Do you think if fighting was mixed sexes women would win?

Question

Here is the question, if males could fight females in MMA who would win most of the time?

1. Rules the same as current mma rules (no groin attacks, men get to wear protection, weight classes)

2. No rules or protections (all groin attacks are allowed, no groin guards at all BUT of the same weight class so not like a massive guy vs small girl)

Who do you think would win out of those scenarios and how would it go down?

Zealashton · Accepted Answer

do not kick a man in the balls, plase don't it won't work at all your going to piss them off in the fight pirode.
when a guy fights, they dont care about their body, and when fighting rage starts to boil,
and when a man is beserking, no pain, nothing will stop him from killing,

honestly my mom, and simular arm thick ness as me, but i am lean, she's not, she use to slap and abuse me a lot, she was about a few inchs shorter then me, she conditioned me mentally to be afriad of her,

well guss what i was 18 still being abused, and well, guss what, i was scared, i wanted to leave, first sign of besker ablity, second i started to cry, second sign of warning before beserking ablity takes effect,
next i became frustrated,
after that i grabed her neck pushed her to the door, and slamed her head agenst it continusly and i was litterly chocking her to death, i could not think stright at all, all i knew was kil, kil kill, kill, kill repating over and over agin, i was litterly grawling and snarling at her like wild animal,
lucky for her she survived, but after that day, she learn her fucking lesson, not to piss me off, and make me cry and feel traped or abuse me,
i had her crying in the basment i was, somewhat happy, pridful, and surpised my self how strong i was.

hmm, only 4 people go me to that point, bully at school , my ant sam, and my brother,

the story is that, wemon , dont abuse your son at all, your not strong enough at all your litterly pocking a bear, and will wind up in a hospital or worse dead,

Anonymous · Accepted Answer

I’ll be more realistic than the other guys. Since guys and girls have different heights and weights the outcome is impossible to predict as some girls are better trained, different sizes etc.

With that being said if the guy in the picture went against the girl on the bottom he would win hands down a vast majority of the time unless she got a very lucky blow to his groin if he wasn’t wearing a cup. In every fight with groin strikes allowed the girl would have a chance to win but the guys would definitely still win the majority of the time of course it all depends on the strength experience height and weight difference.

As for the two pictures I’d say the guy would probably win 9/10 times if they fought 10 times and both fighters could magically recover and not have past injuries after each bout (this is important because if it wasn’t for this it’s very likely the girl would get knocked out or too injured to go on if she didn’t get a lucky groin strike early on.)

what do you think asker? As a side note though regardless I think MMA fighters of both genders look pretty hot and represent peak athletic performance if it’s a higher division.

Anonymous · Accepted Answer

The women have a chance but I’d say that guys will probably win most of the time still even with groin strikes allowed. The sport would probably still remain pretty male dominated but there would always be a few girls who are exceptions and can beat a lot of guys.

Also I saw your other replies. How old is your brother? At your age guys aren’t quite as strong yet. Challenge a guy that is 15 or 16 to wrestle you (not anything with punches, because guys most likely don’t punch as hard as they can with their friends or with girls) and just see how it goes. There is a chance you could win with a strike there of course but 9 times out his strength will win out. Like the guy above me said that’s probs how the fights will go too.

maybe try wrestling your brother competitively instead of punching and see the outcome? I doubt a brother would be trying his hardest nobody wants to Knock-out their sister but he probably wouldn’t have any qualms about pinning you.

JuneLady · Accepted Answer

With all of the massive turmoil surrounding groin attacks, a historic perspective helps to understand it.
ADRENALINE MAKES GROIN ATTACKS ALMOST IRRELEVANT IN COMBAT. That being said, they are outlawed because of the long-term effects and issues they can cause, not because they change the outcome of the battle by much. Guys win, hands down

0112358 · Answer

First of all, random untrained but motivated people, the vast majority would be blow outs incredibly fast with men winning and the woman needing to be rescued. Men are significantly bigger than women with a lot more muscle mass, and also a much higher tendency to be aggressive. Early UFC fights for instance didn't actually ban hitting the groin, it's not quite as effective as you imagine it to be. Yeah it hurts, they pause let them recover, but they're not actually being dropped. They -could- fight through it if they had to.

