This question isn't whether or not you believe in the prison system, it's about whether or not you think the prison system is related to those three things she mentioned.




When she pontificates, she sounds like she's about 12 years old! She apparently knows NOTHING of American history, or world history, either, except the "woke" version that she's been fed! The world didn't begin yesterday! And America didn't begin yesterday, or in the 1950s (she wasn't alive back then, either, but I was). I can hardly think of someone less qualified to be in Congress, or to make public pronouncements about our country!
I know she had been a bartender before coming to Congress. I think to be a bartender, you at least need a degree in counseling and social work!
No, it doesn't. I always say, people get the government they deserve! Einstein once said, "One example of insanity is doing the same thing again and again and expecting a different result!" They just keep pulling the lever for Democrats, like its a religion or something!
You're exactly right on that insanity example. I often wonder just how bad it would have to get in California before they ever wake up? Or they incapable of waking up? They elected Gavin newsom as the governor and he's destroying the place. When Larry elder tried to run for the governor seat they called him a white supremacist. How dumb would you have to be to call a black person a white supremacist?
AOC and her fellow travelers in idiocy would have all the criminals back on the streets. It's fashionable among the woke left to compare unrelated things to slavery and the "new Jim Crow."
Thank you for MHO. 🙋♂️
Opinion
37Opinion
They say "even a broken clock is wrong twice a day." Unfortunately, Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez is a broken digital clock who's circuits have been destroyed and LED screen smashed in.
No, I don't prison incarceration is comparable with Jim Crow, American apartheid and slavery. I could be in a car crash and have permanent brain damage with part of my skull exposed and the top part of my brain visible with the naked eye and still not be that retarded.
Actually, is AOC a flat-earther? The most surprising thing about her would be if she actually WASN'T a flat-earther. Then again, flat-earthers are rebellious and question the mainstream narrative, so maybe not.
The actual quote is: "It is a system whose logic evolved from the same lineage as Jim Crow, American apartheid, & slavery." She goes on to say "A cage is a cage is a cage. And humans don’t belong in them."
So to me, it sounds like she's talking about the dehumanization of criminals, the same way that those other things dehumanized blacks.
The article you've screencapped ( https://prismreports.org/2019/10/07/alexandria-ocasiocortez-on-prison-abolition-explore-just-alternatives-to-incarceration/ ) is referring to the following sequence of tweets:

Which part don't you agree with?
If my interpretation of what she was saying is correct, then yes, I agree with her.
A different interpretation might be that the prison system is designed with the goal of suppressing black people, which I would not agree with. It is certainly indifferent to their plight though.
Consider the stereotypical black teenage gang member who murders someone. You might well say "they're a monster, and they deserve to rot in jail". You could also approach it with the view that nobody deserves to be locked up in jail. Noone is born a violent criminal, and if they end up as one, it is because society has failed them in some way. I'm not a violent criminal, and hopefully neither are you, so what makes them different? And of course, when you look into it, the links between poverty and crime (and race) are undeniable.
My interpretation is that she doesn't like people in prisons. But like her and the rest of the squad, they always throw in racism. It doesn't matter what the topic is they got to throw that in there. Should have just talked about how she doesn't like people in prison of any color.
I work in a prison work release. If you have the access to the database I do you might think differently.
I know a guy who is due to release in a few days, so I asked him what his plans were when she got out. He told me his plan is to go back to prison. I asked him why he wanted to go back to prison. He said it's because it's where I belong. So he released even though he didn't want to and a month later he cut his girlfriend's head off. So ALC can talk about the definition of dehumanizing, but she's never had her head cut off. That's fairly dehumanizing.
I don't agree with her. I believe other countries probably have penal systems better than ours, but that our system is along the lines of slavery, that's just foolishness.
Moreover, I don't believe that the slaves themselves, people who had zero hope of being free, who were beaten severely for not working well, who could be bought and sold at will, and who were *born* into that situation or kidnapped and taken off to slavery, all without any due process, would agree at all that rapists, murderers, thieves, arsonists, batterers, and other prisoners, who are where they are as the result of due process, are suffering a fate as terrible and unjust as theirs. I don't believe they would agree with her at all.
