you were casually listening to this, would the noise bother you?

[Anonymous]

And I mean the piano key noise. I've Eq'd it to give it more treble, but the more treble I add, the more it reveals the little clicks and taps that the piano makes. The vst was sampled from a real piano so it makes sense 🤔 But do you mind?

https://voca.ro/1JN7grzs4Id3

If you're wondering about the song, it's just a free tempo improv of "Angus MacRae - Mirror Lake." I definitely recommend checking it out if you like piano music!

Yes, the noise would bother me.

It wouldn't bother me at first, but it could the more often I listen to it.

No, I don't think the noise would bother me.

[have_a_good_day]

Sorry, I couldn't get past 6 seconds of it.. It started giving me a weird feeling in the pit of my stomach..
So I would say maybe it bothers some people on a biological level..
I feel dirty now

[Asker]

✍ never ✍ play ✍ piano ✍ ever ✍ again

got it! 📝

[cheapshotbob]

i liked this , it sounds like a slower tempo than the other clip you shared , it is something i could rest to or listen t if i was doing some writing , there is noting
wrong with this at all.

[Asker]

That's nice ✍ now what do you hate about it? 🤔📝

[cheapshotbob]

im not lol i didn't hear anything that bothered or hurt my ears. not sure of that means im tone def or not lol if i have to make up a reason i guess it was not long enough but can't think of any real reason.

[Asker]

😂 I'm just playin, thanks for commenting tho

[cheapshotbob]

oh lol ok and no problem.

[Mellifluous_]

Holy shit that sounds nice! I actually like the noise tbh. It gives it an intimate and real feel, it's literally perfect. The sound you chose and just everything 👌

[Asker]

Thanks! ✍ But I must still work harder and get better!

[PaynefulPleasures]

How would it bother me this sounds like a beautiful piece of music thank you for sharing ❣️

[Asker]

No prob! 😂 And thanks! But is there anything you'd change if you could? Like about the sound design?

[PaynefulPleasures]

No actually I like it great meditation piece 🙂

[Asker]

Ahh okay, thanks! 🙏

[PaynefulPleasures]

Please bring out more music you always have good taste ❣️

[Asker]

I do like sharing music! And I have a lot! Do you have any instrument preferences? To help narrows down the search some

[PaynefulPleasures]

I like classical wind calypso🎶surprise me🎼

[Asker]

Ahh, will do! I'll gather some songs!

[PaynefulPleasures]

Looking forward to it 😊

[Asker]

Made a playlist with a bunch of instrumental songs I like:

youtube.com/playlist

[PaynefulPleasures]

Wow love it I just added it to my play list thank you for sharing ❣️😊

[Asker]

No prob! I've got even more music soundtracks I like, maybe one day I can upload them into a drive or something because there's a lot! Then send over the link to anyone that's interested

[WindAtMyBack]

I don't really notice it. I'm not even sure what you are referring to.

It has more of an electric sound than I prefer though. It sounds like an electric piano, not an acoustic piano.

[Asker]

That's interesting 🤔 this is the most non-electric sounding piano vst I've owned 😂

[WindAtMyBack]

Could Vocaroo be doing that? Like do they compress it or anything?

[Asker]

I don't think so, vocaroo is pretty good at keeping the audio quality I noticed. The only difference I hear is that the highs are a bit compressed.

[Asker]

Wait I hear what you hear now 😂

[WindAtMyBack]

I 'm not sure what I'm picking up. I listened again. It might be the soft touch. I'm not a pianist or musician. But I the touch seems too soft to me. I imagine a harder touch for piano ( is attack the right word?) The way it's levered, the hammer is accelerated. It just sounds too soft to me. Or maybe the musician has a very soft touch. I don't really know what's possible on a piano.

There is also a lot of resonating. That might be the placement of the microphone.

[Asker]

Oh okay, I think what you're hearing are my purposeful effects 😂

[MrWolf]

No it doesn't but some of the higher notes kind are to high but all together is an relaxing piece I'd listen over morning coffee.

[Asker]

Ahh, wym too high? Like too loud for comfort?

[MrWolf]

Not the whole but a small part in like from 36 it starts it ain't that bad but could lower that tone.

by the way what's my last name 🤣

[Asker]

Oh, I chose this tone on purpose 😂 I like the older, brittle, full-bodied sound for the highs.

I honestly have no idea, Mr. Wolf

[MrWolf]

Ohh you forgot that you said you will find out what is lmao 🤣

But your music is art to my ears by the way.

[Asker]

😂 Oh forgot that was you, sorry I message so many accounts per day. But I was just joking about that 😂😂

But just to be clear, you were talking about the tone of it and not the volume? 🤔 Because I do have to be extra careful when pressing the upper notes. For some reason, they're very responsive

And thanks man! It a really good song!

[MrWolf]

To pitch of it the volume. Was to how to i say it high note like was a bit loud that tone.

No worries I'm your fen bro. I would always listen to a piece of yours.

