First of all I'd like to clarify that I don't believe in any racial theories and despise Hitler and his ideas. But I just want to figure out the truth about South Europeans and their intolerance towards migrants.
Latin Americans are often classified as Hispanic and not White, but what about Spaniards and Italians? They have the same phenotype as most Latin Americans!
Here we can see that Italians have a substantial West Asian admixture. Wow, just look a that, Italians and Spaniards have the same Red sea admixture as Syrians and Turks! They are genetically close to Arabs and Berbers! Spaniards and Sicilians even have African admixture in them.
Let's take a look at some typical Italians and Spaniards. Italians: If this guy had no flag I'd think he is African American actually. Spaniards:
Before asking this question I thought that Italians were whiter than Spaniards, because Spain was ruled by Africans for several centuries. But they instead turned out to be darker than Spaniards. They don't resemble Romans at all! Augustus Roman dictator Sulla
So what happened to them? Are the Italians and Spaniards really descendants of slaves and muslims and not Celts and Romans? Why are they then so intolerant towards migrants if they don't differ from them?
Like Kkaos said, white and black isn't really a race as it is increeeedibly broad when you think about the variations of skin colours, bone structures and hair and eye colours there are among them. Europeans from around the Mediterranean are historically mixed. Many of them have had Celtic and Roman and Greek history. The thing is though that Roman Empire stretched all the way to the Middle East so it's no surprise they've had some kind of mixing going on, exactly the same thing why you might find blondes and blue eyed people in Turkey. These people have for a long time been involved with the other countries along the coast of the Mediterranean Sea so of course some of them might look similar to berbers or middle easterners at times. And Muslims did rule Spain, Sicily, Greece to Albania and few other Eastern European countries for many centuries. To me it's pretty easy to tell if someone is Spanish/Greek/Italian because to me they don't generally look like the average Swede or Northern European. Europeans really don't look the same lol, I don't know where people get that from.
The one after the soccer player is Diego he is Gitano ( Spanish gypsy) who is a flamenco artist. Gypsies are middle eastern, indian and european. You need to educate yourself a lot if you think that soccer player looks black What existed in south America before the european colonies? Indians whom originally came from asia. The europeans brought over slaves black and gypsy. So how would hispanics be white? Most of the hispanic culture is influenced directly by African culture.
But in the end of the day race isn't real. We are just humans with mixed ethnics that practice a particular culture.
UMMMMMM LETS NOT BE SO IGNORANT WE DO NOT HAVE A TANNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN! ITALIANS ARE UNDER NO CIRCUMSTANCES WHITE ONLY IN AMERICA DO YOU FOLKS CLAIM TO BE CAUCAUSIAN WE ARE PROUDLY MEDITERANEANS WE DO NOT CLAIM ANY OF YOU CAUCASIANS HERE! IN FACT THE ONLY ONES THAT LOOK CAUCUS ARE THE NORTHERNERS BECAUSE THEY MIX WITH AUSTRALIANS & TURKS. THEY HAVE BLOND HAIR ETC. HERE IN ITALY WE ARE 100 PERCENT MEDITERANEAN, OUR GOV WANTS TO CLAIM WHITE PRIVLEDE BUT WE ARE NOT WHITE NOR DO WE HAVE A TAN MISS GENIOUSITY.. WE ARE NATURALLY BORN WITH BROWN OR TAN COLORED SKIN BECAUSE OF OUR DNA - IF YOU HAVE NO IDEA ABOUT REAL ITALY OR OUR CULTURE OR EVER BNEEN HERE PLS SHUT UP IT IS A GRAVE INSULT TO ASSOCIATE US WITH THE WHITES AFTER THE DISCRIMIATION YOUR COUNTRY PUT OUR MEN through WHEN THE MIGRATED TO YOUR COUNTRY. AMERICA IS NOT SO GREAT AND U FOLKS NO NOTHING ABOUT OUR COUNTRY... WE DO NOT CLAIM TO BE WHITE, SOME OF OUR SKINS ARE FAIR, BUT WE ARE STILL PROUD MEDITERANEANS AND WILL ALWAYS BE BY THE WAY NOT ONE OF THESE ITALIANS EVEN THE BLONDIES WILL ESCAPE HAVING African American, SYRIAN, ARAB OR MIDDLE EAST IN THEIR BLOOD, WE ARE NOT WHITE WE ARE A MEDITERANEAN RACE AND WE ARE ONE PROUDLY !