100% with smaller crimes, like weed. Under nixon he demonized it to jail all his political rivals.
"You want to know what this was really all about,”
Ehrlichman, who died in 1999, said, referring to Nixon’s declaration of war on drugs.
“The Nixon campaign in 1968, and the Nixon White House after that, had two enemies: the antiwar left and black people. You understand what I’m saying. We knew we couldn’t make it illegal to be either against the war or black, but by getting the public to associate the hippies with marijuana and blacks with heroin, and then criminalizing both heavily, we could disrupt those communities. We could arrest their leaders, raid their homes, break up their meetings, and vilify them night after night on the evening news. Did we know we were lying about the drugs? Of course we did.”
Let me guess, she said "explore alternatives" without offering even one remotely reasonable answer?
The sad thing is she said this back in 2019, and one would think that after a couple years in Congress that she'd have a less childish view of the world. One would also think somebody with the mindset of incarceration being an overused punishment wouldn't be such a fangirl for Kamala Harris, who's only noteworthy contribution to politics is basically keeping people incarcerated longer than necessary in order to be used as forced labor for the state.
There's certain late night show hosts who pretend to get starry-eyed at the idea of AOC running for president, but then she'd actually have to debate people smarter than her (most), and it would end her political career. No, she's going to be the next Pelosi who spends 40 years in Congress because she won't ever win an election outside of her own district.
It doesn't what country you are in. It is necessary to lock some people up to deter them from re-offending and for social justice.
In my own state of my own country a leftist gov't put in 'poor baby justice' and nothing could be done to some one under 18. Predictably under 18's quickly realized they could do anything in a gang.
There were horrific assaults resulting in deaths and that was just with the girl gangs.
Drug dealers recruited under 18's cause their distribution networks would not be disrupted.
A jail term is not slavery; it's punishment. Some social groups may be more represented but that is because they are doing more crimes not some apartheid policy. Not sure what Jim Crow is but think it is unequal legal treatment. Nope. Same laws.
It’s not unusual for politicians to express themselves using hyperbole. In that sense, the comparison is fair, in my opinion. But even a cursory examination of the facts quickly reveals that the US prison system is none of what she claims. There ARE whites in every US prison, therefore Jim Crow and apartheid do not apply. Full stop.
The comparison to slavery is more nuanced, but i still think it’s generally hyperbolic. In the sense that there certainly some people in prison who should not be there and they are forced into manual labor for someone else’s benefit, there definitely is slavery in US prisons. However, in that the vast majority of inmates do deserve to be in prison, and upon going to prison we know we are relinquishing MANY rights afforded to law-abiding citizens, the expectation that we might still have autonomy over our own physical labors in prison is absurd by any reasonable standard. But i had stopped expecting the left to be reasonable long ago.
Can she explain why men are slightly less than 50% of the population and 91% of the prisoners? Are men being discriminated against, or do we commit more crime?
If young black and Hispanic males commit a hugely disproportionate percentage of the violent crime, they will be incarcerated at a disproportionate rate.
On the other hand, they are incarcerated disproportionately for non-violent, victimless crimes. Blacks and whites use marijuana at equal rates and very few middle class whites are in prison for non violent drug possession. (I don’t thing anyone should be for marijuana.)
Similarly, I don’t see why prostitution is a crime with no minors involved. Pimping, however, should carry the death penalty.
There's no doubt we've created an industrial prision complex but it's not apartheid, Jim crow, slavery or the holocaust. What it is, is a stand alone issue of it its own, a major soceital problem in America that feeds into itself. Hoe to solve it is the problem. Politicians will talk about the problem but have no real intention of solving it as it has become a huge industry in itself.
she is wrong about everything. Not only is she wrong she is just wrong in the head.
If her point was that racism is more about social economic issues and less about racism than, yes….
sadly that’s not what she ment.
Poor black people have the same issues as poor white people.
Doesn’t change the path to resolve by supporting poor black communities we all thrive and benefit. By not imprisoning none violent offenders we allow for more investment and improvement and less sustainability.
Nope, it is probably terrible, what I would say is it's not very effective. I watched a documentary the other day and it stated that prison populations are so crowded that some convicts that are serving 2 year sentences get out in about 10 days, the prison system also has zero percent chance of reforming criminals. This is California, so not sure what's going on in the rest of the country.
