Who is the better musical artist? Kelly Clarkson, or Pink?

[Jamie05rhs]

Kelly's greatest songs: Because of You, Breakaway, Since U Been Gone, Miss Independent, Walk Away, Behind These Hazel Eyes, My Life Would Suck Without You, Stronger. ... Pink's greatest songs: Get The Party Started, So What, Who Knew, Don't Let Me Get Me, U + Ur Hand, Raise Your Glass, Just Give Me a Reason, Try

Kelly Clarkson

Pink

Updates

1 y

Sorry; I forgot Long Shot!! (Kelly Clarkson)

Updates

1 y

Also, I don't think it's fair to judge musicians by covers they did of other musicians... HOWEVER, Pink did a cover of Bohemian Rhapsody (by Queen), and it is absolutely AMAZING.

Updates

1 y

For the record, my favorite is Kelly!!

[NotInterestedSorry]

They are both incredible in their own way. I wish both of them would team up and make an album together or at least record a song together.

I'm shocked people believe pink uses auto-tune because she has actually sung acapella with no music and no mic and her voice is the same as on the record. Her dad was a professional singer.

[DizzyDesii]

Kelly can truly sing a range of every genre. Pinks voice is incredible and raspy and both are in my music album collection. But kelly has her beat

[DizzyDesii]

Also kelly sounds aaaaamazing live. Pink doesn't always sound good singing live

[DizzyDesii]

Thanks for mho

[Jamie05rhs]

You're very welcome! :)

[SnowedIn]

My selection was pink but I'm sure I'm a great judge of musical talent.

And you left What About Us off the list of Pink's great songs.

https://youtu.be/ClU3fctbGls

[Jamie05rhs]

@SnowedIn I know What About Us, but I just think it's kinda lame. That's why I didn't include it.

[Jamie05rhs]

I also didn't include A Moment Like This by Kelly Clarkson. Even though I do technically like that song.

[SnowedIn]

Oh wow. I respect your opinion, sir, but kindly disagree! 😊

[Jamie05rhs]

@SnowedIn Okay lol.

[Jamie05rhs]

@SnowedIn For the record, I don't hate it. If that makes you feel any better. Lol

[SnowedIn]

You're all good man! No judgement, no hate, no hurt lol. We all have likes and opinions and dislikes. I just appreciate that you can have an adult conversation. Thank you!

[Jamie05rhs]

Lol no problem!

[Jamie05rhs]

Another of her songs that I left off the list was True Love. And I will readily admit that I shafted that song for political reasons. I really like the song (musically); I just really hate the message in the lyrics. I think it's toxic.

( @Apple1996 )

[Andres77]

Kelly has more talent and she’s not bitter and moody.

pink has talent, but she’s eclipsed by a greater example of talent and character.

[Jamie05rhs]

Well, I don't want to comment on her personal life. I'm sure she's been through a lot, and I'm not sure what percentage of that was done to her and what percentage may or may not have been brought on by her own mistakes. So I just like to stick to the music.

[ChiTown33]

I think it depends on what you use to classify as "better" KC probably has more range and therefore is more versatile. But I would assume has been more successful.

Personally I like Pink's earlier stuff (Mizzundastood album). But I was never a really a "fan" of either.

[MotherEarth2020]

I like Pink

Specially her song Stupid Girl

[Jamie05rhs]

@MotherEarth2020 I haven't heard that one! I'm going to look it up.

[Jamie05rhs]

It's decent! I like the guitar. 😇

[MotherEarth2020]

I like the meaning of the song

[Jamie05rhs]

Cool

[lightbulb27]

I never got into kelly and o dont connect to her songs and voice as well. I can really connect to Pink whom to me has a lot of expression and emotion. To me its no comparison… kellys just a great vocalist but pink is an artist

[Jamie05rhs]

Thank you for your opinion! :)

[Drewtate]

Both are products that rolled off a pop music conveyor belt. Kelly Clarkson is the better singer, pink the better performer.

[DeeDeeDeVour]

To me, they're both incredibly talented singers.

However, I kinda like Pink's style better.

[AngryCarl2]

I low key hate Pink's music. Our local radio station plays that shit all the time and 90% of it is drivel. I think it must be music for soccer moms.

Even if I didn't like Kelly Clarkson she would win by default.

[Sparkie460]

I only recognize one song from each woman. I'll go with pink because the song I know is cool

[Jamie05rhs]

@Sparkie460 Which song is that?

[Sparkie460]

Get the party started and since you were gone

[Jamie05rhs]

Heck yeah! Great choices.

[Sparkie460]

It's the only 2 I know

[Jamie05rhs]

Fair enough.

[Apple1996]

Kelly Clarkson for sure is better. Pink gives off bad vibes

[Jamie05rhs]

Okay, but we're not discussing "vibes." We're talking about musical talent only here.

[Apple1996]

A persons vibes show through in their singing

[Jamie05rhs]

@Apple1996 But her singing is still good. So...

[Chevy1_kb]

Pink most deffinetly I love her music it's the best

[BCA6010]

Not really my genre but based on the songs I have heard before, Pink's songs are better.

[Jamie05rhs]

Thanks for your opinion!

[Nikki1989]

Kelly Clarkson has more talent. Pink wouldn't have a career if it wasn't for auto-tune.

[adidas0169]

U can say that about 99% of the artist now adays

[NotInterestedSorry]

Wait you actually believe Pink uses Auto-tune? You must not really listen to her much or attend any of her concerts because she actually doesn't use auto-tune. You can hear her breathing when she sings.

[Jamie05rhs]

@Nikki1989 I agree that Kelly Clarkson is better. But I don't believe that Pink is talentless.

[CuriousMufuxka]

Pink was more exciting! Clarkson, though winning American Idol just fit into mainstream.

[Justneedtokno]

We have to say pink mainly because think about it she was on the women’s Lady Marmalade song and killed it in diversity. We give it to her Love pink

[whereismyjohnny]

Kelly Clarkson.

[GoodGuyBreakingBad]

Kelly Clarkson

[Smashingdoozy]

They're both equally as good

[LavLavLuv]

I've always liked Pink lol

[sirderpsalot123]

I don't really listen to either of them

[sirderpsalot123]

I know more pink songs, so I'll go with her.

[Fuentes]

I never listen to any but I rmbr Kelly lol

[gothbxtch]

i prefer pink

[Badgirlnatalia]

pink no doubt