What are your opinions about the great replacement theory?

Question

Anonymous · Accepted Answer

It’s obviously real. Lefties will say that it’s a far-right conspiracy theory, and in their next breathe they’ll say that the increasing percentage of non-whites is a great thing to be celebrated.

Places, workplaces and teams are often accused of having a lack of diversity when the large majority of members are white, but never when the majority are non-white.

I’m not a fan of football (or “soccer” for the Americans) but right now the World Cup is on I think. I’m seeing European teams accused of being too white. I’m not seeing any African teams being accused of being too black, or Asian teams being accused of being too Asian.

That’s actually all that diversity really means: more non-white people. Less white people.

There’s nobody who we could vote for who’d close the borders. Such a leader would not be allowed to win in the first place.

Sometimes people like Trump come into power because they say all the right things to impress the people who’d like to do that leading up to an election, but once they’re voted in they do nothing of the sort. They’re always pro-immigration.

In the UK our “conservative” government always promises to lower immigration levels, but more immigrants come in under them than do when Labour are in power.

Social media companies also do their best to censor people who are anti-immigration. That’s one of the reasons the left are losing their minds over Elon Musk taking over Twitter, although just like Trump he’s also not as much of a threat to their agenda as they think he is.

Therefore there’s nothing we can do to prevent it, and we’re punished for speaking about it openly. People lose their jobs, and in some cases their banking services for doing so, or they’re arrested.

Therefore it’s forced by people who want this to happen. Who’ll say “it’s not happening” one minute, and then “it’s a good that it’s happening” the next.

BeMuse · Accepted Answer

The funny thing is, the minority groups do not even like each other. Every minority has a high degree of ethnocentrism/racism. Whites are the least racist and most likely to work with other groups of people. When Whites lead, ever group is able to negotiate with Whites. The minority groups will always self segregate and be unwilling to compromise with one another. The larger their power blocks get, the more parties you will end up with. Thus the more divided the nation will become. No one group will be able to get to a majority vote without compromise. Thus, White's could be 10% of the population and still be the leaders and get everything they want, because they are able to negotiate and are petty racists like the other groups.

purplepoppy · Accepted Answer

Where does it say what percentage white, black, Asian, etc America should be?

If your beloved Constitution, the one you people treat like the sequel to the Bible, says all men are created equal, then why does it matter if America turns black?

You replaced the Indians pretty quickly so you can't really complain if you're rep replaced.

If blacks, Asians, Mexicans etc are out competing you for jobs because their better educated and trained, then try working harder at school rather than getting your info from alternative-news sites and you'll be an able to afford more kids.

Finally, there's no secret government department orchestrating this. Populations have been shifting for millennia.

letuswaltzforthedead · Accepted Answer

I don't agree with how racists and white supremacists put it. They usually talk about it as foreigners all being bad and other races being inferior therefore must be removed. It's evident that your average American will look different in the next future decades, that's just obvious demographics. Will it be a problem? I'd say so, not because of the racist talking out (which I don't agree with), but because it'll change the culture. I think it's important for a country to maintain their culture and people, if you're the United States, most people should be Americans. Their race doesn't really matter though, just whether foreigners assimilate or not and whether Americans still have children.

Lliam · Answer

I'm not worried about it. I don't trust projections, either.

As far as I'm concerned, the only difference between Latin Americans and other Americans is language and culture. It's not racial. Although there are quite a few indigenous people south of the border.

America has never been homogeneous. Its history since colonization didn't develop over thousands of years into a race and culture. It is a land of immigrants, mostly western Europeans, at first. Each wave of immigrants was met with hostility but they eventually assimilated after a generation or two.

But French were here. And what is the entire western USA once belonged to Spain and then Mexico. So why should Mexicans be seen as foreigners?

With all the legal immigrants from all over the world, it's not surprising that demographics will change. And our culture will be enriched. Just think of all the wonderful ethnic food!

jshm2 · Answer

It's not really a "theory"

Populations have come and gone, as have empires. They get replaced by immigrants or wars.

The elephant in the room is that the USA 99.5% replaced the Natives by killing them off and taking their land. They even celebrate it every year as "Thanksgiving" (the only country to do so).

Hence the "great replacement" really gets people laughing at Americans, as it's the pot calling the kettle black. No other country has killed more of it's natives and others than the USA.

Soteris · Answer

It would be so much better if this theory was just created because of racism but in reality this is pushed by people explicitly to manipulate and exploit you with lies and deceit. It is a conspiracy theory and should be treated the same way as those who believe in a flat earth.

MCheetah · Answer

It's inevitable as the world becomes globalized. You can't imply "white people are getting replaced and going extinct" when it's happening to all races. In 100 to 150 years, almost everyone will be mixed race. Who even cares about this BS? There is nothing special about "racial purity" at all, and only dense extremely-insecure people believe that.

DaveJord · Answer

It's happened in California in my lifetime. Whites went from being 70% of the total to now being less than 50% and Hispanics being the largest demographic.

But that is all I am saying, it probably going to happen regardless, because even most Hispanics today are mixed white... and that mixing is not going to stop... so it will all balance out at some point. they will become less Hispanic and we will become less white.

normalice · Answer

It is a dog whistle constructed because the billionaires who just want more tax cuts know no one is stupid enough to vote republican based on merit.

Berethor · Answer

The theory seems to be true, it's mostly white countries that get overrun and facing extinction.

LaineyLuiza · Answer

It is already too far gone to reverse with mass migration of panhandling parasites

misogynistic_pig · Answer

It's the Europeans' fault for not knowing how to control their women.

Anonymous · Answer

How else can you explain encouraging open borders and illegal aliens?

John_Doesnt · Answer

It's a white supremacist calling card and not a real threat.

notwoke · Answer

it guarantees that the USA is doomed to look like the countries these people are fleeing

MendaciousMarxist · Answer

No excuse to be a racist bastard

CloudMassacre · Answer

I think it’s dumb and racist

FunkyMonkee · Answer

Whatever that might be.

SmokinAces2000 · Answer

It’s a white supremacist talking point

msc545 · Answer

Paranoid and grossly obtuse.

What are your opinions about the great replacement theory?

Most Helpful Opinions

What Girls & Guys Said

What are your opinions about the great replacement theory?

Most Helpful Opinions

What Girls & Guys Said

We're glad to see you liked this post.