Girls, which is most important to you? The tall guy or the body guy?

Question

say there's 2 guys that like you, you could date either one, they're both great and all, personality wise, they have good looking faces too, but there's a diff in height and body build.

would you take the tallest one, or the one with the best body build?

which is most important to you?

AND ONLY CHOOSE FROM THESE 2!

don't give me none of that, o I want a tall guy with a great body, no, that's not what the Q is about, if you answer like that, I will seriously block your ass.

Smilie-xo · Accepted Answer

I like tall guys, but I would rather have a guy with a great body. Unless he was shorter than me... But anyways, its cause I like the way he would make me feel safe and also then I would be more comfortable with him because I wouldn't be afraid to like crush him with my weight, so I'd be more open to like him holding me up against the wall while we hook up, which I've always thought was really sexy. And also because, while I like the tip toe thing, I don't like having to do it ALL the time. And guys who are way taller than I am make me feel like a child in comparison, which is definitely not a good way to feel when you're with your boyfriend.

istartriots · Accepted Answer

Tall. In my opinion, guys with lots of muscles.. turn me off in a way. I don't want my guy looking like a jock or like someone just fed him a bunch of steroids. Tall guys are pretty sexy - I find it adorable and cute that I have to stand on a chair or on my tip toes to hug some of my reaaaally tall guy friends. Plus, I don't want a guy shorter than me even if he has a six pack (and if he was shorter than me he'd be a midget!)

Also, if you're a short girl with a tall guy it can be funny in ways - especially if they p*ss you off and you go to punch them but end up missing, haha. It's cute how the guys always take victory in that.

Usemyname · Accepted Answer

Body guy. But a body guy to me isn't big ol' Arnold S. back in his day, it's the sweet 'yes I have a six pack and yes I know I'm sexy' look that I like. As some of the girls have said, they like to pull his shirt down to kiss him but I don't mind pulling him closer to me for a smooch. And as for the tip toe thing I must say it's very very VERY nice, so sometimes when I kiss my boyfriend (who is only two inches taller than me) I stand on the tips of my toes anyways and just tilt my head down. It all works out if you're me. :)

Anonymous · Accepted Answer

sh*t man, honestly girls love a guy with a body, but they don't care for it.

I worked out since I was 11 all the way till 18 years old. I gave that crap up even with the 6 1/2 pack or w/e and the nice big arms.

Makes no difference, girls want a guy who just has a good lookin smile and all around charm

cyrus7 · Accepted Answer

I love how certain girls are saying a guy with muscles is "fake" lmao, this site cracks me up sometimes

Apodyopsis · Answer

Tall >>>>> Buff.

I love tall guys' hugs. I'm 5'6 so it's easy to find guys taller then me. He'd wrap his arms around me tight and rest his head on mine. It's so intimate, I love it. Standing on the tips of my toes to kiss him. No idea why I find it f***ing adorable.

Also, I've never been attracted to a buff guy.

starbucksaddict14 · Answer

I'm short so almost every guy is tall for me. In my head I would say tall as my answer.. but in reality now that I think about it the guys I've dated haven't been that tall.. I'd say around 5'10 which is still a good 8 inches taller than me. But they've all had nice bodies, not muscular but toned. I don't know! I guess if I had to choose now I would go with height but the guy makes the difference.

EverythingReal · Answer

(I only found this because it is a featured poll on the side bar) I prefer my guys tall, at least taller than me. I would rather have a taller guy who is scrawny than a short guy with nice build. Body build is always nice but I can do without, having a guy with a nice body just adds more pressure for me to keep my body perfect and society fixed.

CrazyXEpic · Answer

Im short. So, mostly every guy is taller than me. And sure. I would LOVE to have a guy that has it all, but if I had to choose one over the other I would choose tall. I think it's REALLY cute when a guy leans down to kiss his girlfriend or when a girl goes on her tiptoes to kiss her boyfriend. But, not too much taller than me.. I don't wanna date a guy more than a foot taller than me.. so know one over 6'2.5'' hahahahahaha!

imperatriz · Answer

Wow, I can't believe so many girls said they'd rather have the tall guy. What's the point of having a tall but scrawny bf? That looks so ugly.

I pick the guy with the great body, obviously. Hot body=biggest turn on.

SoShimie · Answer

I say muscle, cause I don't want my guy to be tall but scrawny and weak or anything, he has to at least be able to hold me up...

I mean, what if I trip and I'm about to fall but he tries to catch me but falls too? flat out embarrassing..

