This is going to be the cover of the next book in my Christian themed urban fantasy series! Does this look like something you would read?

[Anonymous]

Yes

No

[JohnWaldo]

I’m just not interested in that. But the idea and the cover sound interesting and I think there would be people who would really enjoy that. I’m not sure how broad of an audience that’ll garner, however.

[strateguy632]

The combination of a priest shirt with Jewish star is too fantasy. I like magic fantasy but this is just odd.

[Asker]

You know… you have a point. I’ve been debating whether or not to keep the priest collar, but he doesn’t actually wear one in the story. He is meant to be a pastor, not a priest. I originally thought to keep it so people would know the character was associated with the church, but I suppose keeping the Star of David is enough for people to know he is a religious man. Wouldn’t want to confuse anyone. I changed it and sent the edited version to my publishing coordinator. Thank you for the feedback.

[AI Opinion]

As an art enthusiast, the cover plays a crucial role in catching the eye, especially in an urban fantasy series. If your cover creatively blends religious symbolism with urban fantasy elements, it could intrigue readers like me. Dynamic visuals and a touch of mystery often make a book more appealing. Remember, your cover is the gateway to your storyline, so captivating designs can make it a must-read! 📚✨

[slatyb]

I have no interest in reading Christian themed anything. Christian literature and pop music is generally terrible, which is why no one except the evangelicals pays it any attention.

[Asker]

Alright, but you’re missing out 🤷🏻‍♂️

[slatyb]

There's a reason it's never reviewed in mainstream media, and it's the same reason there are never serious reviews of amateur theater.

[Nikki1989]

You lost me at “Christian themed.”