
Which type of immigration is beneficial to America?


I think what needs to happen is people need to change their perceptions just a bit for any policy to work. There needs to transparency and what happens right now is you have people with skewed perception based on presumed facts. You have people from either side giving worst case scenarios that give people the impression with few places we can look to verify the information. They do this because people in fear are easier to control. Look at Covid. Not debating covid but look at how easy it was for them to control things. So now they paint a picture of nothing but rapist and drug mules coming over the border and I'm sure that there is. I don't know how it works but my opinion is that I rather have documented people than undocumented. It's not an easy fix though if we look at people coming as problems then they will be treated poorly and become problems. We also have to look inward and realize that drugs are a problem and we blame everybody for bringing drugs into America. We spend an obscene any of money trying to stop this. Money to find these people and arrest them so we can support them while they are in prison. I'm curious if we spent the same amount of money on research finding a way to stop the demand for these drugs. If we didn't have the demand for this stuff people willing to spend a lot of money for these drugs we wouldn't have people trying to get them here. We can't have a free for all or open borders either that didn't go well for my fellow Natives either. Bottom line is we need Data and information that we can trust to make the best decisions Not
politicians
Well unfortunately we already have the data & info about the demand but no matter what we have politicians don't like to place their policies directly on what would be better (especially cause it would hurt their bottom line and doesn't fit their personal values).
We would have to fix a few huge issues in the country before the demand would be substantially reduced enough really. Its just easier for politicians to claim its another country's fault.
When we have talented, educated people who want to come to America through legal means, open businesses, get jobs , pay taxes and contribute to society. With Biden we are getting just the opposite. We have indigent, uneducated illegal aliens, some are criminals and terrorists, that cannot support themselves and require the taxpayers to give them everything. There are diseases that have made a comeback here that haven't been seen in decades. Polio, leprosy, diphtheria and others have been brought in across the southern border that Bidan had sworn to protect right along with enough fentanyl to kill everyone in California.
The current style of immigration is actually pretty beneficial (people love to lie/ignore this). BUT I could see a merit & majority-refugee style immigration system being better for our so called problems. Also honestly the U. S. should push other countries governments to increase the quality of life of countries where the most people emigrate from.
When I helped immigrants come to America, they had to be vetted by the FBI and gone through a medical exam to make sure they aren't bringing diseases into the country.
For some strange reason, Biden has just opened the flood gates and even known terrorists are entering the US illegally.
Tuberculosis. Aedes mosquito–transmitted arboviral diseases (dengue, chikungunya, Zika) Enteric diseases (Vibrio, Listeria monocytogenes, nontyphoidal Salmonella, Brucella spp.)
I don't want children in America to come down with diseases, but many Americans don't care about children at all.
@exitseven maybe through Ellis island in 1800s…..
@OddBeMe My wife's grandfather came through Ellis island in in the early 1900s. He had the whole routine, he had a job as a mason and had a physical and he had a sponsor who signed for him. We actually went to Ellis Island and were able to find his name on a ship's manifest. He actually went through ellis Island twice because he went back to Italy during WW1 to fight in the Italian Army and after the war he came back to the US.
@exitseven
He flat out doesn't care about viruses coming into the country. He also doesn't care about terrorists, rapists, drug dealers or killers coming into the country. He's not alone, though, many Americans hate America.
Viruses we have treatments for. Thats actually a case for opening legal immigration more. We keep closing it off there’s more illegals coming in with less incentive to get medical checks.
But even so, they spread tuberculosis it can be cured in a week. It ain’t Doc Holiday times huckleberry.
Opinion
12Opinion
Legal skilled workers and highly educated people coming here to fill roles and pay taxes. Every other country from Canada, to Australia to New Zealand to China to the middle east does this except the US who have an open boarder policy allowing more than we can cope with driving down wages.
1. Skilled people are certified as skilled already. If a job requires a degree you just don't say that you have a degree. It's up to immigrants to have the credentials and that's how the current immigration system is supposed to work.
2. It's not up to the United States or US taxpayers to train or educate immigrants. We do give out student and vocational visas. If a company wants to employ a worker and train them that should be up to them or if a foreign student can pat for their college no problem. We already do this but a visa is not citizenship, perhaps they can earn their citizenship or perhaps not.
@findacure4wokeness And that’s our immigration policy. “Your people” and “those people”. Maybe I align myself with productive people who won’t mooch welfare. Including billionaires who think they own a country.
@findacure4wokeness no I’ll stay in the country I invested in, thanks.
@findacure4wokeness all those boomer Liberals became Conservatives when the realised they'd have to reach into their pockets and its the same with most Liberals today as soon as they realise that socialism comes out of their pockets not some bottomless pit of government money.
