What’s more attractive wide hips or narrow hips?

[Anonymous]

• i just had a procedure yesterday and I told my surgeon I want my hips smaller (removed) and he said why? If that’s what gives you the shape you want?
  i said no I don’t like this part big (pointing to my hips)
• i don’t know how I look yet because I’m still all bandaged up.. BUT just curious to know what most people find MOST attractive with hips or without hips?
  i posted some photos below for reference..
• 
  With hips

• WITHOUT HIPS

I like better with hips

I prefer without big hips

Updates

+1 y

For example the second photo, I believe she looked better on the BEFORE photo.

[Lliam]

I think smoothly curving hips without hip dips or saddle bags are ideal. Narrower is fine, but a
.63 to.67 waist to hip ratio is ideal.

[Asker]

so you’re mostly attracted to girls with surgery.

[Lliam]

Absolutely not!

[Asker]

But you just described it

[Lliam]

You don't think normal girls have nice hips and thighs? LOL
Funny, all of my girlfriends did. And that was before plastic surgery was a thing.
Plastic Barbies make me sick.

[Asker]

If you see a girl with no hip dips they’ve had surgery or get injections but most likely surgery because injections are hell of expensive might as well save a little more and get the surgery

[RebelinSteel]

I really don’t care and don’t even notice, almost nearly everyone else in the real world would not notice or actually care.

[WonderingManII]

I like wide hips. <3

[Celticwolf78]

Not really small and not really big I'd say medium

[butterly248]

Doesn't matter