Is the "Great Replacement" merely a conspiracy theory or a legitimate concern?

[Physics-Man]

Great Replacement states that, with the complicity or cooperation of Global and Liberal "replacist" Elites and their advancement of Cultural Marxism, the Indigenous White European populations at large—is being demographically and culturally replaced with non-European peoples—specifically Arab, Berber, South Asians and sub-Saharan Muslim populations from Africa and the Middle East—through mass migration, demographic growth and a European drop in the birth rate.

Conspiracy

Legitimate

[TheFlak38]

When experts demographers foresee this happening, when our governments keep the borders open for the never-ending masses of invaders while we are sitting home because much lockdown, when we are forced to pay taxes to feed the millions of invaders and destroy our nature to house them and when every opposition to these policies is being systematically criminalised then it stops being a conspiracy theory. It's just a conspiracy. The solution isn't to produce more children. No matter how many kids we make, when the borders are wide open to the rest of the planet you're being demographically overrun.

[Dargil]

It's been happening since the Immigration Act of 1965. The USA and Western Europe will face a decision, respectively. Oblivion, Ethnic Cleansing through deportation or partitioned homelands. We will have to become the exact fascists they have accused of us of already being. We will have to cull out the makers from the takers among the illegals and escort the latter to our southern border or homelands.

[hellionthesagereborn]

No, at least not intentionally. If you look most of Europe is still over 90% white. What it is, in my opinion, is cover for pushing clearly socialistic and racist policies. Like voting laws in the US for example, every one with any sense can tell you that having an ID to vote isn't racist, we have ID's to rent, get a job, drive a car, buy cigarettes and alcohol, get a loan, etc. etc. etc. and expecting an ID from every one does not discriminate against one group except arguablly rural people (which are predominantly white as blacks are far more concentrated in urban areas). We all know this, their is no debate on this what so ever (not if you have even a modicum of common sense. In fact the claim that its racist is itself racist as it implies that minorites are incappable of doing a very basic task that whites do every day). However it gives democrats/progressives an excuse to make our voting system weaker and more susceptible to fraud (as they are prone to use and have proven as much) and that is a benefit to them. Any damage it causes to others or the long term viability of the nation is irrelevant to them because they only care about themselves.

So I think that is what is happening in Europe, evil selfish people using these groups as an excuse to pass laws that would otherwise not get passed, or to push an agenda that would otherwise not be accepted.

[BeMuse]

It’s a communist asymmetric political weapon where refugees are used as pawns to foster a domestic political and foreign policy crisis. They aim to extort America for international aid and preferential treatment in regards to economic sanctions as well as to change political behavior through engineered migration. Through cultural fragmentation and by exploiting American principles in relation to human rights, they are able to subvert American cultural and political decisions while simultaneously increasing the cost of welfare, unemployment, crime, and ethnic tensions in our country. Plain and simple it is an attack in a larger war. Those letting it happen or even worse encouraging it are idiots. It's like giving locations for fuel dumps and weapons factories to the enemy so that they can bomb them. People are stupid.

[crmoore]

I have no doubt some people are actively trying to do it, but I don't think there's like a secret plot where elites around the world got together to do this. I just think it's an effective strategy for certain political parties, thus it is being inactive by several people likely independent of one another. This might be a silly example, but if you give a bunch of cave men shovels and many of them start digging, that doesn't mean they got together and decided to do it, it just means it was a reasonable thing to do for their goals.

[crmoore]

Inacted*

[Achilles1]

Definitely a legit occurrence.

It's funny that Europe, or White majority countries are hounded by the media, NGO's, the UN and activists to accept large hoards of illegals, yet oil rich Arab countries, Israel or Asian countries never are...

[TadCurious]

It's a fact that the globalist elites have had this very thing in mind for a long time. And sadly they have gone a very long way in being able to implement it. They don't see Western Civilization as something worth conserving and preserving.

[Avicenna]

Well, it seems to me the actions and in some cases the words of these elites should answer that clearly.

[FilmGuy93]

That's actually not a conspiracy theory at all. That is an expressed goal of these groups, in no uncertain terms.

[Anonymous]

They know that they won't be able to institute a world government while white people are in power. That is why biden is trying to remove the guns. Disarm the country before imposing even more drastic changes

[Anonymous]

Europeans on average are having less babies than other parts of the world. I'm not sure that amounts to them being actively replaced.

