I know that there are many other factors involved: personality, facial attractiveness, how they treat you, etc. But just assume everything else is equal...what would you prefer? I ask because I'm the tall/skinny guy and my roommate is short but more muscled and ripped. I'm 6'4 170 with good abs but not really muscled at all. He is only 5'5 or 5'6 but has a much more muscular build. We're a lot alike other than that but I'll admit he gets much more 'female attention'.
Most Helpful Girl
I'll say short and ripped. I'm 5'11 and thin so it may sound strange, but I was friends with a guy who was about 5'7 and ripped and I was teasing him about his height and the fact I was a lot taller than him. So we started wrestling around and he scooped me up and threw me over his shoulder like I was a feather. I have to say that was a big turn-on and made me feel very feminine, even with the height difference. Ever since then I've had a thing for the shorter, muscled guys.
One disclaimer: when I say muscular I mean more of the lean muscular type as opposed to the bodybuilder type.0