I don't see any left wingers down at the soup kitchen. Or volunteering with the church.
We saw at Martha's vineyard how Liberals worked. They were quick to post on social media about how great they were bringing sandwiches and bottled water to the local christian church but out of the thousands of vacant rooms, homes, hotel rooms and inns they couldn't find space for 50 migrants who had to sleep locked in on the church floor under guard of the local police until an armed unit of the national guard arrived to move them on like vagrants.
@OddBeMe Well white people are by far the biggest hand out givers but nobody seems to be grateful. The beggars have become entitled wanting everything we worked hard for Even when taking our countries and homes they lay claim to it all. Concern for others well being is very much a one way street.
@drewtate Make Martha's vineyard diverse again!
Yes biggest economies yet working and middle class people are fleeing to red states. Why is this? High taxes, low wages, crime etc make them bad places to live if you are working or middle class.
Socialist China has a huge economy and high rate of employment yet in factories they had to put up special netting around tall factory buildings because despairing workers had a habit of throwing themselves off them.
Pretty sure my grandparents funded their social security from decades of taxes on their paid employment. They aren't being given anything that isn't theirs already. Socialists in Cali & NY would love to sticky their fingers in this taxpayer funded pension scheme & dole it out to everyone
Absolutely. Why do you think they never pass this kind of stuff. Senators and congressmen are all about getting elected next term and pleasing their corporate sponsors. That's why you see them "railing against the system" and "cleaning up the swamp". Remember AOC protesting and crying outside a wire fence that later turned out to be an empty carpark rather than some place where illegals children were locked up in dog kennels, it looked good on her reelection promos. I'm sure you've a few for Republicans doing similar filibusting and soapboxing
Please link to Democrat bills that call for tax cuts for billionaires. Cuz all I’m seeing…
www.theguardian.com/.../trump-tax-cuts-helped-billionaires-pay-less
The left does not want more tax on the rich, they are among the rich. That's their election platform. If they wanted taxes on the rich they'd have done it already and honestly the rich don't have income to tax. Guys like Jeff Bezos they don't own anything anymore to tax. Democrats will tax the middle classes and anything people enjoy as well as gas and then blow the money on nonsense social justice programmes like LGBTQ lessons in Thailand schools.
It's very much like the left wing 1%ers of Martha's vineyard. Left wing politics are great but when 50 illegals arrive at their doorsteps they lock them up in a church for two nights under armed guard rather than let them stay a few nights in the thousands of vacant rooms and homes, then of course virtue signal by posting on fbook about how they brought them a few bottles of water and bought them pizzas b4 the national guard arrived to bus them to the next town.
Legal, regulated immigration of people who both speak English and are likely to contribute to society. No freeloaders who are just here for handouts like the scum Biden has let flood across the border, they should be sent back immediately and shot if they are caught trying to come back.
i like the irish and the mexicans. they are hard workers. when companies outsource, that really pisses everyone off. i would see sites like amazon and the like investigated for slave labor
you fucking white immigrant i'm COMING FOR YOU!
@findacure4wokeness not sure I follow. White people are in charge, I’d say of 80%+ of America, despite the skin color ratios. So yes my people has the power and opportunity.
Illegal Mexicans don’t. And the next cancer cure could be in the head of a migrant at the southern border right now.
@findacure4wokeness mmm…decades of aid funding right wing murderous Juntas and dictators. AND you’ll find a lot of America’s “innervations” were created by immigrants and their prodigies.
@OddBeMe are they the murderous Right wingers that aren't allowed to live in an area by themselves? Are they the same Right wingers that others risk life and limb to live with? So terrible we are but we are followed to the ends of the earth. their stomachs are in the west but their hearts are in the place they left.
no, no, no. jews do not consider themselves white people
@findacure4wokeness again I’m not sure who these “right wingers” you’re talking about. The migrants are the ones doing the hard jobs in America and getting shit on by right wingers.
@Sevenpointfive Zionist Jews believe they are the master race and need to destroy white people so they can make us all slaves.
@findacure4wokeness they created fake money and made themselves rich by usuary. if stupid people play along then they've won already
Legal immigration from people with the intent to become Americans and integrate and adopt American ideals.
None. Zero. We don’t need them. If anything go back to where you came from.
Darn. You mean we don’t already have doctors in America? No medical schools either?
Try again.
And no. No immigrants influenced my life for the better. My city has enough taco trucks and maid services already.🖕🙄
American born citizens dont want to work the dirty jobs for little pay. dont lie to yourself.