If we looked at trained fighters who are the same weight class, men still have a large advantage. A fit, trained 145 lb man has significantly more strength and muscle mass than a fit, trained 145 lb woman, because women carry significantly more body fat at a similar level of health, and their reproductive organs are also heavier - so a higher percentage of his 145 lbs is bone and muscle.

So maybe we could adjust for that, spotting women a 5% weight bonus for female body fat differences, and some other adjustment for reproductive organs. So maybe we're now looking at like 150 lb woman vs a 130 or 135 lb man. We're getting much closer here. The man still has some advantages in terms of muscle density, upper body strength, bone density etc, while the woman has more mass to absorb shots which does help. I'd guess in this range skill would usually dominate - whoever was the better fighter.

note to make things equal though, we need to have a larger woman versus a somewhat smaller man, where in the real world, the average man is bigger.

Anonymous · Answer

Women with similar amount of training would not win.

I do martial arts, no women same weight or heavier were able to do anything significant where strength were involved. With similar amount of training before. Martial art I do women can train (only train) with men. When I do I have to use less strength as otherwise she will not be able to do anything...

These day I see SOOO many feminazi influenced movies where main character (small women) able to kill 3x bigger attackers multiple times in a row most of the movie, with head on attack...

WTF who decided that it could be possible IRL? After watching them a lot of people believe that it is possible, NO it is fiction and/or somebodies wet dream...

Women would have huge advantage against untrained or 'wanabe tough guy' and most likely would beat him without any sweat.

And I would encourage all women to do some martial art training in her life, especially against male attacker, as I seen few women only clubs doing it great, if you want fight only against women, but IRL men attack women too...

MrWolf · Answer

Ohh you ain't been too or seen most dark rings the world can offer.

Go ahead research it you ain't going to like it.

Done few fights myself, few broken ribs a broken jaw, arm, leg it's fun you should seen the woman though.

And yes sometimes woman can beat you to pulp if you think they are something less.

Fought with woman fought beside woman don't ever think less.

But no i don't want to watch such a sport. To dark even for my taste. This goes against everything I'm defending or fighting for in life.

But there are places around the world you can see a thing you will regret your whole life. Because it takes a chunk from your soul.

BeMuse · Answer

Girls use to show up at wrestling tournaments when I was a kid. They competed with guys. I rarely saw any of them win a match, and saw none of them metal at all. I think they can win in some martial arts competitions if they are far more skilled than their opponent, but inevitably there are going to be guys that are just as skilled or more skilled than them in their weight class and they will lose the battle of strength and endurance. I don’t care… If they show up to fight... When they get their ass kicked, then they can go back and train harder. You don’t become better if you don’t fight better fighters.

jshm2 · Answer

Males. Not only because of the significant gap in experience males have over females, but also the level of training and coaching available to the male game.

You're also forgetting that the purpose of MMA and other contact sports is money and sponsorship.

Who the hell is going to watch a bunch of guys beat women in a ring for 45 bucks pay per view? Especially when you can watch such fights live and for free at any city nightclub?

Also, do you really think sponsors are going to come forward to put money towards such events on the big screen?

ThisIsMyOpinion · Answer

Even if groin attacks were legal they would not stand a chance. Let me be clear that goin hits are very easy to avoid, specially to a trained fighter.
Second do you know who Lucia Rijker was? She was a boxer who never EVER lost against a woman. Best in the world! Once they put her against a man. He was a nobody in boxing and had a positive record of wins-losses, but still a nobody. He was the same weight as she was... he won. Let me say it again, she NEVER lost against another woman and the first weak man they put in front of her beats her on the second round by KO.
In every sport men's league is an entire different league. This is not me putting women down, is just a fact. Even Serena Williams says it!

R3DthatDude · Answer

This would be the ultimate scientific evidence if mma said fuck it no gender restrictions. However I still think male will win most of the time, there will always be those selected few women who surpass expectations but ultimately the advantage goes to a man. It’s not superiority it’s biological. The Olympics isn’t doing it and they are all about fairness... mostly. Biologically a male is stronger so he is at an advantage, does that mean he is sure to win, no. What I’ve grasped for mixed martial arts is technique and a whole lot of freaking training is what matters most. Hardest worker and better trained wins. I might. It be built like a cheetah but if I train hard I can beat it in a race, not saying it will be easy but it’s not impossible

ChrisMaster69 · Answer

For MMA and some other contact sports, no.

