How would a guy react if he finds out the girl that hated him during childhood always liked/loved him?

[Anonymous]

While it was exactly bullying, I was simply not friendly, gave him an attitude and sometimes made excuses to criticize his clothes or hair. I pretended to exclude him once from a research project. This went on from ages 9-13.

He asked me once ''why are you so angry, why you hate you''? I replied with an ''Shut up idiot. Does it look like I want to speak with you?''. In my private moments without anyone looking, I used to smile.

Eventually I grew out of that phase and we're going to be in our last year of HS after summer ends. We're friends now but I accidentally left my private journal at his house not so long ago and he returned it the next day. For sure he read it all or some of it. Guys how would you react if the girl you thought hated you... actually always had a crush on you?

Updates

1 y

The thing is he had a smile when he returned my journal. Now I can't hide the secret anymore.

[Curmudgeon]

It would confirm to him what he should already know: Females are Crazy. :D

On the other hand, if you are attractive enough...

[Asker]

The secret is finally out. He found my journal (I accidentally left it at his house) and returned it the following day with a smile. I think he must be somewhat surprised. I don't know.

[Curmudgeon]

Well, do you REALLY want him?

[Asker]

yes I do, always did

[Curmudgeon]

Well, he has been socialized to be afraid of you, or is now confused, so you might have to make some more effort, a la Bumble. Do they still have "Sadie Hawkins Dances"? Or am I betraying my age? Or you could just ask him to go someplace like the mall with you, or am I betraying my age there too? :D

[Asker]

Good point. Yeah he's probably confused at this moment. Thanks

[Pyrofox]

I'd be so confused if yo came up to me and confessed. I'm not sure I'd accept the confession. Just based on PTSD stuff.

[Asker]

I didn't confess. He found out when I accidentally left my journal. As my update says, he had a smile when he returned it the following day. He knows it. I can't hide it anymore.

[Pyrofox]

Just ask him out XD.

[Asker]

yeah I guess so

[Pyrofox]

Or... You leave your self vulnerable for him to just beat you too it which would be even more embarrassing XD.

[RedStealthOperative]

She would have to be the opposite of how she used to be for me to even consider any possibility of us being together.

[Asker]

I didn't want him nor anyone at school to know at that time so I would pretend to not to like him. Now the secret is out because I accidentally left my journal at his house. Then he returned it to me the next day but had a smile.
I never would imagine he found find out. The secret is out now.

[RedStealthOperative]

Maybe he might reciprocate the same feelings if you are much nicer to him and you both have fun together.

[Asker]

As mentioned I've grown out of the ''being mean, teasing'' phase. We're friends now but yes I'll start showing more of my soft side. Good point. Thanks.

[Anonymous]

What the fuck is wrong with you?

[Asker]

I was too embarrassed at the time and just didn't want him nor anyone else at school to know it. That's why I would act mean, to cover my soft side and my true feelings for him.

[Asker]

He smiled when he returned back my journal the next day but said nothing about it. I guess it's likely he's confused right now.