On the list you have, Slenderman is the best option but my ultimate favourite is Midnight Man from the ritual game Midnight Game. It has an interesting origin. Midnight Game used to be a ritual forced upon those that broke pagan rules. The point is to invoke the Midnight Man and try to survive the night.
This is how it is done:
Players:
At least 1 principal
Requirements:
1 candle
1 lighter or book of matches
1 piece of paper
1 writing implement
1 pin
1 wooden door, closed
Salt
Instructions:
The Invitation:
Begin prior to midnight.
Write your full name – first, middle, and last – on the piece of paper with your writing implement. Prick your finger with the pin and squeeze until a drop of blood appears. Dot the blood on the paper and allow it to soak in.
Turn off every light in your home.
Place the paper with your name and blood on it in front of the closed wooden door. Light the candle using the matches or lighter and place it on top of the paper. If you are using a taper, make sure it is placed in a candle holder.
Knock on the door 22 times. The final knock must occur precisely when the clock chimes 12am. Open the door; then blow out the candle and close the door.
Relight your candle immediately.
The Main Event:
Keeping your candle in hand and your salt and matches or lighter close by, begin to move about your home.
Should your candle go out, you must relight it within the next ten seconds. If you are successful, continuing moving about your home. Do not stop moving until 3:33am.
If you are unsuccessful in relighting the candle, immediately surround yourself with a circle of salt. Remain inside the circle until 3:33am.
The Ending:
At 3:33am, it is safe to stop moving or to step outside your circle of salt. You may also turn on the lights. The game is over.
Most Helpful Opinions
Slenderman has a cult following, it's become a household name. It is no longer relegated to the internet. I don't know who any of these others are.
He is a a demon that takes the souls of children primarily for a reason I'm not sure of. He makes for great scare pranks.
Jane the killer looks sexy as hell. by the way, why do all these creepypastas look like emos?
Mr. Widemouth. That particular pasta has the subtlety of a brick through your windshield but I find something kind of lovable about it anyway.
Eyeless jack because I find the concept of stealing peoples kidneys kind of funny
What Girls & Guys Said
Opinion
14Opinion
i have never heard of these "Creepypasta Character" until now, but i will pick Jane The Killer because it's more of my preferred style of art when it comes to drawing and sketching pictures XD
Slenderman at least started off good. which I can't say for the rest of the options, but I also can't say that he's good anymore... so... none of them.
Ticci toby and clockwork tbh the only two main stream charters that i like and find there storys intresting and not dumb like jeffs or janes
I don't have a favorite character, but my favorite story is the one with the haunted house with 9 rooms that get creepier as you progress through them. No end house I think it's called
I like slender man and Jane the killer (the latter I don't know the story behind and just think is kinda pretty) but what I want to know is why no scps are on the list?
Probably slenderman as the lore behind the character is interesting
Weebs ruined creepypastas. I used to love reading scary stories until all the gay fan art came along.
Slenderman is legendary
Bob the Builder cuz he can build anything.
Jeff cuz he's hawt <3
Jeff the killer and Slenderman
Slender man since I have his costume
Never heard of it.
Ben drowned :3
Ähm what?
Jane because grill
Missingno
Other
he's a christian
Learn more
We're glad to see you liked this post.
You can also add your opinion below!
Most Helpful Opinions