Girls, whom do you select out of these both guys?

Guy 1 - attractive, tall, cares for you, there for you always and ignores all other girls for you, have all the qualities that you desire in a guy
Guy 2 - tall, attractive, fails to express his care and love to you but he always does it silently, have all the qualities that you like in a guy but this guy will seem like distant but in reality he wants you more than you could ever imagine
Select gender and age to cast your vote:
Girls, whom do you select out of these both guys?
Post Opinion