I believe gender is the language used to define a person's Sex. A female has a vagina, a male has a penis. It is not accurate to say that a female who as a vagina is a male. Because the definition of a male is a person who has the opposite genitalia. A female can conform to the socially accepted gender norms of a male. Having a personality of that on average that applies to males. And a male vice versa. Instead of using gender terminology, (Male, female) to describe someone's identity, we should use "Grammatical Gender" those terms are Masculine, Feminine. This would be MUCH more appropriate to define a person's identity as opposed to using Male, Female. Since male and female is determined by what's between your legs. Whereas Masculine and Feminine is determined by the interests and personality a person's retains. It is a FACT, that females traditionally are more emotional, and males are more Logical. So as far as thinking is concerned it can be said that Emotional thinking is Feminine, and logical thinking is Masculine. So a female, can retain the Masculine trait of Logical thinking. And a Male can retain the feminine trait of Emotional thinking. There should be a middle ground after all every compare contrast chart (Venn diagram) has the middle for comparable traits. Men and woman are equally as good at math, and at science. So math and science is neither masculine nor is it feminine. Being good at math is ______ we need a word for it. I suppose that could be used as the new non binary. (500 characters left) however Women have been proven to be better at Language arts, so reading and writing. So reading and writing would be a feminine trait. And Men have been proven to be better at sports, so sports are a Masculine trait. So i don't believe in Transgenderism. I believe you are either male or woman, but you can have either masculine or femine Gender traits/characteristics. And those are what you should choose to identify yourself with. If you want to do so at all.
In my view, there are only men and women. That is dictated by what you're born with.
If you are a male that wishes to go by 'she', i just believe you like things that are considered for women more than you like things considered for men. But i dont see that as making you a feminine man or something like that. Its just society making you think that way because it has to split everything and categorize everything. Which i think is stupid.
Thats an issue of today, we think that those who are trans are mentally ill, when they aren't. They just prefer different things and people feel the need to categorize it. People are not comfortable when someone does not follow the norm and therefore classify it as an illness. We are quick to say something is wrong with a person because they dont follow the norm. Thats not fair or right, everyone is their own person first and foremost. Yes, there are things that are legitimately an illness, but an issue with identification isn't an illness. Its a problem with how society decided to classify different things and say you must fall into a category.
For example a male that likes to play with dolls, thats not a problem. He shouldn't feel like he needs to be called by 'she' because of it. Its a very simplified problem, yes, but it gets the point across. I know there are many more complicated things, but I still say that falls under social construct and not nature.
TL;DR There are only men and women. What you identify as is because of social construct, which needs to be removed (the social construct). But you are still a man or woman, which is determined by birth.
So... Um yeah, that dumb... That a male that wishes to go by she is not Feminine. But that goes against the very reason why he wants to be refered to as she. He has those feminine attributes, which makes him feel more feminine than masculine, so there grow he wants to be called she. However he is most definitely Feminine. No masculine dude is gonna ask to be called she, instead of he.
He wants to go by 'she' because he feels that he has feminine traits. However these traits that we consider feminine comes from a social construct that I believe needs to be removed. So 'he' and 'she' wouldn't come from do you act like a man or woman, but instead come from were you born a man or woman.
Transgender is a mental illness no matter what way you look at it. It's a mental denial to your physical identity of male or female. For some reason it's now okay for people not to be accepting of themselves and their bodies. What's the difference between a man hating himself because he's black and a girl hating herself because she has boobs...
Is that why they are transgender? I believe it is because we try to push them to be a certain way because of how they look. So instead of changing how they are, they change how they look- or try to. Again, I dont know any transgender people and haven't spoken to any. So I do not know if it is actually an issue of their body or their personality and how we treat them. Do you know for a fact it is about their body?
And yes I do agree, just because you have Feminine attributes does not mean that you should change what you identify as. Nor can you. Playing with dolls doesn't cause you to grow a vagina over night. That's not how the world works lmao.
Gender is not a social or cultural construct. If you have a penis you are male, you have a vagina you are female. There shouldn't be the principal that you can interchange your gender like it's a name tag. You gender is what you biologically are, sex and gender is the same thing. The social construct that you can choose which gender you are, is what needs to be removed. Not gender itself.
I used to agree with you on sex and gender being the same thing, but unfortunately they aren't. 1 is a social construct, while the biological one is sex. I dont agree with it, but thats how it is. And yes, choosing your gender should be removed- because it should be based purely on how you were born. The social construct I am talking about is the personality traits of men and women that make people believe they should have been born the other gender.
