Or is the look too simple / minimal?
Just a nice black top paired with baby blue jeans and either sneakers, boots or mid high heels.
I'd add:
+ some delicate accessories (earrings, necklace)
+ belt (maybe), a shoulder bag
+ simple mani, nothing extragavant
+ natural to minimal makeup (just an eyeliner and a touch of lipstick for me personally, I like to stay true to my original form lmao)
Let's say the date is not happening in winter lol... think spring/summer