Honey18 · Answer

Being as I am 4 foot 11.. The tall guy thing, just doesn't work out for me. My boyfriend is 5 foot 6ish and I love it! I've dated some tall guys (6 foot +) and it always felt extremely awkward for me.

Anonymous · Answer

I chose tall :) there is just something about the thought of them bending down to kiss me or me having to go on my tip toes lol

and I assumed when you said good body you meant 6 pack? That kind of turns me off. I like them built but not REALLY skinny.

Anonymous · Answer

Tall guy. He can always work out & get a better body. If you're short, you're screwed.

(And for those with Napoleon complexes, by short, I mean 5'6" which is my height because I couldn't date anyone my height).

fabulous_13 · Answer

I used to talk to a super tall guy and whenever I would go up to kiss him I would have to jump a little just to get a peck otherwise he would have to help keep me balanced while I stood on my tip toes. It was so cute.

Anonymous · Answer

Honestly, neither. Unless we're talking nice body by my standards, but to most guys nice body means super muscular. And that's a turnoff to me. So if I absolutely have to pick one, I guess I'd pick A. But I really prefer short guys over tall guys. My boyfriend is only 5'6"

smartgirl81 · Answer

im gunna have to be honest an say the tall guy just because I'm 5''7 an I want a guy who has to bend down to kiss me lol...idc bout body build at all...

freebird93 · Answer

i had to pick body cause I'm not attracted to skinny guys, so body would be more important . I like my men thicker, they don't even have to be ripped just powerful (idk if that makes any sense).

tall is always nice though :)

peace-love-couture · Answer

It depends...since you didn't describe the tall guys body and the height of the guy with the best body build...I'd have to say A.

I generally prefer skinny and/or lean/toned. I'm not into muscles, so A.

Kadiboma · Answer

The tallest one. Height is very important to me as I'm fairly tall and don't want a guy who is shorter than me.

angelwithin · Answer

1) I like to get on my toes to kiss the guy's cheek lol just for a second. 2) I like to put my head easily on the guy's shoulder when we hug. so.. my guys are taller please

shesaywhatkinkay · Answer

height has never been a requirement for me, but I do want a guy that's in shape...so I'd say I'd want a guy with a good body over a guy that's tall, especially since I'm super short he'd be taller than me anyway!

6842yvil · Answer

I guess out of these two I would chose the body.  Even though I am 5'9 I have never had a thing for tall guys.  My ideal guy would be an inch or two taller than me with an average build (not skinny or super muscular)

poppylover68 · Answer

Tall! I have a thing for taller guys...when guys are build they look a bit fake.

bunnahies · Answer

depends how tall he is and how built :/

i mean if he was shorter then id have to date a midget...nononono

if he was built like holy crap then nononon

i guess id go for body only cause its not hard to find someone taller than me haha

daintydee · Answer

im not into the whole bodybuilder thing...i love really tall guys (at least 6 foot) that are really slim! theres just something special about having to stand on your toes to kiss a guy!

CatholicVirginia · Answer

Body guy. Tall and lanky doesn't do it for me, but shorter and well built does. Tall and well built would be REALLY nice. And yes, the tippy toe thing is ADORABLE and so romantic.

girl_power111 · Answer

ok..i go to my gym. my gym instructor is like just 5'7 . but he has such a gorgeous physique that I just can't see beyond it. you can't notice how tall or short he is... so body guy for me

Crimson_Petal · Answer

I like having to stand on my tippy toes to kiss a guy. For that reason, and that reason alone I chose A.

Droosilla · Answer

Hard to choose D: TBH I would take either, but I've always preferred tall man over built guys. So I'd have to go with the tall guy based on my past preferences! (I love the tippy toe thing, too! XD)

Eiffelgirl21 · Answer

I like tall.  I do not care for body..especially if they look fake like in magazines...it's actually a turn OFF for me..I want real! not magazine, steroid, retards who only care about their six pack...ehh yuck

Anonymous · Answer

I am short, so more than 99% of guys are taller than me anyway.  I voted for body guy.  I love muscles.  I appreciate the time and energy it takes to build them.  Tall is genetic, muscle is hard work.

Anonymous · Answer

I'd rather have a guy who may be a little shorter (but not shorter or the same height as me, no way) but has a fabulous body.

My definition of a fabulous body: skinny, a little bit of muscle, but not too much.

I'm not that tall myself, I'm 5' 6".

So if it were between a guy with a great body and he's only 5' 8" versus a guy with a not so great body and he's 6' 2", I'd pick the guy who's 5' 8" with the nice body.

