Wide hips or narrow hips on a girl?

[Anonymous]

From an evolutionary perspective, of course a wider hipped woman is far more sexually attractive, but let's see just how much social constructs influenced the attraction in males

Wide hips (yummy)

Narrow hips

[Underduress]

Picture A is mostly fat ass and not necessarily all about wide pelvis. I prefer thinner legs with a gap defining a wide pelvis. So I vote A but that wouldn’t be my choice picture. Also, the lower her waist to hip (pelvis bone not fat ass) ratio (WHR) is the higher her fertility will be according to some references while other references that try to make obesity ok and cool counter that argument. 0.7 WHR is considered the most attractive. The woman of B is not obese but has a waist to hip ration closer to 1 as would an obese woman and would not be considered as fertile as A. Fertile in this case is the ability to get pregnant and carry to term.

[Asker]

I hope you realize that this picture was photoshopped to exemplify wide hips. I understand they're not structurally wide hips, or actual wide hips, but I thought that would be evident by the extreme disparity in fat distribution. No woman has a flat stomach and gigantic hips like these.

[Underduress]

I took it at face value because I have seen women that large when sitting in that position. Regardless of the Photoshop, If she wasn't as fat in the ass my opinion still holds.

[Asker]

Give an example of a woman who has wide hips with no "fat ass".

[Underduress]

I don’t have time right now to turn this into a research project but there are women that have femur bones that extent out the side more than others. I had a girl with a wide pelvis and another with not so wide of a pelvis but had femurs that extended out and was a little wider than the girl with the wider pelvis. I consider the wider without the pelvis width a fat butt. That is my “opinion” . I have to go to work now.

[TheOtakuMaid]

number 1 is to fucking wide that's not what nature intended and number 2 looks natural so out of radical 1 and the natural one il pick 2

[TheOtakuMaid]

no number 1 is just not normal bro. i think you have spent to much time around black girls with asses larger then the moon that your idea of naturally wide hips is distorted allow me to fix that

usercontent2.hubstatic.com/8328135_f520.jpg

those are natural wide hips as what you showed in number 1 looks like an abomination and I have never encountered such unless at a McDonalds

[Wonderer89]

The pictured wide is too much for me, but generally I find larger hips to be quite feminine and attractive

[Asker]

Not for me, but it's likely too wide for you because women with these hips are probably 0.00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000001 of the population.

[Wonderer89]

You have your preference, others have theirs

[Asker]

no shit

that wasn't the point of what I was saying

[Wonderer89]

What you were saying was completely irrelevant to the question and to my opinion. I don't care, nor was I asking how many women have hips that wide.

[Asker]

Are your parents siblings or first cousins, by any chance? I proposed that the reason you find this hip width too much is because of the scarcity of this type of women, and the extremity of the disparity of her hip to waist and shoulder ratio, which is completely relevant to the question, and your opinion. That's more than enough relevance to the subject.

Your response was "u hev openioun I haz obinioun". Oh, really? Stop taking yourself too seriously.

[Wonderer89]

Aww kiddo grabbed a thesaurus. Too cute!
And no, still not relevant. My distaste has nothing to do with rarity, I simply don't find it attractive. Just as I don't find many socially sought after traits desirable.
Your question was based on a generic preference, people are giving those with the condition it not be what you've chosen to depict as an option for you to get all ranty over.
But hurr durr b0iz lyk b7g buTTz and everyone else is a retard. Sure kid. Whatever you say. Bye now.

[itsallover]

Hips that are in proportion look best. So they could be either wide or narrow.

[Asker]

that negates the point of wide hips altogether. the point is foe the hips to look disprortionately wide to the rest of the body, or it wouldn't all be the same width

[itsallover]

Uh not really. Wide hips can look proportionate, as do narrow hips. It's the waist to hip ratio that makes the difference.

[RedThread]

Is that first person real?

But I generally prefer wider hips.

[Asker]

I'm pretty sure it was photoshopped, but I still find it weirdly sexually attractive

[tartaarsaus]

Hips that are in proportion with the rest of the body. Otherwise it would look weird

[Sylvainnn]

I like wide hips but not that wide as on the picture

[Rjsurya846]

It keeps on vary because, it depends how that person presents herself.

[CinMinRoll]

I don't have very wide hips, and I seem to get more attention than I care to have. 😅

[Berserk117]

as long as the girl has a 9 inch penis i'm cool

[Asker]

xdxxddxdddxdddxx

[Asker]

jk luv u not really bye

[laila23]

what about hourglasses

[Asker]

hot af

[LaFemmeFatale]

That's too wide in my opinion. How she runs?

[LaFemmeFatale]

And by the way you say you value such women because they are very few. Do you know the reason? Because such wide hips are against evolution I believe. She would be the first to die once enemies or animals hit the village back then.

[Asker]

No they're not against evolution, and they are rare

[cinderelli]

that's too ''wide'' don't you think

[Asker]

nope. it's perfecr

[Asker]

perfect* wider than that then yeah, probably

[cinderelli]

eehh that looks weird to me.. but whatever floats your goat

[Asker]

yes I'm assuming you're not a a heterosexual man so no primal sexual urge is triggered to wanting to fuck a wide hipped fertile woman so no shit

[cinderelli]

just fuck one of your camels then

[cinderelli]

like you ever had a chance ;P

[cinderelli]

your stupidity aside.. like whatever you want dude.. if that's something you're into then cool.. so be it

[cinderelli]

wow you typed all that for me.. aww you!! <3

[aestheticsofty]

Wide 😍😍😍

[Asker]

girls with wide hips trigger some kind of primal instinctual sexual urge in me. I genuinely have a mini crush on every wide hipped big assed woman that passes by

[Naydyonov]

Wayyy too wide.

[Asker]

the fact that most white guys are calling this way too wide tells me something. bruh she got child bearing hips. sexy as fuck

[Naydyonov]

she can't even fit through a door with those things.

no I want kids, I also want to fit on the bed with my woman

[Asker]

lmao she's not that wide

[Asker]

my shoulders look wider than her hips and I can't fit perfectly in beds and walk through doorways

[Asker]

CAN*

[Naydyonov]

And her legs... fat

[Asker]

sexy

[Naydyonov]

You're strange

[The_researcher]

Well I have wide

[Asker]

guys want to fuck you

[The_researcher]

That's what they tell me

[Asker]

Wide hips and that face? you can be on a steady supply of 10 dicks a day for the rest of your life if you try

[The_researcher]

Thank you I guess