Who would win in a fight, a transgender girl or a cisgender girl?

[Anonymous]

The question speaks for itself lol. Who would win in a fight? Everything goes, attacks in the groin, dirty fighting, etc.

[jshm2]

Well... a trans who has not fully frankensteined, will still have his testicles. Not much of a fight.

But on the other hand, a trans will still have the male testosterone levels. It'll come down to fight experience, I suppose.

The trans will have slapped around a lot more women than the cis. The trans would likely win in that regard.

[Asker]

That makes sense

[Astarlessnightsky]

The one with the most combat experience and martial arts training.

[Anonymous]

The trans girl, easily. It would be more of a fair fight if the trans girl is on estrogen, but I’d still give it to the trans girl.

[Asker]

Perhaps. There does seem to be arguments for both sides here

[Opinion Owner]

I don’t know, I’ve fought guys and girls before. There are differences in strength, speed, size, even the structure of your body regarding shoulder and hip width. I mean most guys could probably floor most girls with a body shot. I like to think that I can hold my own against a good portion of men, but I doubt anyone would be able to beat me had I been born male.

[Asker]

Yeah, I get it. To make it fair, I'd assume the trans girl is transitioned. In which case, muscle wise, they would be similar, but the trans girl would still have size, height, shoulder broadness. They would have reaction speed. However, an advantage females do have, and that the cis girl would have is more muscle endurance, so muscles that would last longer. And we're also assuming bottom surgery has not been done, so the trans girl would still have balls which could be attacked and would be more vulnerable than that cis girl's parts.

[Opinion Owner]

I wouldn’t be so sure about that. Look at any endurance sport record. I’m fairly certain only sport with a female record holder is ultra endurance swimming, specifically swimming across the English Channel. That favors women due to our less dense bones and higher body fat/lower muscle mass which helps with insulation and buoyancy. The endurance difference is smaller than the explosiveness difference between men and women, but it still exists in men’s favor. Even if it didn’t, I’d bet on an explosive athlete over an endurance athlete in a fight any day, because a fight isn’t likely to last for more than two minutes. And as far as the vulnerability, you really have to consider that on a case by case basis. I’ve kneed a lot of people down there, both accidentally and intentionally. Girls react the same way guys do for the most part. I’m sure it hurts guys slightly more, but in the context of a fight, being floored for 5 minutes is the same as being floored for 15. so the difference in groin vulnerability likely won’t be a significant factor. What would be a significant factor is the vulnerability of the chest, because that weakness is entirely absent in men. That’s not to say that a person born male will beat a person born female in all cases. I’ve had a lot of string bean looking guys say they could beat me just because I’m a girl when my benchpress is probably almost double theirs.

[Opinion Owner]

The bottom line is that it’s certainly possible for a cis woman to win... but if all else is equal, it’s unlikely

[Asker]

If the trans girl is one estrogen and had top surgery, she would have the chest vulnerability. I do get your point though

[Opinion Owner]

You’re right, I didn’t consider that. The way that trans women who just underwent top surgery describe chest pain isn’t all that different from the way it feels to get hit there while still developing

[Asker]

How much do you believe that would tip this fight?

[Opinion Owner]

Well it would remove the weakness of the chest as a factor, but I still think the bone structure, bone density, and muscular differences would make all the difference.

[Asker]

That makes sense. When it comes to the groin, isn't it as painful, but just harder to hit the cis girl's spot? In all honesty though, it would be hard to hit the trans girl's balls though since she'd be on estrogen, and they'd be smaller

[Anonymous]

Depends on there fighting experience but probably the transgender women, since they usually still have more strengh then most women.

[In_Trance]

The first person that get's kicked in the balls will lose. Their made up gender won't help them

[Asker]

So would a girl beat a guy then?

[In_Trance]

Depends on the course of the fight. If the guy lands first, chances are she'll lose

[boggboss]

Are they trained to fight?

[Asker]

This is assuming who'd win on average. There are different levels of training, but this is just assuming they are equally trained

[boggboss]

More likely then not the trans then if they still have the muscle mass of a average guy

[Browneye57]

Under 18? Ask your mommy.

[Asker]

63? Tell your jokes to your family and think you're hilarious as everyone reluctantly laughs

[Browneye57]

Open your mouth and prove just how fukkin dumb you really are.

[harry7825]

Why they wants to fight

[Asker]

It's just a theoretical question lol