What to do in a scenario where a girl who rejected you on multiple occasions , asks you to be her boyfriend?

[Anonymous]

So there's this girl who I really liked around 5 years back and she liked me to back then but rejected me since she was with another guy already. She broke up with that guy some time later and I asked her out again but she rejected me and started talking to another guy who she really liked ( I suppose ). Post that , I was just like a very good friend to her and nothing more. I stopped feeling for her the way I used to in the past but I still care for her as a good friend. As days went by , she started liking another guy who I suppose didn't like her back. Recently she tried to get back to her ex ( I suppose ) but he was already in a relationship with another person. A month later she tells me she wants to be with me. I don't really have the same strong feelings as before and I told her that. I didn't give a deep reason but I just told her I want to be by myself. Did I do the right thing?

[dankstranger]

yes, you did. I have been in a similar scenario.

Old crush from highschool who I could never get the timing right with. couple of years down the road she wants to get together, but by then I had moved on and I didn't really have those feelings for her anymore. I told her "i'm focusing on me"

just like you i fell like an idiot, i kept asking myself "did I just miss an opportunity? what if thats the last girl that comes around for a long while?" it felt like a mistake. But it wasn't. why?

I did not have feelings for her and it would have been foolish to strike up a relationship with someone who i wasn't even crushing on anymore.

was she good looking? absolutely
decent personality? absolutely
then why not?
we had grown a part, we were different people than who we were in highschool. I was kind of a horndog in highschool and ended up dating women who really were honestly bad choices for me. As I've gotten a little older I've learned to be pickier. It's totally okay to trust your gut in this scenario. You absolutely did the right thing.

[Jfranco12]

Yes, remove her from your life completely. She just wanted to use you now because she’s lonely, she couldn’t see your value back then and she hasn’t changed at all. If you had agreed it would’ve been a short relationship and she’d have likely lined someone else up before jumping ship. She is toxic.

[ItsMeElliana]

yeah you did the right thing. she took too long to realise what she missed out on, and tbh its better to reject her now, since she did that to you when you wanted her. because her feelings aren't looking genuine rn, its almost as if she just wants you because those others dont want her

[Phoenix98]

You did the right thing. She only asked you out of desperation. She went to everybody even her ex before she asked you.

if someone genuinely likes you and wants to be with you then you won’t be their last Hail Mary option. No you’ll be their first and only choice.

don't waste your time on her you deserve someone better.

[Texaskid1]

Buddy, there is too much pussy out there for you to fixate on one piece of ass. This girl is using you as some kind of possible back up plan. What do you think she has been doing all these years? While you have been pinning over her she has been getting rammed by her boyfriend (s).

Don't bang your head against that rock and keep walking.

[Twalli]

Of course. When you liked her, you were an option. She shouldn't have expected that to always be the case. One guy dated a girl, then they broke up, she gained weight and dated another guy and then wanted to get back together with him despite that she gained over 100 lbs. and he didn't find her attractive anymore. Your case is different, but the same thing is true. You found her attractive in the past and now you don't.

[Anonymous]

I'd do just what she did to me.
First I'd accept. Then I'd change my mind and tell her "I don't think we should go out". Then I'd wait a little while and tell her I just don't think about her in that way. Then if we remained friends. I'd wait a long while and out of the blue when we do something as "friends" arrogantly tell her at the last minute i don't think we should because I wouldn't want to lead her on as though I thought she was still pineing for me.

[shadowowner]

You will say yes if you like being beta and treated like ass. Basically, she didn't work out with the other person, and she's like "o ya there's that nice guy chasing me for 5 years, I could use him as a pillow". Then basically you get looked down at in your relationship.

There are better people out there, and you deserve better. That line isn't just for women. Men can have self-esteem too.

[Truthatanycost]

You did the right thing. Learn to say no, it will make your life much easier.

[EaterPeter]

Ball is in your court, you have a choice to be kind with her and do right thing for yourself or be jerk and do right thing for yourself. I prefer first option.

[noohair]

You should do what is good for you. She seems to be settling with you and there might be some mental instability in the mix, Good luck.

[Waldoe]

YES, she made it clear that you were just "Friends" and you have accepted that... it was her decision. It is in the past.

[Anonymous]

Why would you bother asking multiple times?
That hoe only wants you now because you are the only option right now.

Every other time she tossed you because of some other cock.

[Staximus]

Ask her "why am I the right guy now when I was never good enough before?"

[Rafanrog]

Make her earn her way into conservation.

[XXblack88]

Yes if you don't have feeling for her like that.

[In_Trance]

Block

[888theGreat]

desperate