Do girls want men that other girls want?

I am a bouncer who kissed 5 girls in one-night, all who approached me - they took my number down but then when I texted them each a couple days after, I didn't hear a response from ANY of them. Though I am not sure, lets assume they all talked to each other about me kissing each of them or other women. What's the big deal?
Do girls want men that other girls want?
Post Opinion