What political system would you support in WW1 if you could change the actual situation?

[IesusHominumSalvator]

Democracy, i love feminism, LGBT, pacifism and equality

Fascist dictatorship, i love power, discipline, honor and superiority,

Communist dictatorship, i want to destroy prívate property and hierarchy

Catholic monarchy, I like good, beauty, order... Truth and Good must be above liberal anarchy and madness

[Guy13]

Your question is both a false positive and negative. It is fallacious and incomplete.

Republic is the correct option and it is not present. Know your Data before you publish such a thing please. USA Constitution is the place for you to start. USA is not a Democracy. Democracy is mob rule that turns into Communism or some sort of disciplined dictatorship. Study the Constitution.

[IesusHominumSalvator]

Your country is both a republic and a democracy, USA is a representative democracy in which you choose A OR B to represent you... You have said it right: democracy is mob rule that turns into communism or some sort of disciplined dictatorship, that's why slowly you are losing freedom, and soon they will remove your guns or your private property.

[Guy13]

No. It is a Republic. You know not what you are saying. Read the Constitution

[IesusHominumSalvator]

Yes it is a republic and also it is a democracy... That's why you have republicans and democrats... Go to read what is a republic and read what is a democracy and you will see that your country is both.

[Exterminatore]

I’d institute clerical fascism or a theocracy with Christ at the head.

[IesusHominumSalvator]

God bless you brother, let's fight for the social reign of Christ our lord

[Exterminatore]

Amen. God bless you too brother!

[andreasderjuengere]

I cannot possibly say how I would have been raised back then. My family in the early 1900's supported (German) monarchy... bad luck :D

Seeing who I am as per today, and thinking myself back some 100 years: I might attempt to joint the French overseas forces and... silently disappear :)

That changes nothing - I know. But trying to stop an avalanche is plain stupid.

[MCheetah]

Can't tell if you're joking or serious. And if you're not joking, I'm going to go ahead and leave...

[DryGermanGuy]

What fascism and communism would there have been in World War 1 (1914-1918) ?

[IesusHominumSalvator]

The doctrines were there already, marxism was from 1863 and fascism was simply the response to fight the marxism and capitalism.

[DryGermanGuy]

There still were not any country using them as political system, so your question makes no sense at all.

[Exterminatore]

@Dry

Incorrect. 1917 the communists took over Russia and put Russia out of the war.

WW1 did not end until 1918.

[DryGermanGuy]

@Exterminatore
Please don't explain European history to me, my family was quite literally in the midst of it.
I guess we can safely say that a revolutionary year does not start with something so intricate as a whole political system, ready to apply to a country, a people, a world war? Easily confirmed by the fact that it started the Russian civil war, which was not over until 1923.

[Exterminatore]

@dry

When you state no country was using communism or fascism during WW1 you need European history explained you.

Your statement is incorrect. I corrected you. Period.

[DryGermanGuy]

No, I stand by what I wrote. It's obvious that a country switching its political system by a bloody revolution, followed by a civil war does not have its systemic handbook ready to apply at the drop of a hat, that's impossible. 1917 saw every faction for or against Lenin, Mensheviks, Bolsheviks, Trotzkyists... trying to duke it out, for what should be their ultimately implemented system. So nothing was set in stone until after the civil war.
And the start of fascism is best associated with Italy's Mussolini and his rise to power in 1922.

[Exterminatore]

@dry

You are correct about fascism. You are incorrect about communism, though all you stated in your last message was accurate.

It’s not a question of if they were organized enough, the official political system of Russia in 1917 was communism. Whether it was a Leninist form or Stalinist form or Trotsky form makes no difference. Whether it was very functional or not also doesn’t matter. The point is that was the official political system of Russia at that time.

[Hispanic-Cool-Guy]

You give extreme choices. There needs to be balanced in approach to political ideas and government to establish justice and fairness.

I pick none of your choice.

[Bee-Hatch]

Have you been on the meth again?

[IesusHominumSalvator]

Drugs are for liberals and inferior people

[USLegionary]

None. WW1 needed to happen.

[OddBeMe]

Which country was democratic in WW1?

[IesusHominumSalvator]

WW1 was to impose the demonic democracy, and the corrupted republics like the weimar republic, or the Spanish republic, breaking with that 3000 years of tradition and monarchy, that's how fascism began a few years later, to try to stop marxism and democracy.

[OddBeMe]

you're right, freedom sucks. We shoulda kept the warmongering kings that started the damn war.

[IesusHominumSalvator]

You were not that free when they imprisoned you 2 years in your house for a flu...

What warmongering kings? are you talking about the Bush killing 1.4 million iraquies?

[OddBeMe]

I’m talking about the colonialist empires that slaughtered African and South American tribes. But yes, warmongering Americans are also guilty. Funny how Biden is getting blamed FOR pulling out Afghan.

[OddBeMe]

And we werent imprisoned. I chose not to infect my neighbors. Which i guess you did.

[IesusHominumSalvator]

Then why the Spanish america is full of mixed people if they killed all the natives? and Africans have enslaved and killed each other from centuries... is better to have them enslaved and feeding them 3 times per day with a dentist, than let them starve in "freedom" in africa.

[Aiko_E_Lara]

Democracy without the feminism.

[-Asca-]

Cooperative libertarian socialist democracy.

[Shyfemguy]

The first one of course, it's the right path.

[Chazmatazz269]

The Labour Party

[Avicenna]

A is my choice

[MCheetah]

It's a trap.

[In_Trance]

None