[Sargentcaptain]

Do morons who spread this not realize that the biggest problem here is white people not having kids, you know, something they can easily solve themselves?

[Celtero]

My perspective on it is... who cares? Whites already have shown they don't particularly care about their own group so if they get replaced then good riddance.

[MasterOfReality]

Yes, it is apparent and obvious by the agenda they push.

[Soteris]

The replacement theory is literally just racist scaremongering nonsense. Has about as much legitimacy as the flat earth theory and should be viewed even more negatively since at least flat earth people are not necessarily horrible racist people.

[Physics-Man]

Can you support your claims? Show me that indigenous Europeans won't become the minority in a number of European countries by the end of the century. White British are already a minority in London.

[Avicenna]

Leftists emote and think proof is racist, so you won’t get him to back up his claim. He just wants to denounce people who share different opinions.

[Soteris]

Well first of all the burden of proof is entirely on your side as the one that is making the claim, as such I am in the very comfortable situation of just having to tell you "You are wrong, prove it to me first."

However since I know you people have no idea how basic rhetoric works I will put myself at a disadvantage and be the first to provide evidence of why you are wrong and should feel stupid. First of all its important to give it the right name because its not actually the "Great replacement" now is it? Its the "White genocide" rebranded because you people realized how stupid you sounded and how badly you did convincing people so change the name and try again.

Now, as if I even have to say this, there is obviously no evidence of white people being killed off/genocide and to be honest that is just the most obvious fear mongering I have ever heard.
"Help! They are taking over and are going to kill us all! Save us from the evil foreigners!". Fucking pussies the lot of you, are you not ashamed of being part of a movement that is so obviously driven simply by scared insecure people?

[Soteris]

Now, speaking of cultures! "Oh noes! They will outbreed us!" or whatever other nonsense. Dont care. No, honestly I could not care about any of this. I am not less "Swedish" because people of Arabic decent moves to my country and I think that is very demonstrable with the whole "Anglo-Saxon" fetish Americans have.

"Oh we are proud of our Anglo-Saxon heritage!". No you are not. No one goes around claiming they are Anglo-Saxons anymore, we talk in terms of British or Welsh or Americans. Anglo-Saxon culture is dead which is completely natural. Just like how Saxons dont exist anymore or how Anglians dont exist anymore, it really means piss-all.

If you were worried about the "great replacement theory" why have you not complained about the advent of Americans? Because that is not what scares you is it? You are worried about that scary foreigner coming over here and being just a tiny bit too close for comfort. You sicken me scardycat.

[Avicenna]

Well, thanks for proving my point that leftists merely emote. As a reminder, here is the claim you made:

"The replacement theory is literally just racist scaremongering nonsense."

Facts and evidence is what you need to marshal, not more childish shrieking. That is, if those facts actually exist...

But I'm sure all we'll get is more shrieking...

[Soteris]

@Avicenna No, I was responding to OP over there hiding his opinion behind a thinly veiled vapid question regarding the "great replacement theory" which is further reinforced by his reply to me. That is the original claim in this discussion and considering there was no serious attempt to justify this I am equally under no obligations to provide counter-evidence to disprove his literally non-existent evidence.

That said I went above and beyond even still to prove I was correct. Let me list them now for your lazy convenience:
1: I do not hold the burden of proof. Objectively true.
2: The Replacement theory is just a rebranding of an already disproved racist movement called White Genocide. Everything that applied against White genocide still applies to this.
3: The whole argument makes no sense since it claims you are somehow a victim of being replaced when you are never actually replaced and nothing happens to you. Its all about being upset that other people have the audacity to exist on the same planet as you do without your consent.
4: Until proven otherwise there is no foundation behind this theory except for white people who are afraid and acting all emotional about it.
5: The whole culture thing is complete and utter nonsense and just boils down to racist stereotypes of other races and cultures such as how they "breed like rabbits" or how they seduce your women. Pathetic really.
6: It is also highly hypocritical since the supposed replacement has happened countless times throughout even recent history without anyone even bothering to comment on it and is happening this very day around the world but here you two fuck boys are seaming to think this is unique and targeting you specifically. No, you are not special snowflakes and until you speak up about this "problem" elsewhere then its just a sad excuse to hide your actual racist intent of attempting to deny foreigners.

[Anonymous]

Statistics show that it is true

[itsnotme123]

The levels of irony here are apocalyptic

[Anonymous]

Totally ridiculous like every conspiracy theory.