I was thinking the same thing with regards to the Greeks & Portuguese... Some people say they aren't white? They say most have Turkish genetics. It would be interesting to know, but really, all races are mixed breeds by now.
Portuguese people seem to be genetically identical to Spaniards. Greeks look like them too, and they both have some Non-European blood in them. Greece had a lot of slaves in the Ancient times, like Rome.
the answer would be yes. I think Turkish are also caucasian. the mediterranean race which a subgroup of the white or caucasian race, I think is further subdivided , for example european mediterranean are slightly lighter skin dark hair and sometimes have dark brown hair, Middle eastern and northafrican mediteranean have sometimes slightly brown skin. But the correct term is caucasian instead of just white, the craneal features determine the race more than the skin color
You do know that Hispanic is an ethnicity and not a race, right? Most Hispanics are either white, or mestizo (white + native American).
Besides that, most from the Mediterranean area are mixed with a LOT, cause that area has seen more trading and people coming through than any other place in the world. But mostly, Spaniards and Italians are mostly white.
http ://i. im gur. com/riJLc2O. png According to this map there are few Spaniards and Italians with blue eyes, and even less with blond hair. So I guess their average appearance is like that of the guys in my post.
No xD Most Spanish people don't look like those two guys, especially the first one. Like another person told you, he's not ethnically Spanish, he was born there, but his blood is not from there.
Ummβ¦ Iβve literally been to Spain before thereβs nothing but Caucasians there, nothing like the people you posted on your posts Those people probably do have Spanish nationality, but are of Moroccan or other Arab African country descend
to be honest we had ethnic mixes since the roman empire. if you go in the North you have german/celtic descendands looking italians and if you go South they look more arabic than anything. culture wise is the same thing
i'll speak for myself tho, i dont even look like these two types! lol
Spain, eh, hard to say but hell i do have a thing for Spanish girls :3
White isn't actually a proper race, same applies to black.. It's just colors. However Italians and Spaniards are definitely the same race as English for example, they're all European. The real thing that distinguishes races isn't skin color, but bone structure etc... Otherwise people would change race every time they got a tan. Northern Italians are generally fairly light skinned, whereas southern Italians can be much darker, they're still Italian, they're still European... It doesn't mean they're different races.
The European race thing is kinda bull because Europe is and always has been a hot pot different nations and people warring with each other, taking each others land, breeding with each other and migrating in huge numbers. Like Spain and scilly was once full of moors and saracans, Italy was once invaded and settled by the lombards a barbarian nation chased west by the huns/mongols with all the other barbarian nations. Look at celtic England invaded by the Romans, then the Saxons, at one time the Irish, the vikings, the normans and now immigrants from every corner of the world. To say someone from Europe is white is far to vague.
The way that the west classify human beings more likely depends on how civilized, rich, developed the ethnicity is, and how close their ideology, culture, language to the west. Features and akin color does not matter so much as most people think.
Funny fact: The definition of white in the US has been changing and relational.
For instance, Finns and Slavs weren't considered white in their early immigration laws. And people in Middle ages counted Chinese people as white before Mongolian invasions ( ´βο½).
lots of Italians and Spanish people definitely share the same genetic roots with the middle Eastern countries nearby. But most western people still don't consider these middle Eastern countries white lol.
