Search Results: nice guys always end up with mean girls

OK so I kinda have a huge crush on this guy in one of my classes. He has a really nice jawline, the coolest green eyes, a cute smile, and, best of all, he is the most genuine guy I've ever met.
Ok so here are some things that have happened with us:
+I don't really talk to him because he intimidates me but one time I wished him luck before a competition and he gave me this surprised look, smiled really genuinely, said thanks, and came over to where I was talking to my friend going to the same competition. We didn't talk more after that because people not going had to leave (I wasn't in it)
+When we have free time in class I'll be sitting somewhere with my friend and he'll always casually end up sitting close behind us with his friend
+I see him in the same hall almost everyday and sometimes I notice him looking my way. One of the first times I saw him he gave me this deer in the headlights look, not sure what that means
+He is friends with a lot of super nice and pretty girls though and I wouldn't be surprised if he likes one of them, he talks to them a lot and gave one a hug on her bday. My friend said they talk to him more than the other way but I think it's a mutual thing.
+He doesn't follow everyone back on Insta but when I requested he accepted and followed back almost immediately. My friend recently requested and he hasn't responded.
+I got put in a group with his friend but his friend barely talks to me/makes eye contact with me, he asked help from my crush the other day and my crush was talking to him (I couldn't hear what they were saying) and he looked right at me.
+I make contact with him at random times. (I don't catch him looking at me much though) Someone made a joke and I was laughing and then we made eye contact
+He holds doors for me and stuff but he's just that kind of a person
Thanks lovies :)