Gender energy (masculine and Feminine) are based off of averages, what is culturally normal for a male or woman to do or express themselves by. A male like cars, a girl likes horse. Since more girls happen to like horses more than boys seem to like horses, we can call horses a feminine trait. there is nothing wrong thought with a guy who likes horses. The terms feminine and Masculine are just describing preference of the average gender. Or gender norms.
Right. There is nothing wrong with a man liking horses, but people use that to say there is something wrong with him, because it is associated with girls. But he is a boy, so obviously that can't be right, right?(that is not what I believe) So therefore those associations with cars for men and horses for women should be removed, because people can't handle it.
How the fuck do you still not understand what I am saying we should remove? We keep Male, Female, boy, girl, etc - that is defined by how you're born. Period. Thats fucking it. After that, thats fucking it. You do not say cars are for boys and horses or for girls. You do not say boys should act some certain way. You end it at ARE YOU BORN BOY OR GIRL?
No I'm not. I'm saying it isn't beneficial to remove social constructs nor is it even possible to do so. I understand that your saying no longer say barbies are for girls and action figures are for boys. But you understand that that's primarily the care because kids are entertained by the toys that interest them the most. You realise kids are generally the ones that choose their toys, they go intot he store see a toy they pick it out. Most boys will grab a Superman action figure most girls will grab Barbie and her prom dress outfit. So when a boy goes to school and he's talking to his friends about his new Barbie doll he will be the outcast of the group in comparison to the amount of boys that bought Superman. And when they realise that most of the girls have bought barbies they will say that he likes girly things because more girls have been associated with having such a toy than the other. And vice versa. This is what I mean these social constructs are based off of. And it's impossible to get rid of them.
If you understood then I do not know why you had to ask what we could use if we got rid of male and female. Moving on: This comes down to a difference in view point here. Yes, they will pick their own things and see that that one boy does not follow the norm. But your then saying that the children themselves are determining what is for boys and what is for girls. However I believe that is not being decided by the children entirely on their own. They see commercials that portray boys using the superman, and girls using the barbey. Which influences what they do and pick. Kind of similar to the difference between a black and white doll. Why do children think the white doll looks prettier? Because that is what they see and are 'told' through society and its commercials, etc.
I disagree with the concept of gender entirely. There are 2 sexes. Man and woman. Those who use the term gender often believe that a person's gender can be many different things based on the way a person thinks or feels; how they see themselves. However, they will also say that Man and Woman are gender options. I'm sure we've all heard some guy say "I feel like a woman today", yet they can't tell you what that feels like. Even if they could, a woman who identifies as a woman would probably tell you being a woman feels entirely different. There are traits and activities that are traditionally or statistically associated with one of the 2 sexes, but wanting to do things that aren't typically associated with your sex doesn't change your biology. Personally, I think the tension about all this gender identity, transgender stuff would go away if we all would recognize that our contemporary understanding of the term "gender" is at best a misunderstanding. At worst, it's a fabrication. So again I say do away with the whole concept of Gender. Let there be men and women who do whatever they want.
We don’t need gender. We need to remove socially controlled behavioral expectation for a person based on their sex.
Why do we need gender at all if everyone was free to Be who they are Independent of their sex.
If people get a sex change they get a sex change. Gender is meaningless. All it does is support sex based discrimination.
What good is to anyone did a person to assume a woman is going to be emotional when this may have nothing to do with her personality l.
Or that a man is going to be aggressive when he may be the gentlest soul.
It serve NO purpose. People will still gravitate towards those they get on with. We get to know people and decide if we like them
We apply for positions and our competency should determine if we are hired
How is it productive to linguistically brand people for life based on something they have no control over and has nothing to do with their potential.
Sex is important for mating and proper medical care.
Gender serves no purpose.
If men were not beat up for wearing nail polish and women were not raped for looking too masculine, no one would need to announce to the world they have switch graders, Bc they would not he persecuted by mixing their personality with the sex they were born into.
Trans gender only exists bc if the lunch mentality surrounding reversion from “ gender “ norms. Take away gender, you don’t have that problem.
Instead you want to add even MORE categories to reinforce original stereotypes that started the issue. Just get rid of them. Simple.
gen·der /ˈjendər/ Learn to pronounce noun noun: gender; plural noun: genders 1. either of the two sexes (male and female), especially when considered with reference to social and cultural differences rather than biological ones. The term is also used more broadly to denote a range of identities that do not correspond to established ideas of male and female. "a condition that affects people of both genders" members of a particular gender considered as a group. "social interaction between the genders" the fact or condition of belonging to or identifying with a particular gender. "video ads will target users based only on age and gender" 2. GRAMMAR (in languages such as Latin, Greek, Russian, and German) each of the classes (typically masculine, feminine, common, neuter) of nouns and pronouns distinguished by the different inflections that they have and require in words syntactically associated with them. Grammatical gender is only very loosely associated with natural distinctions of sex. the property (in nouns and related words) of belonging to a gender. "adjectives usually agree with the noun in gender and number"
It’s defining who u want to be, not others to tell you what u should be. Gender doesn’t have to be explicitly male and female. A female may have a masculine energy. And a male could have a feminine energy. Or a person regardless of his/her gender can have both energy. In reality, gender just defines your physical looks. It doesn’t define u as an individual.