I work in a prison work release, and it's not zero percent chance of reforming, it's more like a 2% chance of reforming. That's dismal, but most of the prisoners love being there. It's the only way for them to get the monkey off their back. (no offense. lol) They seriously love the easy prison life.
One guy I work with asked a prisoner what it's like to be in society. (Where I work they can hold jobs, and go on approved shopping passes) The prisoner got very angry and said: "Prison is a society, it's just different than your society.
I was talking to another prisoner, and I was mad that he didn't finish his sanction hours. (he did something bad, so I made him spend extra time cleaning)
I said to him that if he didn't finish his two sanction hours, I was going to keep in prison for three extra months. (he was due to release in two days)(my threat was a joke, and he knew that)
I'll never forget what he said, and I just wish that the people on this site could understand this...
Hal said: "If you could keep me in here for three more months, I'd really appreciate it. Heck, if you kept me forever, I'd like it even more. Incarceration is a piece of cake. What I struggle with is freedom. I'm just not very good at it."
This is the theme for most all of them. Another guy was due to release, and I asked him what his plans were. (he was around 30) He said his plan was to go back to prison. I was shocked, because I didn't understand all of this back then. I asked him why he wanted to go back. He said that prison is where he belongs.
About three months later he cut his girlfriend's head off. AOC has her head so far up her ass. She's a bartender that somehow got idiots to vote for her.
What do you think is a good solution to stop people from offending, and re offending.
Great question. One Christmas, the prisoners got ham, turkey, mashed potatoes and gravy, stuffing, green bean casserole, and ice cream, and pie.
The staff got corn soup. That's it.
I know that you're an Aussie, so you don't know about "PREA"
The prison rape elimination act.
George Bush signed this into law.
It's the most fucked up law there is.
Some dumb bitch had sex with a prisoner, and now she's in prison for rape. I'm an ultra conservative, but Bush was a moron.
Yeah makes a lot of sense. What's this guards name. The one that got charged with rape.
I tried to do some reading on PREA, at first glance I think that legislation has its place, I don't believe sexual misconduct in corrections facilities should be taken lightly, unfortunately if it was consenting, that is hard to be proven, as for Christmas dinner, I hope you guys get penalty rates for working holidays, I don't care too much about if incarcerated persons get a special meal once a year. You guys get to go home at the end of your shift.
The prison system IS related to those things.
Poor countries in Africa couldn't afford a prison system like other wealthier countries so they enslaved people that broke laws instead. They then began the practice of selling slaves for profit to countries like America. So slaves were actually Criminals/Prisoners.
It was no different than a chain gang. They broke laws. Do the crime you do the time.
However, Saying that we shouldn't arrest people that break laws is the crazy part.
Stevie,
I blew up the pictures of AOC you provided. Oh man, she looks like she's crazy alright. That crazy look in her big ole' eyes would scare anyone! She's a nut case!
Trump used to call her a crazy little girl. 🙄
I usually post questions at home on my computer, and I'm pretty good at being able to resize and adjust things. But I posted this one on my phone and I do have an app to resize but I always forget to use it. And yes, she is one crazy lady.
Her and the rest of the squad always have to play the race card, because their arguments are always so weak.
@StevieNix what is her reasoning for wanting to abolish prisons? She wanted 4th of July cancelled too🙄.
I wish she had never been born. She is just a crazy shit disturber! What I don't understand is how in the hell anyone voted for her to be a Congresswoman. Once she got her foot in door she started the Green New Deal and people above listened to her. I heard she is very popular in social media and that is in her favor. What can I say?
Pollyanna wore those Rose colored glasses. Everything she saw was rosie. I don't know what kind of glasses AOC is wearing, but everything looks horrible to her. Everyone is racist except her and all white people are bad. So she just thinks prisons are bad, and criminals are good.
A broken clock is technically right twice a day. Forgetting about race and prisons for a moment, the US as an entire society just frickin' hates poor people.
That woman is crazier then a wild goose. She loves it when BLM or ANTIFA or women's marches burn shit and tear things up.
Yea and Soros. Pretty disgusting really. Then people get angry with the cops when their hands are tied pretty much...