Anonymous · Answer

I'm only 5'2"-5'3"ish so assuming they both still have a few inches on me I'd pick the one with the best body build! I don't want a guy that's too tall, I like to easily be able to lift my head and kiss him while hugging. Yay for short people :)

shebhip · Answer

the man who respects his body enough to take care of it by going to the gym or jogging.  don^'t want to have a beer belly now!

lorahayes · Answer

the tall guy, becuase I am 5'9'' and its my job to wear heels a lot so I'm almost always over 6ft... hahahah

bamafanboyle · Answer

I would rather go with the one with the great body so I feel safe. But I would like the taller guy if the other one was shorter than me.

ForeverYours39 · Answer

If they're too muscly it's kind if gross :/ lol But tall (slim) guys are so cute! (usually lol).  I'm pretty short so I agree that the whole tip toe kissing thing is cute ^^

Janeight · Answer

tall any day! besides you can always get buff, but once grown, height really won't fluctuate. plus, I'm tall (like 5' 10-11") so its nice to have a guy as tall as or taller.

FitNix92 · Answer

I'm not really interested in height or muscles to be honest.

Deft_maiden · Answer

The body guy as long he is not shorter than 5"8". Can't stand out of shape dudes.

Ponchi · Answer

I picked taller, BUT what really makes me weak at the knees is when a man makes me feel intellectually inferior.

bel42 · Answer

I'd date the tall guy. I find tall guys very attractive. He can work out to improve his physical appearance. Height can't be changed/altered but the body can.

Ellena102 · Answer

We can fix the body, no problem, but height is the major contributor, and sadly we can't fix or change that if ever (:

Anonymous · Answer

"haha coo" "ok coo" "orly coo?" ... If you say COO one more time I'm going to KILL MYSELF.

chriiistelkelly · Answer

TALL. :) I'm 5'10, so I go for tall guys:) I honestly don't care about their body build.

EntropicDecay · Answer

Since I'm quite tall (5.8) , I'm going for the tall guy as well =]

Shea25 · Answer

i picked tall but really it doesn't matter to me as long as the guy is east indian.

Draco_Spitfire · Answer

:/ I don't like guys with muscles. It kinda weirds me out. I like mine with a little belly, or thin.

Animal_Girl · Answer

The body guy. I'm super short, so 99% of guys are taller than me. :)

MissConfused93 · Answer

Body! I'm short, so height doesn't bother me at all. But I love a guy with muscles.

steve1122 · Answer

Looks like most of you like the tall guy- I feel so much better now! I am 6'4" and no bodybuilder!

SweetFace28 · Answer

Tall. ;-) I'm with the others, I'd pick tall over a built-up body any day.

vishna · Answer

I really don't like super tall skinny guys so best body would win.

Tatiahna · Answer

It seriously depends on the guy. There's no such thing as they "both have great personalities" or "they both have nice faces" one is going to look better than the other or, one's body is going to be nicer than the other or, one's body will suit them better.

It seriously depends on the situation. Some people aren't made to be tall. Some aren't made to be buff.

Then, it all comes down to how you make the me feel. You can be an amazing person but, if I don't feel butterflies it ain't happening.

Lilac8 · Answer

Even though I'm short, I would definitely go for the tall guy.

teamderek13 · Answer

I like tall. He doesn't have to have a massive build, as long as he's not skinnier than me.

Standingpretty · Answer

I love tall guys but the body would nice too...but still, I am a height person.

justthewayyouare · Answer

Due to the fact that I'm 5'8" height is kind of essential.

DishLady · Answer

(Was the link a representation of the TALL guy or the MUSCULAR guy? Lol.)

sarahruth · Answer

lol at the link.  I would go for the taller one- its rare to find guys taller then me.

rockin_angel · Answer

I choose body. :)  I'm not really into the whole tall guy and tippy toe thing since I'm quite short. I'm only 4'9''! So yeah, tall guys kinda scare me lol

blondmoments101 · Answer

Tall guy! I am 5'1" I like to feel totally surrounded, I also like having to tip toe to kiss the guy. Big muscles scare me, I like to feel like I'm gonna crushed. :)

ilyurbella · Answer

I would want the one that would 'prove' or go out of his way to show me that he liked me... I can't decide on looks because they just fade. Sorry I can't give you a straight answer ):

naima17 · Answer

its all about the tall ones..with little muscle! :)...besides I don't wanna be lookin down at you when I talk! :)

Girls, which is most important to you? The tall guy or the body guy?

Most Helpful Opinions

Most Helpful Opinions

What Girls & Guys Said

Girls, which is most important to you? The tall guy or the body guy?

Most Helpful Opinions

Most Helpful Opinions

What Girls & Guys Said

We're glad to see you liked this post.