No, we get ONE life to live to our best ability that makes us happy. What I don’t like is the lying... Trans community should stop lying to love interests about who they really are! This is dangerous, deceitful and downright wrong.
3
0 Reply
Anonymous
(18-24)
+1 y
I personally don't beleive transgerism is wrong. Because I Think gender has more to go with how the person feels than if the person has a penis or a vagina. I don't know why someone changing their gender would hurt someone else. And if the person is happier in being the opposite gender than I think they should do it. I mean if you wake up tomorrow with the opposite gender should you just keep living with that gender now or can't you change it?
Is it wrong, no, but there is an issue of age. Some studies have shown that children who identify as transgendered at a young age often grow up to desist, and grow into homosexual people of their cisgender, as much as 90% in some studies. So actually transitioning, be it hormone blockers, replacement therapy or surgery shouldn't be done that young.
many people who choose to live as the other sex have a deep feeling that they are "wrong", or they had a closer relationship with their mother than their father and that leads them to want to emulate their role model. it also has to do with feeling confident and representing how they feel on the inside.
The problem comes when you force others to accept their concept of reality against their will like in California. Where does it stop when you make a law with jail time for anyone saying something offensive to others? The other part I don't like about the modern trans movement is men competing in women's sports. If a woman had the same level of testosterone as a man she would be disqualified for using steroids.
Look every in the world just needs to mind the business that pays them. Let people live their lives. No one should be judging anyone, because no one is perfect
Is it wrong to pursue happiness? I am of the opinion that if it has nothing to do with me and it don't hurt any one. Go ahead and knock yourself out. If I am approached by someone that is gay or transgender when i'm wearing heels then I have invited them to approach me. That goes with straight people too. Depending on the attitude of the person dictates my attitude. I think that every one just needs to take the attitude of if it dont hurt anyone then let it be.
You can do whatever you want, dress differently, cut parts of your body, take chemicals, consider yourself as something else... Deep down, you are what you are. Biology, nature, can't be denied. You can pretend, you can refuse to see, but you'll always be who you were at birth.
I agree that it is not natural. Call it a personality disorder or something else. But if they do not want nor accept "help", then let them be is a more peaceful way to get along.
It's defiantly a mental illness that is being turned into a lifestyle. For that mater ALL LGBT's are ill. (Hear me out before just grabbing something to beat me up.) If it was nature making people the way, why are humans the only ones that are? Seems to me, if it was something nature caused, it would effect other animals as well.
I have mixed opinions, I'm a centre libertarian so if the person who is over 18 and who totally committed and sure about changing their BINARY gender then yeah I support it but only fully grown man can change to a woman and vice versa cuz in human science there are only 2 genders (plus birth defects), my opinion is mostly logical but reasonable.
In my opinion, trans... Is a mental health disorder, the man or woman that has the need to be the opposite sex, wjhat is everyones opinion on Transabled ( able bodied people who make them selves disabled ) or Transparalyed the ( those who want to be paralysed). People with perfect vision who choose to lose their eyesight - most would agree that these are mental health conditions
Its not a mental illness, just because someone relates to a different gender. I am transgender I have had this since I was old enough to remember. My mother said when you get older you will grow out of it,,.. Well im in my 50s and it is still here, I tried to change 20 years ago but it would caused me and my family a lot of distress so I have to bury my feelings, at times very hard...
0
0 Reply
Anonymous
(25-29)
+1 y
I don't like to judge things that I don't understand. I think it's weird but for the rest of us, who don't feel that way, it's really hard to understand what's going on inside their heads so... But I definitely wouldn't call them mentally ill. If you ever meet one, you wouldn't even know they used to have something else between their legs
@cipher42 No they are mentally ill imagine if they said they wanted to change into a toaster they would end up in the looney bin wouldn't they? So why do they treat them believing they are the opposite gender like it is normal? Oh wait I remember Democrats want votes that's right so they will say any ridiculous thing even if it means these mentally ill people end up with a huge suicide rate.
@BuffaloChickenWrap Are you a professional psychologist? If not, I don't think you have any right to determine what is or isn't a mental illness, considering that the actual psychologists/psychiatrists/etc disagree with you.
@cipher42 Check the suicide rates look it up they off themselves after they realize what they have done to themselves any psychiatrist without some sort of far left wing agenda would treat them for their mental illness the only shrinks who would disagree with me are only doing it for their agenda not because they are right. It is simple logic if you woke up one day believing you were a dog would you be sane? No you would not so how is someone sane believing they are the opposite sex? If you can't see this maybe you need to be locked in an asylum as well.
@BuffaloChickenWrap Cite them for me. And do all psychiatrists have some sort of left wing agenda then? Are you sure you're not just confusing "has a left wing agenda" with "doesn't buy into anti-scientific bigotry and propaganda"?