@Hawk4225 trying to point out the fact that she is a female has nothing to do with the statement she made. She said she has half masculine/ Feminine energy. She never said she was a male, or Non-binary. We can only assume though that she is a she based off of her gag profile.
This question is over complicated nowadays by spoilt little kids who have no real life issues. This question is not a society and political question. It is simply biological you are male or female by whether you have a cock or a pussy, now just move on with your lives and shut up
Well if gender is just about what you identify as and their are only 2 (or 3 if you consider hemaphrodites a separate sex) then how have we got to the 30 odd different genders? I can think of 5 which I could argue are legitimate those being man, woman, intersex, trans man or trans woman.
Gender has been used as a synonym for sex since the 1600s if you want to use it in its usage before then you have to take into consideration that caucasian is a gender, middle class is a gender even your family name is a kind of gender.
My point is that people who say sex and gender are different is bullshit because they will then say a transwoman is a woman. That doesn't make sense since male is a biological sex and man is an adult male therefore a transwoman is still biologically a male therefore adult trans women are men.
0
0 Reply
Anonymous
(30-35)
+1 y
"male and female is determined by what's between your legs." Male and female are sexes and are determined by your chromosomes, not genitals. Man and woman are genders, they are determined by performance and appearance. You're getting them mixed up. Though these are flexible definitions that people use in different ways. Sex and gender are often linked and used interchangeably.
Also you're going to make the "infinite gender" progressives mad by trying to categorize things as a masculine or feminine.
See that thing between your legs that you pee and have sex with? That's your gender. If it's an inny, you're a girl, if it's an outty, you're a boy. If you have both, you're a hermaphrodite, or an F to M transgender. And, it doesn't mater if you've got a man-made inny, you're still a woman.
Biological sex and gender mean the SAME THING. God made us EITHER male or female. One or the other. Only two. NO more, no less. God intended females to play female roles, and for males to play male roles. Females will ALWAYS be females. Males will ALWAYS be males. If you try to transplant sex organs from one sex/gender to another sex/gender, you will only have freaks with damaged minds running around.
If you think it's anything else then biological sex, please explain to me why we should care about gender in the first place. What's the point of having the word if it doesn't mean anything of substance?
You're pretty right on the money, except that people who don't identify as their biological sex don't use the words "male" and "female". So, what you've outlined is what's already happening ;)
Why not simply call them X or Y? That way there's no bathroom confusion? How many people really have this problem? Shouldn't we tackle something else rather than waste our time on a few freaks that can't decide on a bathroom?
0
0 Reply
Anonymous
(25-29)
+1 y
female and male. That's it. PERSONALITY IS NOT GENDER.
I feel like with so many people, mostly women, complain how there are so few "real men" anymore, I start to suspect that gender is personality + genitals.
@Lightning8 I think gender is genitals UNLESS you're transgender I think everyone else is just female or male exhibiting more masculine or feminine traits, but that doesn't mean you have to change your entire gender
I can can understand your point of view, but hormones play a big part in who we are. Like myself outwardly I'm male, but I have softer skin vertically no body her , facial features are softer more like a female smaller penis and testicles. Up to being 16 i looked like a girl. Use to pass as one when got dressed up. Also you can get females who are more male they need to shave of facial hair and body hair.
Gender to me is the reflections of a society on the behaviour of humans in that society, and how that society attempts to deal with this biological reality.
Probably evryone Agree and i think its a grammar mistake. And what you talking about is not energy, its leftist/rightist (or any other) ideilogies, philosophies.
whoever wrote that arricle i bet was a male trying to save face. And for any man to think that sex was how or why a woman had more control in a relationship should say anything nothing and just cut their loses or chose their battles more wisely
You forgot to capitalize Bible. Also, you're wrong for assuming the author has a Bible. Furthermore, this generation does not blindly accept the words of the Bible as absolute truth. All this is coming from a Christian by the way. If you want someone to look to the Bible for answers, suggest reading it. Convey that there are answers to be found within it's pages. No one will be interested if you introduce it as though they should know better.
Most Helpful Opinions