Could a female martial artist beat an average guy in street fight?

Question

Justify your opinion.

Answer 1

genericname85 | 121 opinions shared on Sports topic.

Master

nobody can beat a suckerpunch out of nowhere. real fights are nothing like in martial arts movies. in real life it's just one hit and one goes down in 99% if the cases (if there was such intention for violence in the first place)...

but if you pitch a female martial artist and a reasonably fit man with no idea about martial arts in a fighting position, where both are prepared to be attacked and supposed to knock the other out as fast as possible, i think a man would still have the higher chances die to pure strength and mass advantage.

React

3 People

genericname85

+1 y
also on average male reaction times are ever so slightly quicker than females. that's another edge they get.

Answer 2

genericname85

also on average male reaction times are ever so slightly quicker than females. that's another edge they get.

Answer 3

Riverotter

Xper 3

The average guys knows next to nothing about fighting, when I did martial arts size was a minor advantage but the top girls could beat anyone below 3rd degree black belt pretty easily

React

3 People

krancen

+1 y
How about purple belt? Does it mean she is highly skilled?
Riverotter

+1 y
No, it means she has learned the required material to get that far but it rarely involves anything more than technique. It takes a lot of work but that doesn't mean she can fight. Doesn't mean she can't either, but I wouldn't be scared of a purple belt, she knows how to punch and some fighting but hasn't trained to actually fight

Answer 4

krancen

How about purple belt? Does it mean she is highly skilled?

Answer 5

Riverotter

No, it means she has learned the required material to get that far but it rarely involves anything more than technique. It takes a lot of work but that doesn't mean she can fight. Doesn't mean she can't either, but I wouldn't be scared of a purple belt, she knows how to punch and some fighting but hasn't trained to actually fight

Answer 6

Appless

Xper 6

Yeah of course, the female would know what sort of techniques she would need to use to win the fight. Just because men are physically, naturally stronger doesn’t mean anything when the female has been trained.

React

4 People

cavmanier

+1 y
Being bigger and stronger means something though. I remember when Serena and Venus Williams challenged the 200 and something ranked guy to tennis. That guy played 18 rounds of golf and had a few beers before beating them both back to back. He lost one of the sets. Then he said something like he barely tried and didn't think they could realistically beat a top 600 male tennis player.
Appless

+1 y
Its funny that you’re talking about tennis players when the question is on a female martial artist.
cavmanier

+1 y
Well yeah, both are athletic sports. There would realistically be an even wider divide when it comes to fighting though. I don't think the best mma female would have a chance against the worst mma male fighter but maybe I'm wrong.
Show All Show Less
Appless

+1 y
That’s where you’re being incredibly sexist. They’re far from the same, one is based on physical protection/ attack and the other is on hitting a ball. A great female mma fighter could easily take down another male mma fighter, stealth and skill is also applicable not just strength. You clearly have never met a strong and focused woman before.
cavmanier

+1 y
You don't have to insult me. I'm not trying to be sexist. I never said they are the same. I understand what playing tennis and fighting is. I'm not retarded lol. My opinion is based on men having such a clear physical advantage. I think we both agree that strength and speed are determined by physical ability. I think because men are on average (especially when it comes to top end athletes) far superior to women regarding physical activity it gives them the advantage to dominate in both activities.

The truth is for Serena Williams to be able to beat the 600th best man is actually a tremendous physical accomplishment for a woman. She can do that because of how exceptional of a woman athlete she is. I guess you see that as sexist but that's not how I mean it. Everything is so terrible and sexist and dramatic nowadays in the mainstream. In reality though, people aren't that bad.
Appless

+1 y
I called you sexist because you’re putting stereotypes in. I did say that men are naturally physically stronger, I never denied that. But the question is about a female mma against an average guy. Which would be extremely easy.
cavmanier

+1 y
What stereotype?

The question is about a female martial artist which is broad. A girl that did taekwondo at the local shop is a martial artist. I agree with you the average professional female mma would destroy an average guy. I kinda said that in my answer, "If you mean a female martial artists with fighting training, she has a good chance I think. If you mean somebody who's done martial arts for a couple years in a studio, I doubt it." What I mean earlier is I didn't think the top mma female fighter could do much to the worst pro male mma fighter. She'd get destroyed i m o. Maybe a female has fought a male pro? I doubt that though. If one had a chance against a pro male fighter, I think it would have happened. It may have actually.
Appless

+1 y
Once someone has learnt the skills, strength seriously doesn’t matter.
DVanx

+1 y
You are totally right. Skills beat size and muscle strength any day. That's the point of martial arts to begin with!

Answer 7

cavmanier

Being bigger and stronger means something though. I remember when Serena and Venus Williams challenged the 200 and something ranked guy to tennis. That guy played 18 rounds of golf and had a few beers before beating them both back to back. He lost one of the sets. Then he said something like he barely tried and didn't think they could realistically beat a top 600 male tennis player.

Answer 8

Appless

Its funny that you’re talking about tennis players when the question is on a female martial artist.

Answer 9

cavmanier

Well yeah, both are athletic sports. There would realistically be an even wider divide when it comes to fighting though. I don't think the best mma female would have a chance against the worst mma male fighter but maybe I'm wrong.

