Could the thing that initiated the big bang exist without time, space and matter?

[Anonymous]

[ohsheeT]

I'm not sure but the way I remember is that this was filled with matter and when the Big bang happened it created time space another


Or maybe it was after the bang the thing created time space and matter it was just like a little ember little spark it just went bang so get a book of matches and strike it on the striker and watch that little dot just go all directions and explode into the air it is pretty interesting and at the same time look at all the things that scientists have gotten wrong and they're just finding out in our days a different story and it all makes sense it's very very interesting I know this we are probably the aliens we are all natural we can do things that we don't even know yet and it's all because of energy we are made of energy and energy can do anything everything and if you study that and study what we made out of and understand the possibilities and capabilities of yourself it is a very beautiful thing and when you're exploring this and you make things happen it becomes more interesting I've always known since I was very very young that we were this way and I have lived my life believing in certain things and they are now coming to the point where they are saying the same things that I believe it is just freaks me up because I have said it so many years people told me I was stupid and I said okay it's all right but it goes Way beyond My beliefs I just find little pieces here and there and the evidence that they come up with now is just unbelievable so cool but to answer your question I think it came after the bang I don't know but I do think that space was filled with matter like 13 billion years ago whatever and there was like a spark just doesn't something burning and then all the sudden it just went to boom

[jshm2]

There cannot be space, time or matter before the big bang, as such concepts can only exist after it.

Just like a "cake" doesn't exist, until all its ingredients are put in the oven, and cooked right.

This is why the Higgs Boson discovery is important as it shows that there is a "system" in place and it's not all "random".

[Asker]

So nothing initiated the Big bang?

[Nikki1989]

Some theories suggest that the universe may have existed in a different state before the Big Bang, perhaps in a state of quantum fluctuation. Others propose the idea of a multiverse, where our universe is just one of many. Of course, some nutters will always churn out the “it was god” myth.

[Jennz6]

It was God that made it happen

[Asker]

In all cases there was the very first thing that initiated everything.
So could anyverse whether multiverse or universe exist without time, space and matter?

[HighValue]

The James Webb telescope disproved the big bang theory. Plus by science's own rules that nothing can be created or destroyed, only change form (solid to gas, liquid to solid, etc) then the big bang lie was impossible from the beginning.

[Asker]

Yes it would mean it didn't have a begining

[Guanfei]

Time, space and matter are notions coming with the universe itself. Before that, it just wasn't there. What was there "before" existed because it was what made it.
Question is, what was it? And what made it? What was there before it?
It's hard to explain because the human mind isn't made to understand the concept of infinity.

[jahaims]

Space time is one thing. Matter cannot be created or destroyed. Something having a beginning or end is a man made concept. A lot of people just assume everything has a beginning and end because just about everything observable follows that pattern.

[Asker]

So matter existed outside time ad space?

[joehypo1]

No , the big bang is still happening so I have heard

[nawtee_me]

In the beginning God created heaven and earth. So yes God was there when there was nothing but void….

[AmeerX]

It was God, so yes they exist

[Grond21]

Logically it has to

[DJB72]

It's simple

[motownplayer2000]

You mean like… God?