Which one is your favorite Girl Scout cookie?

[TrueConfection]

I know it's hard to choose. Comment your other favorites below. 😋

Shortbread

Peanut Butter Patties

Lemon

S'mores

Peanut Butter Sandwhich

Coconut Delights

Thin Mints

[ohshee]

If you like to make cookies I have something for you
Ok you can do this a few different ways depending how you like your crunch
Cup of peanut
Get some cream cheese frosting the blue cans the best
You have to mix it to your taste with the peanut butter
Smash up some Ritz crackers you can roll it into a ball or flattening out like a cookie dip it in melted chocolate
You can eat it just like that or you can put it in the oven on 350 melted down a little bit and then eat it I guarantee you can't have just one

[TrueConfection]

Can you chill them too?

[888theGreat]

Thin mints , better for kissy kissy after

[TrueConfection]

Excellent point! If I eat the whole box of Thin Mints without sharing, I'll just explain to my husband that I was thinking of him and wanted to freshen my breath. 😇

[888theGreat]

I am so helpful

[CrazyGirl2]

None of the above… I forget exactly what they are called. That are in a light blue box, they are like shortbread with bits of toffee in them, they are delicious. Im gonna remember this, as soon as i post it, but b/c because we can’t edit, I’ll have to look some looser next level inception thing

[TrueConfection]

Toffee-Tastic?

[CrazyGirl2]

YES! Thats IT!!! Wow, thank you I’ve been killing myself (figuratively) trying to remember, but yes… Toffee-Tastic! Best cookies on earth! I bought an entire case of them last year, I still have 2 boxes. But I never know when they are coming out, so I’m screwed!

[TrueConfection]

😂 GaG would only let me have 7 poll choices and so I cut Toffee-Tastic because they are fairly new I most people probably haven't had them.

Cookie-Time is officially Dec-Mar, but troops and girls are selling from Nov until after March (whenever they get rid of all their boxes). If you find a Girl Scout, you might be able to get more. They're sold online, but I wouldn't trust that unless they came from the Girl Scouts website.

[TrueConfection]

*and

[CrazyGirl2]

Well as long as they are the right retail price, then I'm okay. Nothing wrong with an ambitious young lady setting up an Amazon store to sell her cookies, rather than going door to door! I say good for her! Definitely a future leader if it was all her idea! But thanks so much, I ration them so strictly, when im down to a few boxes, my roommate hides them from me, so I'm accountable to someone for eating them! There is nothing wrong with a friend saying NO! You’ve already had 4 cookies, no more tonight! Then I say “please? Just one more, please I’ll do you dishes tomorrow? LOL 😂 anyway, thank you so much!

[TrueConfection]

Just be sure they're not counterfeit cookies. Amazon isn't always dependable.

Anyway, you're welcome! 😋

[dustybiker]

🤣

[TrueConfection]

I thought of that scene when I was making this poll. Figures you'd be the one to mention it! 😂😂😂 gmta

[dustybiker]

Yes, they do. 😎 Now I have to go listen to this theme song. lol

[dustybiker]

“Yes they do” what? I was not paying attention when I replied to this. I can’t figure out my own reply. lol sorry! 🤣 What was I smoking that morning? 🤪

[dustybiker]

Wait… can I blame the cookies? 😁

[TrueConfection]

🤦 gmta (the scene from Adams Family)

[dustybiker]

@TrueConfection 🤣

[dustybiker]

Thanks for the mhg.. 🥴

[meetkitty123]

I was torn between tagalongs or trefoils. We avoid peanut butter in my house due to allergies. Though I dont eat cookies so If I was actually buying a box Id go for thin mints. MY KIDS LOVE mint and chocolate... Not my fav but Thats perfect to buy and support the scouts because there will be no temptation to eat any on my part.

[crmoore]

First it was the Tagalongs, then it was the Samoas, now its definitely the Smores.

The Samoas and the Smores are really good, but now that I've tried them, the Tagalongs don't compete at all lol.

Though while I haven't tried them, I heard the new Oreo-like ones are really good.

[TrueConfection]

I haven't seen the Oreo type yet. Different areas have different cookies. I agree about the S'mores!

[dorksided1]

as much as i like peanutbutter anything, i have to go with samoas

[TrueConfection]

Those two are so hard to choose between. 😋

[dorksided1]

true !

[Bluemax]

Thin mints. Once I bought a box at the grocery store and I didn't even make it out of the parking lot before opening them.

[TrueConfection]

They are sooooo good.

[Lliam]

I would have said Samoas, but I never heard about the S'Mores ones and might like those better. I don't know. I also like Thin Mints.

