+1 yIf I'm going to be interested in a guy, he has to not be unattractive. That means he could be anywhere from average to drop-dead gorgeous. Obviously, a hot guy initially catches a girl's eye more than an average guy, but I honestly am more interested in personality. Often I go for average guys who have personalities that I really like... and then for some reason I perceive them as physically more attractive, the more I know their personality. So looks are, at least to some extent, subjective and influenced by overall personality.
In your example, I would definitely pick the guy who is not as hot, but has a better personality.
In terms of flirting, I am more likely to flirt with a hot guy than an "average" guy. But that's not as bad as it sounds. Usually, the guys I really like and am serious about are the ones with a great personality... and that's something that you only find out after you know the person for a while. So usually what happens is that I start falling for a guy friend... but by that time he's my friend and I don't want to lose him, so I don't flirt with him because I don't want to make life awkward... but I'm usually more attracted to them (at least on a deeper level) than I am to the guys I flirt with... if that makes any sense.20 Reply
Most Helpful Opinions
Although a good looking guy would cause me to turn my head, if he was a totall ass, I wouldn't want anything to do with him. There is nothing I can't stand more than a conceited arogant man. Before I got with my current boyfriend, who isn't blessed with looks, I was stuck between him and another guy who was much more attractive physically. The reason that I picked my boyfriend was because he was smart, cared for his education, quiet, loyal to past girlfriends, funny, and laid back. The other guy, although attractive, was arrogant, loud, overly flirtatious, and not so loyal to past girlfriends. And besides, when you grow to like someone, they always end up being much more attractive to you than the first time that you laid eyes on them. :) I hope this helped.
70 Reply
+1 yOf course. My brother's a pretty good-looking guy, and I'm sometimes shocked by how bold girls get with him. Bold for girls, I mean.
Speaking for myself, I do act differently with a guy I'm attracted to vs a guy I'm not. I'm nice and respectful to everyone, but I wouldn't flirt with a guy I'm not at least a little attracted to. I think that's only natural.
Looks do matter, they're just not the only thing that matters. I've also been in situations where a guy was definitely objectively attractive, but I felt zero chemistry with him. Or he has a personality really incompatible with mine, etc.91 Reply
+1 ywell for me, appearance does have importance but I care much much more if the person is nice. I would much rather date someone that is not as good looking but is loving and friendly because really what is the benefit of being with someone that is extremely hot/hansome but is rude and disrespectful? its not like I would want a "trophy" to just be showing off to people.. I want someone who I can rely on and share amazing moments with. and its actually easier for me to talk and approach someone who is not crazily good-looking yet they are a super nice person and still fine looking.
00 Reply
+1 yWell bro here's another dudes opinion:
When i was in high school i only dated 2 girls and that was because i was a musician it was during the dating that they opened up to like my personality. Now in college its another story after i gained some pounds and was 210lb, I hardly ever got a girl to like me. Now that im in the US AirForce and i went down to a 155lb abs and muscles guy the scales tiped around and its quite annoying really because the girls i meet only like me for my body and not my adventuruous half italian half brazilian bassist personality.
It really depends on the girls that you meet in or around your area as well as the ones that you will meet along the way.
Hope this helps fellow dude30 Reply
+1 yOf course it does. Women are drawn to attractive men much the same way we are more drawn to attractive women.
However I have seen some pretty homely guys get some fairly good looking women. Because deep down a woman knows it's what in a man's character that matters more than his face. His character protects her, loves her, keeps her safe. Not his face or body.
If only more men would realize that about women. Except instead of character, he should be looking at her heart (And yeah, also character).00 Reply
What Girls & Guys Said
Opinion
15Opinion
+1 yI will obviously react differently. Chances are that at first I'll be physically more attracted to the handsome man.
Though, in the end charms is what matters to me.
I remember a time when I had more SwB with men, I was not exclusive the men new it and it was easy to compare. For exemple, there were two men. One was really good looking and turned out to be awful in bed because he was extremely selfish, his personality turned out to be a disaster, it's just my worse memory when it comes to men.
Whereas the other man was less good looking, he was really average but he was extremely nice, fun, I saw him many times and the sex was amazing which made him hot in my eyes
So, yes, I need to be attracted to a man, it's obvious but charms is definitely the key to me.20 ReplyObviously i gotta be honest here, i do feel more intimidated to a guy who is super duper hot and has a chizzled modle look. But that is also more based on attitude too. If a guy comes off as super confident and looks hot too, i'de be like woah look at him but if a guy is more relaxed and friendly or even on the funny side, i would feel more comfortable and he would be easy to talk to. This is weather he is really physically attractive to me or not. So i guess i just go off of the vibe he is giving me. I personally would not be attracted to a guy just by lookin at him. I would deffinantly pick a nice guy over a hot guy.