@PrincessAlis true, and immigrants have a work ethic because they traveled through muck and horror to get here. So bad they’re kids complain about being over pressured lol
Legal immigrants, like for example Elon Musk.
White immigration
Why? there's just as much as bloat in white communities. In fact I could argue taking most unemployment receiving Americans and swapping them for the people at the southern border wanting to get in and make something of themselves.
These fcking whites had their whole fucking lives to.
You could make that argument, But taking people that built a first world country and replacing it with people who couldn't is an argument I could put forward. They have an in group preference like all non whites do while white people like you have been indoctrinated to pretend to prefer other groups. We once had companion and concern for others while forced immigration and other groups demonizing our right to protect our spaces along with many other anti white agendas has sown anger and resentment among many white people today. if their people are so great then why are they fleeing their own countries then?
the Meccan Muslim's in Saudi araba murdered and raped their way across the whole middle east. yet they aren't obliged to help even their own, it seems Only us whites must pay for our sins is another double standard we aren't allowed to discuss. We are handing out to other groups that bite the hand the feeds them and they don't care about the cost to us, Our feelings, Our needs, Our safety are conversations they don't serve their greedy interests and are of no concern to them or the left.
Legal immigration lol.
@Drewtate should we be able to discuss whether or not they lowered the bar in order for that scientist to graduate? equity should never be threatened by truth.
@findacure4wokeness often the bar is not lowered. A lot of the scientists that come from the US have the intelligence & academic ability to do advanced degrees in the first place. We aren't just taking some guy who slogged through a degree because they managed to get a loan and a college acceptance letter.
For instance I was talking to a svottish girl a while back about their education system. Apparently they can leave school at 16. I asked if that makes it more difficult to get a job without a high school diploma but she said their schools don't do that at all, instead they do something called GCSE which is 6 or more individual subjects together and its equivalent to a high school diploma in the US. They can then stay on at school for doing something called A levels in 3 different subjects or do them in a community college day or night or opt to do a technical degree, now apparently these are the equivalent of 2 years of college degree in the us, apparently most UK students do this. Then they go on if they choose to go to university to study another 3-4 years of college. So UK kids are already graduated high school at age 16, done two years of college by 18 and go on to do another 4. Their kids are way ahead of ours.
@Drewtate I'm not allowed to question that so I guess you win by default. I'll just bury my face in the ass of the sheep in front of me.
Like always you fucks are wrong.
www.cnn.com/.../index.html
@OddBeMe great story but that med student is not a victim. If she graduates from med school she will be able to get a job anywhere in the world and command good money including in the country she is an actual citizen in China. The socialist Chinese government I'm sure would be more than happy to see her complete her education. I could understand her getting deported if she was studying gender studies. Fact is that her parents entered legally on a visa but weren't citizens and still are not citizens. She should apply for citizenship and abide by the federal government's decision.
@findacure4wokeness sorry no freedumb. gun. suckitbrandon links toay
@OddBeMe The big problem is that all white countries aren't allowed to say no to colored immigration at replacement levels. Instead of Immigrants expected to convince us of why this might be a good thing from us they act like the burden of proof is on us to proof that it isn't and then you cry foul and censor discussions they don't like. This isn't the only example of them not knowing there place. Immigration is nothing but trouble and doesn't benefit white people but some of us are charitable to a fault.
@findacure4wokeness Jews Will Not Replace Us! Were you at Charlottesville?
Culture is forever changing like dna. What you perceive as “white” is competency arbitrary.
@OddBeMe No group celebrates their replacement and the desire to preserve their race and culture is completely and universally understood. Do you respect other cultures as much as your own? They mostly respect their own ingroup. Diversity just means replacement of whites with people of their own kind. White people are burdened by other groups, the same groups that benefit from living with us. Go live in the 3rd world with them in a society their culture built rather then turning our counties into the places they came from.
@findacure4wokeness I respect others ideas and their preservation as long as it’s not interfering with others lives. And your idea of “RACE” is just that. You’d sacrifice many migrant lives to save your so called “race” which isn’t real.
@OddBeMe They aren't for us to save. Interfering and not helping are two different things anyway and it's disingenuous to imply otherwise. We aren't even allowed to draw a line anywhere and you and the left can't even respect our right to do so. You should humbly beg for charity and if you act like you have the right to just take what you need then you do not deserve it. Your people are being ungratefully used yet you love everyone else while hating your own kind. Charity starts at home.
@findacure4wokeness you right wingers are obsessed with being “respected” aren’t you?