@cipher42 there is no science that can debunk the fact that our anatomy defines our gender it is simple anyone saying there are 99 genders has a political bias because these mentally ill people will vote Democrat if the liberals support them that is all there is to it
@BuffaloChickenWrap That's not really a fact, it's a matter of definition, which is a deeply subjective area. First off, yeah, some people use "sex" and "gender" synonymously. But those people talking about transgender issues don't, so if you're using "gender" to mean "sex", you're committing the equivocation fallacy- like equating the colloquial use of "theory" with the scientific one and thus claiming that evolution (or germs or gravity) are "just" theories and thus not proven. So what I'd recommend is that yes, you probably should stop commenting, at least until you understand the language being used here well enough to make a meaningful argument.
@BuffaloChickenWrap Yeah, we've already established that your definition of "insane" isn't exactly reliable, especially considering that again, you don't seem to grasp the actual meaning of the words you're trying to use here. That's a pretty major issue if you're trying to form a coherent, let alone convincing, argument.
Cipher42 I tried to tell him BuffaloChickenWrap that it’s a mental disorder and his opinion is unacceptable since it disrespects people. He told me that Christians were bullied into accepting gay marriage and that I was too young to have an opinion and not true to my religion. I gave him the example of Hitler vs Malala (who was much younger but right in her opinions) he still wasn’t convinced. Sometimes you have to let ignorance be and walk away, because by definition ignorance means denying common sense.
I think having an unreversable procedure before the age of 25 is irresponsible. It's easy to still have doubts about your own sexuality even after the end of puberty. So better not go around chopping pieces of your body until you are absolutely certain of what you want (You=general person)
No, it's not wrong in terms of morality. It's hard to just sum this situation up to a mental illness someone is born with. Things can happen in a person's life that influence a person's decisions. It takes a whole lot of resolve to decide to make a gender change decision.
Gender Dysphoria is a real mental illness when someone feels like they dont belong in their own gender. Transgenders have a suicide rate of about 40%, yes! 40%! Higher than Jews in Europe in the 40s.
With such a high suicide rate for transgenders we can't have society treat it as a norm. Not to mention that this statistic DOES NOT CHANGE even after transgender surgery is operated.
Being transsexual is a dangerous mental illness that shouldn't be socially acceptable.
What Girls & Guys Said
Opinion
74Opinion
No, we get ONE life to live to our best ability that makes us happy. What I don’t like is the lying... Trans community should stop lying to love interests about who they really are! This is dangerous, deceitful and downright wrong.
I personally don't beleive transgerism is wrong. Because I Think gender has more to go with how the person feels than if the person has a penis or a vagina. I don't know why someone changing their gender would hurt someone else. And if the person is happier in being the opposite gender than I think they should do it. I mean if you wake up tomorrow with the opposite gender should you just keep living with that gender now or can't you change it?
Although I beleive there are only two genders
Is it wrong, no, but there is an issue of age. Some studies have shown that children who identify as transgendered at a young age often grow up to desist, and grow into homosexual people of their cisgender, as much as 90% in some studies. So actually transitioning, be it hormone blockers, replacement therapy or surgery shouldn't be done that young.
Religiously its wrong... and its also wrong if you try to date me without telling me that you used to be a girl/guy
Other than that, i dont give a crap, let them do some weird shit to themselves and i’ll go the opposite way and on about my day
Keep them far far away lol
many people who choose to live as the other sex have a deep feeling that they are "wrong", or they had a closer relationship with their mother than their father and that leads them to want to emulate their role model. it also has to do with feeling confident and representing how they feel on the inside.
The problem comes when you force others to accept their concept of reality against their will like in California. Where does it stop when you make a law with jail time for anyone saying something offensive to others? The other part I don't like about the modern trans movement is men competing in women's sports. If a woman had the same level of testosterone as a man she would be disqualified for using steroids.
Look every in the world just needs to mind the business that pays them. Let people live their lives. No one should be judging anyone, because no one is perfect
Is it wrong to pursue happiness? I am of the opinion that if it has nothing to do with me and it don't hurt any one. Go ahead and knock yourself out. If I am approached by someone that is gay or transgender when i'm wearing heels then I have invited them to approach me. That goes with straight people too. Depending on the attitude of the person dictates my attitude. I think that every one just needs to take the attitude of if it dont hurt anyone then let it be.
You can do whatever you want, dress differently, cut parts of your body, take chemicals, consider yourself as something else... Deep down, you are what you are.
Biology, nature, can't be denied. You can pretend, you can refuse to see, but you'll always be who you were at birth.
It is literally a personality disorder. These people need serious help, not to be supported for something they're not.
Yes they do but corrupt Democrats want votes so they keep encouraging it
I agree that it is not natural. Call it a personality disorder or something else. But if they do not want nor accept "help", then let them be is a more peaceful way to get along.
It's defiantly a mental illness that is being turned into a lifestyle. For that mater ALL LGBT's are ill. (Hear me out before just grabbing something to beat me up.) If it was nature making people the way, why are humans the only ones that are? Seems to me, if it was something nature caused, it would effect other animals as well.
