Are these custom legendary MTG wizards broken in Commander or Modern?

[SeekerOfTruth007]

Rugas Eroz RBU

Legendary Creature - Wizard - Rare

When you cast your third spell each turn, draw a card, then Recruit (Draw another card, then discard a card, then create a 1/1 Blue Wizard creature token.)

3/4

===

Ispep Odas BUW

Legendary Creature - Wizard - Rare

When you draw your third card each turn, and each draw after that, Manifest the top card of your Library.

3/4

===

Aria Star, Miracle Summoner RGW

Legendary Creature - Wizard - Rare

RGW: Reveal cards from the top of your Library until you reveal a Creature card. Put that card onto the Battlefield and the remaining cards back on bottom of your Library.

3/4

[AI Opinion]

Nice designs! 😄

Rugas Eroz feels strong but fair in Commander. Three spells a turn already means you’re set up; the reward is gas but not game‑breaking compared to stuff like Aetherflux or Storm payoffs.

Ispep Odas is the scariest. Repeated manifest on your third+ draw each turn with wheels or big draw engines can flood the board fast. I’d add a “this triggers only once each turn” or “only on your turn” clause.

Aria Star is undercosted. A repeatable, instant‑speed, untyped creature tutor/cheat for just RGW is far stronger than cards like Mayael or Eladamri’s Call. I’d either make it 3RGW, tap and sorcery‑speed, or put a mana‑value cap on the creature.

So: Rugas is fine, Ispep and especially Aria need a safety tweak for both Commander and Modern. 🎨🧙‍♂️

[SeekerOfTruth007]

I think the first one is fine, but you play it with a lot of flashback spells or fat creatures with some animate spells.

The second and third one both favor large creatures in your deck, since you're allowed to turn a permanent face-up for its mana cost if it is Manifested.

The third one is supposed to be slightly OP. I don't want it to be a tap ability. It takes a lot of work to get the mana to spam the ability more than once per turn, so I don't think it's too OP.

[SeekerOfTruth007]

What I've done is a limited the second Legend's abiilty to only the 3rd and 4th card per turn.

Then I gave Aria Star a drawback: You can't cast Creature spells from your hand unless you activate the other ability at least twice per turn. This way, casting from the hand will become a huge disadvantage.