[TrueConfection]

It's a tough choice! 😋

[anniisa97]

I'm British so never tried them but if I could pick one to try it would be Tagalongs. I love chocolate and peanut butter together

[anniisa97]

I do love shortbread but I've heard the ones we have here are more buttery so I don't feel the need to try that in the States

[TrueConfection]

Thin Mints are the classic, but Tagalogs sell just as well.

[zeitgeist057]

you can order an alcoholic beverage called a "Girl Scout Cookie" which is also quite good.

[TrueConfection]

@zeitgeist057 Wow! What's in that?

[zeitgeist057]

vodka, chocolate liqueur, creme de menthe, and baileys (Irish creme).

I also make it as a hot chocolate drink with peppermint schnapps and Irish creme. A little vodka too for extra kick.

[TrueConfection]

@zeitgeist057 I love Bailey's.

[anniisa97]

I dont drink lol

[TrueConfection]

Me either! 😋 But it sounds good!

[DizzyDesii]

Im not a cookie person but i had shortbread maybe twice in life and i remember how it melted in my mouth

[TrueConfection]

Those are awesome dipped in tea or coffee.

[DizzyDesii]

Oh nooo i can't rat something soggy lmao. I rather it just melt as i eat it haha

[TrueConfection]

I like soggy cookies. 😂😂😂

[LaFerrari]

Never had any official ones before, I’ve had knock off thin mints and the coconut delights from Keebler which I’m guessing are similar. Which one is your favorite?

[TrueConfection]

I didn't know there are knock-offs. 😂

Thin Mints are my favorite.

[t-8900]

Thin mints followed by Samoas, followed by tagalongs, followed by Dosidos, S'mores, then lemon ups

[TrueConfection]

That's almost my order of favorites. 😋

[Uptowngirl88]

I'm stuck between the lemon and trefoils. Are they still selling girl scout cookies?

[TrueConfection]

There are a few troops that still have cookies. You might find some if you ask around.

[exitseven]

I usually get the Trefoils. They used to have a fudge filled cookie that I really liked.

[TrueConfection]

They did change the cookies around. I miss the Thanks-A-Lots. They were my 2nd favorite.

[exitseven]

@TrueConfection I bet they are ten bucks a box now.

[TrueConfection]

$5 this year.

[exitseven]

THat isn't too bad. I think they were about that when my daughter was selling them and that was about ten years ago. I'll take 2 boxes please.

[TrueConfection]

I think you can order them online now.

[exitseven]

that takes all the fun out of it.

[TrueConfection]

True. Do you know anyone with possible Girl Scouts? They don't go door to door like they used to and the booths are done.

[Cubus]

We don't have girl scouts in my country. It's a very American thing I think.

[TrueConfection]

The only thing you're missing out on is the delicious cookies. 🙃

[PerfectDark_Joe]

I might go to hell for this, but I don't care for any of them.

[TrueConfection]

👿👿👿👿👿👿👿👿👿👿

[Echosoul]

*sends you to Hell* 😉

[Alwayreckles93]

Honestly I like all the cookies. But my most favorite is the peppermint.

[Miristheiss]

It is a tie between Thin Mints and Samoas. Since I could only vote for one I went with thin mints.

[AviatorTom]

I once ate two entire boxes of Thin Mints in one sitting. Tasted great, and gave me a headache. 😁

[MelissaMarie9614]

Samoas have always been my favorite. Also the smores one too.

[TyLeeAndPink]

What on earth happened to Savannah Smiles

[TrueConfection]

What are those?

[TyLeeAndPink]

They’re powdery lemon cookies from the Northwest. I don’t know if they’re still making them, but they’re WAY better than all the other lemon cookies they’ve come up with

[TrueConfection]

Ok, I haven't had those. Different councils have different bakers, so not all GS cookies are created equal. The lemon cookies in my area look different than the lemon cookies I polled.

[andreasderjuengere]

I haven't ever heard about ''Girl Scout Cookies'' :)
So I must assume that ''Girl Scouts'' in my own area feed on something different?

[TrueConfection]

Where are you?

[TrueConfection]

I mean country.

[andreasderjuengere]

As my profile says - I'm in Thailand.

[TrueConfection]

As your profile says? So the users that have Antarctica in the profile really live in Antarctica or are they the only ones who make something up? Why be rude?

[andreasderjuengere]

Nothing was meant to be rude here :) I just indicated that I DON'T make up my location.
As for ''Antarctica'' - to expose a liar usually will not solve a problem, but will add one, I think.
and isn't it better than not having one at all? ;)
...
so: the girl Scouts - this could be a ''local tradition''?
In my original area - Germany- 'scouts' didn't have their own cookies. I guess, they munch anything that they liked.

[Киттйлинк]

None. They always taste bad to me like sticky chewy.
I believe they should invest in making them better and healthier.