Clown fishes can change their gender
I have mixed opinions, I'm a centre libertarian so if the person who is over 18 and who totally committed and sure about changing their BINARY gender then yeah I support it but only fully grown man can change to a woman and vice versa cuz in human science there are only 2 genders (plus birth defects), my opinion is mostly logical but reasonable.
In my opinion, trans... Is a mental health disorder, the man or woman that has the need to be the opposite sex, wjhat is everyones opinion on Transabled ( able bodied people who make them selves disabled ) or Transparalyed the ( those who want to be paralysed). People with perfect vision who choose to lose their eyesight - most would agree that these are mental health conditions
Its not a mental illness, just because someone relates to a different gender. I am transgender I have had this since I was old enough to remember. My mother said when you get older you will grow out of it,,.. Well im in my 50s and it is still here, I tried to change 20 years ago but it would caused me and my family a lot of distress so I have to bury my feelings, at times very hard...
I don't like to judge things that I don't understand. I think it's weird but for the rest of us, who don't feel that way, it's really hard to understand what's going on inside their heads so...
But I definitely wouldn't call them mentally ill. If you ever meet one, you wouldn't even know they used to have something else between their legs
God created people the way he wanted them to be. We should not tamper with God's creation
Beautiful comment
So God created people who want to change themselves, meaning that if we prevent them from changing themselves we're interfering with God's plans.
@cipher42 No they are mentally ill imagine if they said they wanted to change into a toaster they would end up in the looney bin wouldn't they? So why do they treat them believing they are the opposite gender like it is normal? Oh wait I remember Democrats want votes that's right so they will say any ridiculous thing even if it means these mentally ill people end up with a huge suicide rate.
@BuffaloChickenWrap Are you a professional psychologist? If not, I don't think you have any right to determine what is or isn't a mental illness, considering that the actual psychologists/psychiatrists/etc disagree with you.
@cipher42 Check the suicide rates look it up they off themselves after they realize what they have done to themselves any psychiatrist without some sort of far left wing agenda would treat them for their mental illness the only shrinks who would disagree with me are only doing it for their agenda not because they are right. It is simple logic if you woke up one day believing you were a dog would you be sane? No you would not so how is someone sane believing they are the opposite sex? If you can't see this maybe you need to be locked in an asylum as well.
@BuffaloChickenWrap Cite them for me. And do all psychiatrists have some sort of left wing agenda then? Are you sure you're not just confusing "has a left wing agenda" with "doesn't buy into anti-scientific bigotry and propaganda"?
@cipher42 there is no science that can debunk the fact that our anatomy defines our gender it is simple anyone saying there are 99 genders has a political bias because these mentally ill people will vote Democrat if the liberals support them that is all there is to it
And that is the last time I am commenting on this post.
@BuffaloChickenWrap That's not really a fact, it's a matter of definition, which is a deeply subjective area. First off, yeah, some people use "sex" and "gender" synonymously. But those people talking about transgender issues don't, so if you're using "gender" to mean "sex", you're committing the equivocation fallacy- like equating the colloquial use of "theory" with the scientific one and thus claiming that evolution (or germs or gravity) are "just" theories and thus not proven. So what I'd recommend is that yes, you probably should stop commenting, at least until you understand the language being used here well enough to make a meaningful argument.
@cipher42 Ok I will say one more thing you are fucking insane bye.
@BuffaloChickenWrap Yeah, we've already established that your definition of "insane" isn't exactly reliable, especially considering that again, you don't seem to grasp the actual meaning of the words you're trying to use here. That's a pretty major issue if you're trying to form a coherent, let alone convincing, argument.
Cipher42 I tried to tell him BuffaloChickenWrap that it’s a mental disorder and his opinion is unacceptable since it disrespects people. He told me that Christians were bullied into accepting gay marriage and that I was too young to have an opinion and not true to my religion. I gave him the example of Hitler vs Malala (who was much younger but right in her opinions) he still wasn’t convinced. Sometimes you have to let ignorance be and walk away, because by definition ignorance means denying common sense.
*it isn’t a mental disorder but a medical condition (sorry typo lol)
I think having an unreversable procedure before the age of 25 is irresponsible. It's easy to still have doubts about your own sexuality even after the end of puberty. So better not go around chopping pieces of your body until you are absolutely certain of what you want
(You=general person)
I have the issue how it's being promoted.
"These people aren't sick"
"These people are mentally stable"
How is the suicide rate that high? Even bullied kids don't come close to it, not even by 10% of the trans suicide rates...
No, it's not wrong in terms of morality. It's hard to just sum this situation up to a mental illness someone is born with. Things can happen in a person's life that influence a person's decisions. It takes a whole lot of resolve to decide to make a gender change decision.
It is the most immoral thing there is.
How so?
Gender Dysphoria is a real mental illness when someone feels like they dont belong in their own gender. Transgenders have a suicide rate of about 40%, yes! 40%! Higher than Jews in Europe in the 40s.
With such a high suicide rate for transgenders we can't have society treat it as a norm. Not to mention that this statistic DOES NOT CHANGE even after transgender surgery is operated.
Being transsexual is a dangerous mental illness that shouldn't be socially acceptable.