What is your favorite Girl Scout Cookie?

[TenderFantasy]

Unfortunately can't choose more than one lol.

So if you had to choose just one for the rest of the GSC sales. Eat just one type.

Peanut Butter Sandwhich (Do-si-dos)!

Thin Mints

Savannah Smiles

Cranberry Citrus Crisps

Ra-Rah-Raisins

Thanks- A - Lot

Cookie not listed hehe.

Updates

+1 y

I think there's like 12 kinds lol. But for me, I always go for either the Thin Mints or the Peanut Butter Sandwhich (the do-si-dos)! That's my top favorite, followed by the Thin Mints. Haven't really tasted (nor plan to), taste the others lol. It's not $6.00 per box and I'm not rich! Haha.

Updates

+1 y

$6.00 per box I mean lol.

[OfMiceandMen]

I like the Peanut Butter kind.

[NostalgiaSenpi]

Do-si-dos.

[Apple1996]

Tagalongs but I'm kind of cheap so I usually just buy the knock off ones at Walmart

[TenderFantasy]

Lol I did that before. But I still kind of think the real thing is better. The keebler ones are okay.

[PBandJ_Nerd]

I have a few: lemonade cookies, trefoil cookies, thanks a lots (they no longer make them), pb sandwich, french toast, and brownie. I like the thin mints and the pb chocolate patties, but they aren't in my top favorites.

[TenderFantasy]

Damn lol. You ARE a true Girl Scout Cookie Lover! 😛

[PBandJ_Nerd]

They're good. We have some saved for summer.

[PBandJ_Nerd]

I thought today you could take the trefoil cookies and make like the one sandwich cookies from lunchables. lol

[lightbulb27]

I can't imagine the size of these cookies now due to inflation. Gotta be the size of a quarter.

I honestly don't like most... American cookies are just junky.. buy European or Indian. I like girl scouts and often supported them.

[Static_In_The_Attic]

Tagalongs are my favorite.

[DubiousIntentions]

Some of these have not been around for a long time. Tag a longs are now peanut butter patties. Trefoils are long gone even though they were well liked.

[CateM]

That's a no-brainer! Thin mints, (duh!) But I'll say the worst ones are most definitely toffee-tastic, more like toffee-terrible

[Amy10223]

My favorites are the Tagalongs and the Samoas. One of my kids was crazy about the Thin Mints.

[Sevenpointfive]

i dunno? i don't eat cookies, but i do eat girl scouts !!!

[TenderFantasy]

Lmao!

[annabananna]

Tagalongs are first and dosidos second. How did you not list Tagalongs? That a customer favorite lol

[TenderFantasy]

No more room lol!

[annabananna]

Those sweet sweet Tagalongs would probably hit at least 60% lol

[horatiohornblower]

Seriously. Most of the ones listed I wouldn’t touch. Except Thin Mints. But Tagalongs are the best.

[TenderFantasy]

@horatiohornblower Then you've never tried the Peanut Butter Sandwhich, oh Lord do they scream DELISH! haha.

[horatiohornblower]

I never liked peanut butter cookies. I love cookies. I love peanut butter. I do not like them combined. They aren't disgusting, they just always taste funny to me.

[TenderFantasy]

@horatiohornblower Even if it's wrapped in oatmeal crackers? It's nothing like Nutter Butter, that's stuff is nasty. This is different, it's not too sweet and not too salty. It's just right. If you ever stop by one of their tables to try one, I think you would change your mind. Up to you :- )

[horatiohornblower]

I've had them before. I just do not like sweet mixed with peanut butter. With the exception of a bit of jam. But mainly I like peanut butter on toast, saltines with cheese or on a saltine with a scoop of chili.

[DeeDeeDeVour]

Almost always, it's the Tagalongs that I prefer to buy.

[DizzyDesii]

Im not really a cookie person but i admit that Shortbreads (trefoils) just melt in your mouth

[DizzyDesii]

Never knew cookies were only 5-6 a box. Thats not bad at all. people act like its $20 a box lmao. Now i wanna go find the nearest girlscout and load up

[Wish4UrB00ty]

My favorites are the thin mints and the pb patties.

[Still-alive]

Tagalongs and thin mints please. Love peanut butter

[TenderFantasy]

Have yet to taste Tagalongs, but maybe one day hehe.

[Still-alive]

They’re great. And once i start i end up eating like over half the box lol

[CaptainSmartass]

Hang on? They get little kids to sell overpriced biscuits, and some how its OK? If I tried that, I'd be investigated...

Simples...

[DancingQueen16]

I liked the thin mints and I actually used to be a girl scout in elementary school

[Mewzinc]

Was that fun? What did you guys do?

[exitseven]

They make these fudge filled cookies that I like.

[lottiebannotie]

Oooh the rara raisins look good I'm torn between them and the peanut butter

[PointTaken]

Samoas. I ordered like 6 boxes. Lol. But going to hand them to friends.

[CB-Raido-Time]

I was peanut butter coconut and mint. But I would never buy them again.

[Dinosaursandanime65]

I've never had any but that Thanks-A-Lot one looks pretty good.

[JustinTheGreat]

thin mints!

[douride2]

I never like those overpriced cookies.

[TenderFantasy]

Ok. You're missing out hehe.

[msc545]

Thin mints! Everyone loves them!

[clampfan101]

A and B.

[SnowedIn]

Thin Mints!

[call_me_scar]

Tagalongs

[shortster]

Thin mints

[Anonymous]

Samoas.