Things like bone density, muscle strength etc.

A guy can seriously injure a girl in say boxing.

guys can take body blows, chest blows.

long term damage to a girls boobs, stomach etc

mazharhussainkhan · Answer

Women would definitely win most of the times because men would have to be very careful not to touch any private parts of the women they are fighting with. Because if they accidentally do touch any private part of the woman they are fighting, they will be in huge trouble. The woman could file a case of sexual assault against that man.

modelUN242 · Answer

Men would win because biologically speaking they have better physiques and muscle composition to handle competition. Men are competitive by nature. Also, men have better reflexes. Make a strong woman fight against a strong man. The picture showing a weak guy fighting a strong girl is dumb unless he's purposely letting her win.

IronLady6354 · Answer

Men would win more. Men and women are equal in most regards, but physical strength is not one of them. Men are much physically stronger than most women. There are exceptions. There are Ronda Rouseys and Gina Caranos out there who can take down super strong men. However, they are very much the exceptions to the rule.

Secret6620 · Answer

Some might. Many will lose. Speaking from experience of fighting boys growing up...

Some guys can fight and some cannot. I haven't personally lost a fight to a guy but he ripped my shoulder from the socket so I guess that's losing but the match timed out and no victor was declared. Fun times in the Marine Corps.

I think I like grappling more than sparring. I can hold a nice good arm choke until he falls unconscious.

Great question!

curiousscorpio89 · Answer

There is a reason why men compete against men and women compete against women. It's not a fair competition. A man and a women of the same weight is not fair because the man has higher bone density and less body fat. Not to mention testosterone and strength. Men and women are just biologically different and its silly to even debate this.

FýrdracaDócincel · Answer

So here's the thing about combat..

In striking.. size, weight and strength don't matter nearly as much. I do think there's a lot to be said for mixed gender boxing/kickboxing/muay thai/karate etc.

But the SECOND you throw in any kind of grappling, sex division becomes out of the question.

Technique helps.. but do take into account that the people who claim that strength doesn't matter at ALL tend to be either huge dudes or masters of "Couch Fu"

Anpu23 · Answer

I've faught women in the ring before. It's not unheard of, many martial arts competitions are co-ed. If it's a competition of skill the person who has the advantage is the person who trains hard. But MMA is also about raw strength and men are, generally, stronger than women. In that case men have the advantage, simply because of biology.

Anonymous · Answer

Guys would win because of the overwhelming athletic advantages of the male body. I don’t think allowing groin attacks would change much, considering that it’s also a weak spot on women and the male fighter in question could strike the woman in the groin to great effect.

Floppy2112 · Answer

People would get seriously hurt in this scenario. No I don't think women stand a chance in the ring against men. The disparity in power is huge. I know it's not PC to say it, but this is a really bad idea and if I were in MMA I would flat out refuse to fight a woman.

Anonymous · Answer

"1. Rules the same as current mma rules (no groin attacks, men get to wear protection, weight classes)"

Men would win most fights.

"2. No rules or protections (all groin attacks are allowed, no groin guards at all BUT of the same weight class so not like a massive guy vs small girl)"

This would be way more balanced. Allowing groin attacks is a huge advantage for women.

LazyProphet · Answer

Thats kind of a ridiculous question, p4p guys will almost always win because they are built different, they are naturally stronger. There are exceptions of course, I'm sure Valentina Shevchenko and Amanda Nunez could hold their own against some guys their size.

jasco · Answer

Honestly it depends on experience and even than, luck has to do with fighting to, not all fights but some fights have been won due to luck. Exp, luck, determantion, many factors can give a women or men a advantage in combat. so its a let just wait and see

Do you think if fighting was mixed sexes women would win?

Most Helpful Opinions

What Girls & Guys Said

Do you think if fighting was mixed sexes women would win?

Most Helpful Opinions

What Girls & Guys Said

We're glad to see you liked this post.