1. No previous first love or romantic bonds, especially from youth
2. At least averagely attractive (she does not have to be a super model of course; a 5 or 6 will do)
3. Willing to pursue marriage and kids as an end goal (considers marriage and a family one day)
4. Loyal
5. Can fall in love and consumate a relationship (not aromantic or asexual)
... those are the big 5 for me
Otherwise, I am not that particular. I can find women of pretty much all races and ethnicities attractive, although, I am not into black women in general. I've hit on plenty of Asian and Hispanic girls in my lifetime. I've hit on Tom boys, girly girls, and nerdy girls too. Really, as a Christian myself, I should be seeking other Christian girls, but I don't set a hard deal breaker on it (as guilty as I feel saying that).