If there were a national vote to grant amnesty to only certain illegal immigrants, would you vote yes?

[Anonymous]

Specifically, the bill says that single females between 18 and 29 will be granted amnesty, and nothing else. No punishment for anyone else, and there is still potential amnesty for others in the future. Just that the focus right now is for this specific group, would you vote yes?

Vote yes

Vote no

See results

Updates

1 y

I should have called this "citizenship" and not "amnesty." It would be both in this scenario.

[Anonymous]

Lmfao even the lost left wing women in the country would be stopping these women from coming over. And making up the most BS excuses possible for it. Like pretending like it's a way to protect those women, instead of admitting it's a competition issue.

I'm surprised there aren't more guys saying yes though. Or maybe they won't be honest either.

[Opinion Owner]

Someone please tell me what the one girl's response was. I'm blocked by her.

[Asker]

It was something about how those women would be exploited for marriage.

[Opinion Owner]

So, exactly what I predicted in my top comment. Shocker. I tend to get blocked by sociopaths, so this all makes sense.

[Cubus]

Check the results of the presidential election, where illegal immigration was top 3 most important issues, and then say how the majority of the population would vote on your proposal.

[Asker]

There was nothing even remotely resembling my proposal though. Besides, GAG people are completely different than the average US population.

[Cubus]

I believe GAG is much closer to average US population than f. e. Reddit.

[Asker]

I hope so. If reddit represented the US average, we're doomed 😂

[AviatorTom]

Illegals who are allowed to stay in the country might have a future path to citizenship, but that should be codified into law and apply to everyone, not limited to a specific class or group of people.

There are already laws about granting amnesty. Just follow them, and enforce them, something that hasn't been consistently done.

[CupcakeTheDestroyer]

That just sounds like some excuse to have a mail-order bride, which is completely exploitative

[Asker]

No one would take away their rights in any way. They would already be here, so no mail order. They can consent or decline any form of relationship, just like anyone else.

[CupcakeTheDestroyer]

Amnesty doesn’t have the same rights as citizenship

[Asker]

Ahhh, you're right and I should have called this citizenship instead of amnesty because I was implying the former without being clear about it. Good catch.

But still, no rights would be taken by giving amnesty, of course.

[exitseven]

No, they all gotta go.

[Asker]

Well, I guess my dream of a 22 year old latina second wife ain't happening 😭

[lightbulb27]

2nd wife? you want to add to the one you have?

[Asker]

Yeah, but only until I can get a third wife. Preferably East Asian.

[lightbulb27]

Jesus, you're up to 3 wives now...
interesting idea to grow the economy, enable polygamy and marrying of immigrants.

[Pterodon]

I’d vote fuck no

[Asker]

What if they only let the hot ones stay?

[Pterodon]

For what?

[Asker]

To expand the dating pool

[Pterodon]

We have plenty of dateable women

[Asker]

Maybe you and I have plenty of options, but the average guy doesn't.

Do you think women would oppose this because they don't want competition in the dating market?

[Pterodon]

Interesting question. Some might