Italians probably do have some genetics of Middle Eastern countries, Spain in other hand doesnβt. Spain is of Roman and Celtic descent the Moors occupation in southern Spain didnβt really dominate much for Spaniards to share blood with the Moors
I donβt know anything about the mixture of Arabs and African blood the Italians and Spaniards have but I have been to parts of Spain where the least migrants and tourists people be at and I saw nothing but Caucasians some with blue and hazel eyes however, somehow dark eyes but their skin tone was extremely pale and lift European like, Iβm not too sure since I donβt live in Spain, but I can tell that those men that you put in your post are originally north Africans with Spanish nationality but not actual Spanish blood
Yeah, they're white. Here in the UK we seem to focus more on nationality than race, so it's less about what colour your skin is and more about what country you're from.
I believe most people aggree that greeks, italians and spainards are considered white. Even by some (strict) standards of third reich (I do not endorse it, just using it as an example because they were crazy about races).
Obviously, they're white... No idea about the migrant problems. Most probably it's because it's difficult to get jobs for the native people there... so they don't want some foreigner stealing their jobs...
OBVIOUSLY YOU ARE WRONG WE ARE NOT UNDER ANY CIRCUMSTANCES WHITE - IN YOUR COUNTRY YOU HAVE ITALIAN AMERICANS THAT MIX WITH CAUCASIANS WE ARE NOT CAUCASION WE ARE MEDITARRARNEAN AND WE PROUDLY OWN THAT HERE, ALL THESE people CLASSIFYING US AS IF YOU KNOW ANY OF US HALF OF YOU IF NOT ALL OF YOU HAVE NEVER SET FOOT ON EUROPEAN SOIL MUCH LESS MY COUNTRY IN ITALY SO SORRY YOU WHITES CANNOT CLAIM US... WE DO NOT SEEK YOUR PRIVLEDGE NOR YOUR IGNORANCE TOWARD OTHER CULTURES WE PROUDLY REMAIN MEDITERANEAN ALONG WITH SPAIN, FRANCE AND GREECE. WE ARE NOT CAUCASIONS, ONLY IN AMERICA DOES IT COME DOWN TO THIS '"WHITE"SKIN THING HERE WE ARE ALL EQUAL HERE WE LIVE, WORK AND BREATHE BESIDE ALL RACES. AND FOR YOUR INFO, ITALY HAS A NORTH AND SOUTH THE ONLY REASON THE SOUTH ARE BLONDES AND WANT SO BADLY TO BE CONSIDERED WHITE IS DUE TO THE PRIVLEDGE AND BECAUSE THEY MIX WITH AUSTRIANS WHO ARE IN FACT WHITE... HOWEVER WE HERE ARE DARK SKIN FROM BIRTH, SOME OF US NOT BUT WE DO NOT CARRY PINK SKIN OR BURN IN THE SUN OR EAT HOT DOGS ! WE ARE ETHNIC, AND WE ARE PROUD OF OUR ETHNICITY AS MEDITERANEANS. WHEN OUR MEN CAME TO YOUR COUNTRY TO MIGRATE U DISCRIMINATED AGAINST US FOR OUR SKIN COLOR , BUT THEN RODE THE BACKS OF OUR RICH MAFIA FOR MONEY AND CLOUT NOW ALL OF A SUDDEN WE ARE GOOD ENOUGH TO CONSIDER WHITE? NO THANK YOU.. WE ARE PROUD MEDI AND WE WILL STAY THERE THANK YOU BUT NO THANK YOU
Yes. They are white Europeans. They have had some influx of genes from the Middle East, but they are still essentially white in genetic terms, and also in cultural ones. To be white is to be of European origin.
0
0 Reply
Anonymous
(18-24)
+1 y
Ctfu have you ever seen an African American person before? Because the guy who you said kinda looks African American looks nothing like an African American.
Are you Black? People easily recognize people of their own race and can distinguish between race subcategories. I am North European so I don't know the difference between different kinds of Blacks.
Most Helpful Opinions