Answer 10

Appless

That’s where you’re being incredibly sexist. They’re far from the same, one is based on physical protection/ attack and the other is on hitting a ball. A great female mma fighter could easily take down another male mma fighter, stealth and skill is also applicable not just strength. You clearly have never met a strong and focused woman before.

Answer 11

cavmanier

You don't have to insult me. I'm not trying to be sexist. I never said they are the same. I understand what playing tennis and fighting is. I'm not retarded lol. My opinion is based on men having such a clear physical advantage. I think we both agree that strength and speed are determined by physical ability. I think because men are on average (especially when it comes to top end athletes) far superior to women regarding physical activity it gives them the advantage to dominate in both activities.

The truth is for Serena Williams to be able to beat the 600th best man is actually a tremendous physical accomplishment for a woman. She can do that because of how exceptional of a woman athlete she is. I guess you see that as sexist but that's not how I mean it. Everything is so terrible and sexist and dramatic nowadays in the mainstream. In reality though, people aren't that bad.

Answer 12

Appless

I called you sexist because you’re putting stereotypes in. I did say that men are naturally physically stronger, I never denied that. But the question is about a female mma against an average guy. Which would be extremely easy.

Answer 13

cavmanier

What stereotype?

The question is about a female martial artist which is broad. A girl that did taekwondo at the local shop is a martial artist. I agree with you the average professional female mma would destroy an average guy. I kinda said that in my answer, "If you mean a female martial artists with fighting training, she has a good chance I think. If you mean somebody who's done martial arts for a couple years in a studio, I doubt it." What I mean earlier is I didn't think the top mma female fighter could do much to the worst pro male mma fighter. She'd get destroyed i m o. Maybe a female has fought a male pro? I doubt that though. If one had a chance against a pro male fighter, I think it would have happened. It may have actually.

Answer 14

Appless

Once someone has learnt the skills, strength seriously doesn’t matter.

Answer 15

DVanx

You are totally right. Skills beat size and muscle strength any day. That's the point of martial arts to begin with!

Answer 16

ChocoLada

Guru

Of course, size doesn't matter, even smaller fighters can defeat big and strong guys like Bob Sapp. Martial arts are about speed and skills, not about physical strength.

React

1 Person

Answer 17

madhatters4 | 699 opinions shared on Sports topic.

Influencer

depends on the level. a high level female martial artist most likely could

React

Answer 18

Ouroboros8Fate

Xper 4

Yes, it's happened multiple times... what kind of random sexist question is that lol? If a woman is skilled in martial arts and self-defense she could easily beat the shit out of an attacker. Martial Arts teaches you ways of outmaneuvering and taking advantage of cleanly taking out or disabling your opponent/attacker.

React

3 People

Answer 19

cavmanier

Master

If you mean a female martial artists with fighting training, she has a good chance I think. If you mean somebody who's done martial arts for a couple years in a studio, I doubt it.

Guys have a huge advantage or head start.

https://youtu.be/YbBIK8CzCYo

React

1 Person

Answer 20

N192K001

Guru

What's her rank and how long has she trained?
Is she trained in an armed martial art or empty-hand?
She's trained in which martial art (s)?

React

1 Person

krancen

+1 y
She is purple belt. I don't know how the martial art is called but it's empty-hand.
N192K001

+1 y
If she has polished her skill and developed muscle memory of the said polished skill, I would imagine she could.

Answer 21

krancen

She is purple belt. I don't know how the martial art is called but it's empty-hand.

Answer 22

N192K001

If she has polished her skill and developed muscle memory of the said polished skill, I would imagine she could.

Answer 23

dropkicknj13

Guru

Obviously, average people dont even know how to make a proper fist and they have martial arts specifically designed for fighting larger opponents

React

1 Person

krancen

+1 y
Which martial arts do you mean?
dropkicknj13

+1 y
Well wing Chun for one

Answer 24

krancen

Which martial arts do you mean?

Answer 25

dropkicknj13

Well wing Chun for one

Answer 26

Edanurus

Explorer

Are we talking about the average person who does martial arts? If so no. Doing martial arts and a street fight are completely different things most martial artist would get flattened in a street fight.

React

Answer 27

zagor | 156 opinions shared on Sports topic.

Master

Yes, if she is fit and a reasonable size. I don't think a girl the size of Simone Biles could beat a guy the size of Shaq O'Neal regardless of how well-trained she was.

React

Answer 28

Anonymous

She'd understand leverage, balance and things like that and would win, yes.

React

3 People

Answer 29

Hunterb

Xper 6

Yeah I have seen it happen in my old mma gym

React

2 People

krancen

+1 y
How it happened? Guys got knocked out?
Hunterb

+1 y
No but she just outclassed them hell she even beat me up I was 15 though
Hunterb

+1 y
It’s really weird fighting a hot mma girl too like you don’t know whether to fuck or fight
Show All Show Less
krancen

+1 y
So how old was she? It must me difficult to fight a hot girl. Maybe that's why you had lost.
Hunterb

+1 y
Late 20s I was 15 she wasn’t being serious with me but she kicked other guys ass