How free would citizens be if palestine was a muslim state?

[strateguy632]

i am NOT asking a cultural question instead to each reader: when you say, or write you want, free Palestinians what do YOU mean and what elaboration to these 2 vague words? do you want arabs in west bank to START being able to vote? they did vote already HAD elections for a palestinian government called p. a., that already existed so...

free from what? and exactly what CHANGE do YOU refer to? i expect many varied answers, from different perspectives and i wonder, which change will most repliers say?

[richardcory]

I want them to have self governance, not under the control of Israel. Freedom to trade with whomever they want (including weapons, and including Russia, Iran etc). Freedom to make treaties with whoever they want. Freedom to allow visitors from wherever they want. Ownership and control of their own lands, including the right to remove "settlers".

I want all this in a country whose borders include the resources (such as water) that give them the possibility of being independent.

OR I want israel to make them part of Israel with Palestinians having the right to vote in all elections, and complete legal equality.

I don't care whether or not they have a state religion.

[strateguy632]

try reading the questions, they ALREADY HAVE the p a. try again.

[richardcory]

The PA is under the control of Israel, and Israel will use military force when they deem it necessary, without any declaration of war. The PA is also not allowed to have an army or to purchase arms from other countries. In addition there are Israeli settlements in the palestinian territories in violation of PA laws.

[strateguy632]

you should stop believing disinformation. israel does not control p. a. policy, and if they did, they would coerce elections when abbas term ended. about israel military, that related to the undefined border. so no border yet. sad how people abandon rational for hate.

[ChiTown33]

Palestinians would find some other reason to hate the jews. Hatred of the Jews didn't begin with the modern state of Isreal.

You could remove every Isreali from Palestine and they'd still hate them.

[John_Doesnt]

There's not one single Muslim majority country that isn't a dump.

[richardcory]

Jordan is quite nice. Turkey isn't bad, though at the moment their leader is a problem. Indonesia is OK, though pretty poor.

[John_Doesnt]

@richardcory all poor countries with a dictator and they oppress non-believers. Muslims care about minority rights when they are the minority, but when they're the majority there is no minority.

[Anonymous]

Down with Israel! Go Palestine!

Catch this comment before it’s gone 😆

[strateguy632]

so it sounds like you are against israel , but still... which group of freedom fighters do you support , the one with goal for secular palestine? or the ones that want a muslim palestine? and if you say "free" palestine how free will people and lady be under a muslim governance.

[Opinion Owner]

I want the people of Palestine to worship whatever God they want and not have to be killed and murdered by Israelis.

[strateguy632]

you did not choose which goal? different groups different goals. about murdered, israelis do not go hunting arabs. israel needs self defense that is when people get shot. but i guess the jew victim is less value in your opinion. let the israeli get stabbed but israel not respond?