[Asker]

😂 But thanks man, means a lot! And feel free to let me know any other other preferences because I'm always trying to improve! 🙏

[MrWolf]

Welcome to my life I'm even more confused then you. And if i might say whatever your souls dictates you to that i would listen. You are the artist we can only listen and enjoy

[Asker]

True that! Can't appeal to everyone! 😂 No matter how much I'd like to

[SandandWaves]

i really enjoyed that. real relaxing, and i need that right now too ;)

[Asker]

I'm glad to have brought some peace!

[SandandWaves]

hugs

[Asker]

Did you remove the photo I sent or is gag tripping? 🤔 I swore I hit send

[SandandWaves]

it scared me

[Asker]

😂 poor pennywise, you hurt his feelings!

[SandandWaves]

hahe.. what about mine...

[Asker]

pennywise feelings matter before any mere mortals!

[SandandWaves]

ok...

[Asker]

‏‏‎ ‎

[Citizenkirk]

It's better than most of the elevator music I've heard.

[Asker]

so it's shit 😂

[Citizenkirk]

I wouldn't call it "the shit" but it's not horrible, iether.

[Asker]

What kind of piano music do you generally like the sound of? 🤔

[t-8900]

i played pokemon as a kid so this would not bother me at all. :P

[Asker]

Ion get it 👄

[Wolfinabbie]

By this question and the answers we can really see who is a music lover with quality or those who are not bothered by it😂😂

[Asker]

Which are you?

[Wolfinabbie]

Music lover with quality. I'd rather enjoy the sound and everything.

[Asker]

Ahh, the funny thing about this piano vst is, if I don't eq up the highs (which causes more key noise to appear), it will sound less quality and muffled 😂

[InferiorElegy]

I don't know why but I got sad listening to it, it's like it tried to give me a reason to cry. The song is nice and I am not sure what noise you are talking about but I wasn't bothered.

[Asker]

Maybe it's tryna show you the already existing reason

[InferiorElegy]

Yeah it just sounds like I'm collecting reasons to cry since I already have a bunch.

[Asker]

Do what I do. Put on some sad music, lay in bed, think about life and just let loose under the cover!

[Anpu23]

It sounds like a real piano. I prefer to hear the mechanical sound it makes it feel more real.

[Asker]

I'm torn between the two. I like when there's no sound but I really don't mind listening to artists that have mechanical sounds, sustain pedal sounds, or any background noises 🤔

[Lexi_Lous]

No I listened to piano and violin today actually, it wouldn't bother me at all

[Asker]

Ahh okay, what were you listening to?

[Lexi_Lous]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dx5qFachd3A

[Asker]

How do you feel about this?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=65A1uJp0l-o

[Lexi_Lous]

I like it!

[Asker]

You might like this one as well:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GFoJli7qRdc

[Wise4myage]

No. that is very peaceful music to hear at any time of the day.

[Asker]

thanks!

[anylolone]

Might be a cool new texture.
But try and see where it leads.

[Asker]

🧙‍♂️ hopefully the journey leaves me satisfied

[Anonymous]

Where's the noise?
I didn't hear ANY super high pitched keys being hit to create that mechanical noise.
Unless you're talking about a different kind of "noise"

[Asker]

It can't be picked up by certain headsets but it's mainly in the 5khz range I think

[MCheetah]

Is this a humblebrag or what? It sounds fine.

[Asker]

No, there's key noise at around the 5khz region, and I just wanted to know if it bothered people. So, I had to play a song as I would normally play it. I don't like bragging, because I don't see what I can do as something to brag about.

[MCheetah]

I didn't hear any noise or something that stood out. Then again, I don't use headphones on my computer or phone.

[Asker]

Oh okay, yeah that's definitely why.

[Serelita]

No, I don't think the noise would bother me.

[Asker]

U sure? 🤔📝

[lillianaustin]

No, i really liked it, it's comforting

[Asker]

thanks!

[Cam45795]

Not bad, for a cat stomping on ivory🐈

[Asker]

Still not good enough, I gotta practice my tap dancin more often

[Cam45795]

Clogging seems more fitting

[Asker]

I've heard that tap dancing is more complex 🤔

[Cam45795]

Clogging is raw power

[Asker]

but piano needs more than just power 🧙‍♂️

[Cam45795]

It's no hammer dulcimer

[Asker]

It's also no hammer Mjölnir

[Cam45795]

Great Odin's Raven! it most certainly is not

[Asker]

Best tasting bird I've met

[Cam45795]

It's not often a man meets his dinner to be. Cats are better known for this

[Asker]

He was a funny guy too! I didn't speak to him tho... His funny bone just tasted abnormally delicious for a bird 👄

[Cam45795]

I feel you are assuming the raven's gender

[Asker]

well she looked like a dude

[Cam45795]

Long live queen Elizabeth since we're on the that subject

[Asker]

😂 hear, hear! 🍻

[Jaylaa2000]

Not at all

[Asker]

Ahh okay, I am relieved tbh 😂 thanks for commenting!

[Jaylaa2000]

No problem

[JosyJosy]

No you're good :)

[Asker]

thanks!

[msc545]

I hate noise

[Asker]

The noise? Or noise in general?

[msc545]

Noise in general

[Joker_]

listening to what

[Asker]

I honestly have no idea

[Asker]

I think she may know☝️

[Joker_]

comedy moment

[Asker]

she should title my piano music

[Joker_]

I agree