20 ReplyOnce a bunch of my bfs friends were coming out to meet us at a sports bar. Some I had met... others I hadn't. We held a table for about two hours for all of them. The place was packed and people came up to us every 5 minutes to see if anyone was sitting there. I was feeling really bad about turning all those people away. Well, the friends showed up. Everyone introduced themself, except one girl. I introduced myself to her, but I could tell she was completely reluctant. Well, she started yelling at all the friends that sat down with us to move over to this other table that just opened up. There wasn't enough room for everyone there. She kept pointing at people at the table (singling them out) to "get over there." She was persistent for a while and gave up on a few that didn't move. I wasn't one she told to move over there and she became increasingly frustrated at those who didn't. That was my most recent episode.
11 Reply- +1 y
Sorry, thought you were initially talking about girls vs girls. Not that I think I'm attractive, but this was how I was treated by another girl. Misinterpreted your question.
Yes, initial attraction is a must! I think some girls might be more initimidated by hotter guys or hold them on a pedostol. They might do things to try and keep them more than they would an average looking guy.
Anonymous(36-45)+1 yYes appearances matter. Girls are just like guys, we noticed the hot dude with tats and muscles and concoct fantasies about him deeply falling in love with us.
Does that mean we want to pursue a relationship with him?
The difference i think is that women are raised to restrain their impulses unlike men who are taught to embrace them. Boys will be boys is such a common saying and so many people believe it, cause you know all that testosterone is a bitch to control so why even bother?
Women on the other hand are pretty much raised to keep it in their pants or else you be a slut. So girls have a different outlook on relationships, which means that although the dude is hot we can resist if he seems like trouble. Everyone's definition of trouble will vary obviously, and with age and experience i feel like men start to be more selective... But just in general you know.30 Reply
+1 yOf corse a girl might like you more for the way you look, it's exactly the same as a boy would like a girl for the way she looks. It has a huge impact. Yet, for me looks aren't everything, I've dated some really sweet guys that aren't that good looking, and I don't regret it one bit. If a girl just judges you on your looks, she's shallow and a bitch.
10 ReplyI would say personality wins every time. Looks and sexiness are subjective. However, there has to be some sort of chemistry for things to last. Wealth and power can play a part in making a person appear 'sexy and attractive'. Ever wonder why you see young, attractive women with older, not so attractive men? Not saying that I would be as shallow, but do you those same women would be with that guy if he was penniless?
10 ReplyOh most definitely. Looks mean EVERYTHING plus a great personality that's a huge bonus. If you're a sexy guy lets say age 15-24 I'm going to flirt with you. It doesn't matter to me if you have a girlfriend or not I'm gonna have to scoop you up for a few minutes. Now if you are ugly but you're a nice guy then you will be forever in the friendzone but if you're sexy and nice... oh hell yes that ass is mine.
21 Reply
+1 yUGH well yor definition of sexy could be different from mines, some girls may think guys from one direction are hot while I like korean guy bands etc. So you can't really put labels on anyone but in a way yes but it depends on the girl, I personally wouldn't approach a sexy/hot guy I probably would never talk to him. But a guy that I see as good looking/ average I'll be warm to because their not as intimidating.
10 Reply
+1 yI ask my gf why she likes me at first she said your personality. Then later on I ask so looks don't matter to you and she responded of course you are attractive that's what caught my eye at first. Yes looks do matter for example, I ask her to show me one of her ex she said no he's ugly and I'm ashamed...
10 Reply
+1 yOh, this is easy for me. I won't say looks don't matter- they do a little bit, though not much. I've been told that guys I find attractive aren't what other people consider hot cute or attractive. Personally, personality is what attracts me to people. If you have a mean or an arrogant streak like you said, i will go for the less attractive, friendly guy in a heartbeat. If you don't have the personality, you aren't worth my time.
10 ReplyIf you're my friend then I can be comfortable to you. I mean, I can put my arms around your shoulder or fool with you, but if you are my friend and someone that I like, I can be aloof coz I dont want you to know that I have feelings for you. But in another case, if there is someone I like, ike cute guy, and we're not friends, I can be flirtatious to him.
10 ReplyPut it this way; a girl is getting robbed in the streets. And a (not so handsome dude) kicks their asses and saves you, and the girl is like super hot. She will adore you and will probably want to be with you. Where as if your just a average guy who wants to take a chance with the Same girl then nothing will probably happen. You see where I'm going through this...
10 Reply
+1 yLooks are important yeah, but I can't tell you the number of times I've talked to a really attractive guy, and that once he started talking I was instantly put off by his awful personality (being mean to others, etc..) Basically I would pick an attractive guy with a good personality over an abercrombie model with a bad personality...
00 ReplyWell for me looks do matter because there's that initial attraction which will then act as a catalyst to a developing relationship be it romantic or not. But then again, there are other aspects of a person which do matter greatly although the looks can not be over shadowed
00 Reply
+1 yYeah, it definitely has an impact, but only for flirting, making out, and hooking up. It has much less of an impact for a real relationship. I definitely think girls act differently towards hot guys because they're, well, hot. But also hot guys sometimes aren't trusted as much, and girls can easily get too nervous around them.
02 Reply- +1 y
Lol I don't know about you, but "flirting, making out, and hooking up" sound way better than a real relationship.
- +1 y
Id disagree with you spartan, to each their own.