The home owner's wish's should always be respected in regards to their property. Just like the 3rd worlder's wishes should be respected while visiting the 3rd world they have every right to deny entry to anyone they see fit and they owe nobody an explanation as to why. This shouldn't need to be explained to you. You have a common leftist respect and entitlement problem don't you? you are so anti white you want to deny white people even the most basic common decencies that the rest of humanity enjoys. People are waking up to this fact.
@findacure4wokeness damn straight!
The entitlement these illegal immigration advocates have is astounding. Coming into United States is a privilege, not a right.
You are literally for open borders. You don't want to check anyone, you just want unfettered illegal immigration and you are so stupefied that you can't even see how that is a bad thing.
"Illegal immigration causes an enormous drain on public funds. Accommodating the needs of endless numbers of poor, unskilled illegal entrants undermines the quality of education, healthcare and other services for Americans.
American workers must compete against job-desperate illegal immigrants, unfairly depressing the wages and working conditions offered to legal residents.
Illegal immigration overwhelms communities by crowding classrooms, consuming already limited affordable housing, and increasing the strain on precious natural resources.
Illegal Immigration compromises our nation's security, allowing potential terrorists to hide in the same shadows."
lamborn.house.gov/.../illegal-immigration
Actually it doesn’t. Idiotic policing causes a drain on public funds.
Immigration, legal or illegal, increases economic output.
scholar.google.com/.../biblio_socioabtract1_auteurs_resumes.doc&hl=en&sa=X&ei=dctuZbWGNLqR6rQPscmLsAU&scisig=AFWwaeanj6COeRjMnPY6VkLSJXbk&oi=scholarr
Did we screw it over? The America's apart from Canada, Greenland, & Caribbean all had their wars of independence and democracy around the same time as the United States yet nearly everyone of them is a basket case bannana Republic long before the US got involved. Why is Canada, Greenland & the United States so stable by comparison to our latin/Hispanic neighbours?
@findacure4wokeness unless we made them. Allende. Pinochet. Drug cartels. Nothing’s our fault?
Open boarders policy is creating a situation where kids are starving at the boarder. The more you allow in the more come until there are too many to be supported. Its a similar situation in Europe.
The Gaza massacre is entirely down to Hamas and the Palestinians. All they have to do for peace is to stop murdering Jews and using schools and hospitals etc as military bases
The USA is deliberately letting in all of these terrorists so they can take over the destabilized America when terrorist attacks happen. The open borders policy is part of WEF's plans.
Every crisis that happens is going to push us towards authoritarianism and people in power are going to argue that democracy does not work so there needs to be stricter controls.
Just like what happened with that covid nonsense.
@findacure4wokeness they don’t get welfare genius. They’re illegal.
@oddbeme They get hand outs in forms other then a check and in most countries they indeed get a fortnightly check. What's it like being a smart ass that's always wrong?
@findacure4wokeness please rephrase this. Apologies for the delay they froze my account for some reason.
The kind where people like you leave.
Legal immigration.
Then what's wrong with this Mexican migrant having that thought in Mexico?
I don't think all the fentanyl that's coming across our southern border killing Americans or all the sex trafficking of women and children is worth the possibility that one illegal might have an idea and invent something.
I get it... You are empathetic to All the people of the world who have it worse than we do. But bringing the world's poor here doesn't bring them up, it brings us down. America as a superpower can help other countries and we do. America as a shithole (and that's the direction we are heading) can't even help itself forget about the other countries.
And you may not like it but everything you have today you have BECAUSE of a conversation. You need to stop biting the hand that feeds you.
This is from https://www.nyc.gov/
Immigration is the New York story. It is the American story. But as I declared nearly a year ago, we are facing an unprecedented state of emergency due to the asylum seeker crisis,” said Mayor Adams. “Since last year, nearly 100,000 asylum seekers have arrived in our city asking for shelter, and we are past our breaking point. New York City has been left to pick up the pieces of a broken immigration system — one that is projected to cost our city $12 billion over the course of three fiscal years without policy changes and further support from the state and federal governments. Our compassion may be limitless, but our resources are not.
$12 billion dollars in the next 3 years? Where is that money coming from? TAX PAYERS! taxes have to go up. Services that the tax payers use will go down. Already have to cut 5-10% in many citizen services… higher taxes and less services that’s a reduction in quality of life… is it not? And this is NOT just NYC. This is all over.
California is now a giant tent city and shit all over the sidewalks… that too is a reduction in quality of life.
Tax money isn’t unlimited. Services aren’t unlimited either. The more people using the services will exhaust the system.
anybody but the irish 🤣
Legal.
The only opinion from girls was selected the Most Helpful Opinion, but you can still contribute by sharing an opinion!
You can also add your opinion below!