I mean they can set something on fire and KILL SOMEONE!!! The left either loves it or is totally indifferent
Yea kind of like how they are harassing justices at their private houses as well as trying to influence court cases...
You're right about that. They can burn and loot and just terrorize this country nothing is done and if it is the media won't cover it
If only they could be arrested for their crimes... I am sure we could at least get some life sentences
Yea well I am glad terrorist's did not change their view. Because he is a Democrat. They own the justice department pretty much
But I think the justices have the power to issue warrants themselves for this kind of thing
There is nothing I can ever agree with her on, she is living in some unrealistic fantasy world.
Equating slavery to serving time for doing crime seems like something a legit white supremacist would say.
I think they’re related, but AOC is just a virtue signaler, she’s in the establishment pocket and won’t ever vote how she talks unless Nancy tells her it’s okay
She is an idiot and dumb as a rock. If she some how becomes President we are all doomed. No way the country could survive 4 years of her. She will do stupid things like Biden , but at least Biden has an excuse.
She would like to put political opponents in prison and let out the violent criminals.
Not in a YEAR of Sundays. I dunno what she's smoking, but it can't be legal. That's why she wants to ditch the shovel, because she's been doing Class A drugs.
Simples...
Yeah, that's a worrying prospect...
There are a lot of Black people in prison so yeah she’s got a point
Comparing the prison system to Jim Crow apartheid and slavery
I think so but I’m not sure
Of course it is. The whole war on drugs was a war on Black people.
I agree with AOC being the next Dem rep for Prez. And I hope she wins. Why? She can't win legitimately. They can't possibly try that shit again.
Fucking aye. They must do Michael Obama first, then try Oprah. Third is Biden again. AOC? Jesus Christ...
I think everything that comes out of her mouth comes from a place of ignorance or deliberate misrepresentation.
The answer is obviously no. AOC has to be one of the biggest morons in American political history.
I thought she was too young to run for the presidency in 2024, but it turns out I was wrong.
She was on the Stephen Colbert show and he flat out asked her if she was running for the presidency in 2024. She gave the standard non answer. She said something like, right now I'm just focus on maintaining this democracy for all of us.
I bet she's going to throw her hat in the ring in 2024.
Socialists in overall don't believe in things they say.
it still boggles my mind that just because she’s a decent looking girl with big boobs she made it this far into politics, she’s literally retarded.
She got upset with Elon musk when he bought twitter. So she tweeted out that she's going to sell her tesla. Like Elon gives two shits if she sells it or not.
But prior to all of that, AOC was tweeting that Republicans don't like her because they can't have her.
So when she started flipping crap to elon, he tweeted back and told her to stop hitting on him. LOL
It's sad someone can look good & be so damn stupid lol
I don’t agree with anything that comes out of that cunts mouth
But stupid voters do. Remember when Amazon was going to put a corporate headquarters in her district? 40,000 high paying jobs. I think the only thing Bezos asked for was that the city install a helipad or something. She said no, so they just went to one of the other cities that was begging them to come.
I think nobody should be listening to her.
Bad for them.
No, she's crazy. But I'd bang her.
What about abuela? ☹️
AOC is not a poor woman she makes a nice living yet when that hurricane hit her grandmothers home in Puerto Rico she didn’t help her and left her living in a battered filthy shack and when Matt Walsh tried to make a gofundme for her abuela AOC got it denied she doesn’t care about the prison system she doesn’t even care about her own family
Not at all. She is psychotic.
So out of touch are all Democrats
A girl on here as some kind of question about why do people deny racism or don't want to talk about it. I just told her to the race card has been played so many times that we're tired of it. Nancy pelosi said the southern border wall is racist. And inanimate object is racist. Now AOC thanks prisons are racist.
Prison isn't racist. It's underfunded and mismanaged, but not racist. Also the justice service is fucking autistic because I can't get a copy of VISOR (UK sex offender list).
Only the American sex offender lists are online. The British one isn't. Anyhoo, whatever'll make Putin part from his cash...
Lol like what? Slavery.
No hell no.
no, jails are good
Hell NO!!!
You can also add your opinion below!
Most Helpful Opinions