+1 yIf a guy is average-ugly but he's confident & his personality is awesome, & he knows how to build stuff/ houses id like him especially if he's funny and has a nice smile... And he has to be fit but I don't mind if his face is not that attractive as long as he has the attributes i listed hot guys aren't all that... Vin diesel and Adam Sandler fit the UGLY (because they're very old now) BUT SEXY CATEGORY... The guy I like is a bald PuertoRican ginger
20 Reply- 382 opinions shared on Girl's Behavior topic.
+1 yDuh. Girls typically treat good looking guys better. Just like how guys treat good looking girls better.
91 Reply
Anonymous(45 Plus)+1 yI have dated some very hot guys. None of those relationships lasted very long because they were conceited and inconsiderate. I flirt with lots of guys throughout the day, most of them average looking, and it's their personality and sense of humor that sets some of them apart for me. I think I am equal opportunity flirter to begin with, regardless of looks. Their responses are what determine I'd I take it one step farther. Chemistry is next on the list...
20 Reply
Anonymous(36-45)+1 yYea, but sometimes they get treated worse because of it. Like girls think they expect special treatment so make a point of treating them lower. Or They get turned down for dates sometimes, because people won't trust a guy who's too hot sometimes.
Sometimes though (more often than not) they're treated like kings.10 ReplyI think everyone acts differently with someone who is visually appealing, I mean looks are the first thing you notice about a person and is what's going to draw you in most of the time, but personality is what keeps you drawn in.
I've never been in a relationship so i don't have that much insight on this subject.00 Reply
+1 yYes they do. For me sometimes girls don't even want to talk to me and completely change demeanor. It's strange sometimes I feel like they don't like me. But I've had many people tell me I'm handsome out do the blue. I even had this women once at penn station randomly walk up to me and call me a papi chulo she was white I'm latino. It was weird
20 ReplyBlasphemy. Not saying I'm any of the forementioned positive looking names here. But I feel like most girls I'd see when I went out would look at me with a "why is he looking at me?" face. Or like they're mad at me for some reason.
20 Reply
Anonymous(25-29)+1 yObviously, a girl will treat an attractive guy differently because deep down (or not so deep) she wants to suck his dick. people react to attractiveness, that's life..
70 Reply
+1 yYea typically we treat the hotter looking guys as someone we flirt with and/or wouldn't mind a relationship with where as the not so good looking ones tend to be friendzoned
30 Reply
Anonymous(25-29)+1 yIf a guy is cute and attractive then I'd have more courage to talk to him and be myself
If he's sexy/ hot I'd be too scared to even look at him and if he talks to me I'd get nervous60 Reply
+1 ywhen girls say guys are good-looking, sexy etc etc, that just means we like guys who can take care of themselves :) but yes, guys who do are viewed as sexy etc. thats just my opinion!
10 Reply
+1 ywell yeah im gonna flirt more with a fine guy and more than likely hook up with him easier than I would with a guy that I wasn't as attracted to
10 Reply
+1 yGirls hop into bed with me str8 away, but you will get to wine and dine them and treat them like a princess, and also the anticipation of waiting 6 months to get laid.
21 Reply- +1 y
I ain't even mad bro that's all most woman are good for anyway heh.
- 535 opinions shared on Girl's Behavior topic.
+1 y... Duh.
The subconscious assumption is that the better someone looks, the better person they are.11 Reply Of course. I used to work in a department store with this kid, he was good-looking apparently. The girls who worked at the chocolates counter used to give him free chocolates. They never gave me any free chocolates. Skanks.
10 ReplyLooks matter yes! Every one had a personal preference though. If a girl is not stupid she would choose the hottie with the good personality.
20 ReplyYes. Im one of the best looking guys in my highschool and trust me they treat you differently, but in a good way.
00 Reply
+1 yBro what ever they say... it makes a world of difference.
10 Reply
Anonymous(30-35)+1 y32 Reply- +1 y
Haha wow I just died laughing but it's so true!
+1 yI would definitely take the less attractive man because in the long run which is more important you looking happy or feeling happy?
10 ReplyThey smile and giggle more if they find u attractive
00 Reply
+1 ywell obviously. that's why girls avoid me like the plague because I'm not good looking
12 Reply- +1 y
yep feelsbadman
Anonymous(36-45)+1 yno not for me. i dont act differently just because someone fits within the social construct of "good looking".
20 Reply#PrettyPeopleProblems
Soo troublesome30 Reply325 opinions shared on Girl's Behavior topic. Good looking people get better breaks.
00 Reply
Anonymous(30-35)+1 yDeep down yes we do...
10 ReplyI just be myself
10 Reply
Girls, do you act differently around very attractive guys?
Learn more
We're glad to see you liked this post.
You can also add your opinion below!
Girl's Behavior
Guy's Behavior
Flirting
Dating
Relationships
Fashion & Beauty
Health & Fitness
Marriage & Weddings
Shopping & Gifts
Technology & Internet
Break Up & Divorce
Education & Career
Entertainment & Arts
Family & Friends
Food & Beverage
Hobbies & Leisure
Other
Religion & Spirituality
Society & Politics
Sports
Travel
Trending & News
Most Helpful Opinions