Do you believe the great replacement theory of overtaking countries and their native population with a massive influx of migrants is real or a myth?

Question

ArtemisSilver · Accepted Answer

It's a thing, but mostly because we've strangled the hope out of our lower and middle class to the point where the population is collapsing.

Seems to be an issue endemic to late stage capitalism.

The bandaid is of course to import people to replace the ones that aren't breeding anymore, but it doesn't fix the rot at the heart of the system, and eventually it erodes and destroys the original culture. It also imports problems from the countries of origin like rape gangs and organized crime.

Just look at Paris France, with the most common given name being Mohammed. I bear no particular ill will to Muslims, it's just a less than subtle hint that the French culture is dying.

Rather than blaming the immigrants for wanting to better there lives I think we should in the west collectively reflect on what is causing the population collapse and try to create social conditions that don't turn our cities into Golgothas (locuses of death).

It's not race related at it's heart though, because the same thing is happening in Japan, they're just letting the population drop to protect their culture instead of delaying the issue like we have been elsewhere in the west.

Don't get me wrong, there's a lot of hate directed at white people specifically, and some people are using their privileged positions of corporate power to persue their own vendettas, but I wouldn't go as far as Alex Jones and call it an intentional white genocide.

It can definitely be frustrating at times, I often see new immigrants get prefered loans and other better treatment than locals. Regardless of intent this is going to push some disaffected whites towards extremist views.

There's also a push from the identity politics crowd to bundle whites, particularly white men as a monolithic group to be hated and reviled, which again leads to a shift towards tribalist thinking, as whites band together out of a perceived need to defend themselves.

It's getting harder each day for people like myself to hold the middle ground and try to bridge viewpoints. Being constantly attacked by both sides is not for the faint of heart. However without considered moderates and compromise we're doomed to a bloody future.

exitseven · Accepted Answer

It is real. There is a couple of small cities about a hundred miles away. 25 years ago I used to have a few customers there and I went there twice a year. About 15 years ago so called asylum seekers started arriving. There was a movie made about this. A so called charity will get asylum seekers at the border and distribute them in cities that are mostly Republican. Soon one of my customers moved their facility. There was a large public park that has been taken over by drug dealers. The cops have given up and just tell white people to stay away from there at night. This "charity" gets paid by how many illegals they can bring.
This place used to be a pretty nice place to live. Now the property values have plummeted and nobody wants to live there. Now they have liberal mayors and all the bad liberal policies that are turning all our cities into war zones.

Screenwriter · Accepted Answer

The native population of the United States were American Indian tribes. The "immigrants" were the British, Dutch, Portuguese, Spanish, Germans, Italians, Irish in the 16 to 1800s.

In those 200 years white Europeans who became Americans planned to take over the lands of Native Americans, intermarried with them, diluting and, in many cases, wiping out native tribes through introduced diseases, outright genocide or forced assimilation.

What is happening today is not "replacement," but a similar process of change through new people coming to America. If there are no new people, the country will die. This is a fact for any land. The idea that it is a political "plot" is the height of foolishness.

It has become a "threat" to some Caucasian people because they will no longer be in political power in 20 years or so. But living nations change. Another group of people will be in the majority in 25 years past THAT time. For ultra right wing people to try to predict who will be the dominant political party and how those people will vote is fearmongering.

Spotifyplaylist · Accepted Answer

I feel like it has been discussed a lot but honestly its 2022 anything could happen.

007kingifrit · Answer

depends on how you word it, do i believe there is a shadowy cabal of evil satanists making it happen on purpose? no.

do i think there is a loose group of social classes who benefit from mass migration and want cheaper wages so they let/make it happen independent of one another? yes

do i think diversity inherently damages a society as the new groups want to get rid of "replace" old ways because humans are tribal creatures that stick together? yes

do i have TONS of historical examples of this happening as immigrants wipe out the local population and take territory? yes. in 1700 cambodia invited refugess from vietnam into the mekong delta... the mekong delta is now part of vietnam. or how about... the entire continent of north america and south america?

RealMarek · Answer

It’s obviously real, as one can find numerous academic, NGO, and Davos statements advocating it. These are merchant elites, and as such they want a uniform population of mass consumers with no cultural characteristics or familial institutions that might serve as nodes of resistance.

Anonymous · Answer

I don't believe in this but if I did it's not by the groups they think it's is.

Asians out compete fincicnally white men
Indian and east Asian etc. I mean look at china right now. And India slowly moving up.

Latinos out work the lower class and middle class white men. And do majority of the trade jobs

a lot white dudes are lgbt now. Or incel MGTOW, They came up with that 80%20 woman rule.
Or ln the spectrum

White people are fighting each other again Russia ukrianke stuff.

That might be the reason they taking away women rights to force white women to have kids.

Look at the white birth rate compared to the death rate.

I don't know why people think black people are going to do it. Sure there's a lot of us that complete at the high level but not collectively.

I don't know about forien blacks like Africans hatians etc.

TheFlak38 · Answer

When expert demographers says that it's happening then to deny it you must be either stupid or ideological motivated.

BillyBalls · Answer

I think the Democrats are counting on it. Why else are they willing to have open borders with all the extra social services needed to deal with the inflow.

WhiteBoyChill · Answer

100%. I mean liberals are ranting nonstop about how evil and oppressive and racist our country is, and how we need to be more accepting of other people, otherwise anyone who objects is a bigot

Anonymous · Answer

Great replacement theory isn’t correct term. The democrats are using that to say it’s racially replacing white people. It’s about influencing voter demographics.

anylolone · Answer

Blacks in the US are being replaced by immigrants. That's an objective fact.

SignedAutographs · Answer

It's a racists way of saying "im racist, and I don't care"

Anonymous · Answer

All a big distraction. These nut jobs get wound up and let go to distract from the real problems

Do you believe the great replacement theory of overtaking countries and their native population with a massive influx of migrants is real or a myth?

Most Helpful Opinions

What Girls & Guys Said

Do you think its politically incorrect to say replacement theory isn't a theory but a fact backed up by actual data and migration trends globally?

Do you believe the great replacement theory of overtaking countries and their native population with a massive influx of migrants is real or a myth?

Most Helpful Opinions

What Girls & Guys Said

Do you think its politically incorrect to say replacement theory isn't a theory but a fact backed up by actual data and migration trends globally?

We're glad to see you liked this post.