Would old Justin Bieber be as famous if he started now as opposed to when he rose to fame in 2009?

[Oliverlogan263]

Basically, the question is asking if old Justin Bieber, the one who got famous in 2009, would be just as famous if he started his music career now instead of back then.

The main thing it's asking is whether Bieber would still be able to become a huge star like he did, or if it would be harder for him to reach that level of fame in today's music scene compared to when he first blew up.

Yes

No

[DizzyDesii]

His voice didn't sound good until he matured and cut that uglass haircut. So yea he’d be more popular even as a sickly pothead because his voice got better as he got older. I just dont think people would find him as physically attractive the older he got

[Oliverlogan263]

His hairstyle was the style and trend back then lol and he definitely matured as for vocally when he came out with boyfriend and as long as you love me

[DizzyDesii]

I hated As long as You Love Me. Only songs i liked before he hit puberty was just Favorite Girl and Never Let U Go. After puberty, i liked Under the MistleToe, Boyfriend, Confident, Intentions, What Do You Mean, Company, and most of the songs from Justice Album (Peaches, Lonely, As I Am, Die For You, Holy, Ghost, Hold On, Somebody, Loved By You). But thats about it

[Anonymous]

He would have gotten a nice blowjob when I was around 12 if he had cared to stop by.

[NathanDavis]

definitely, yes...

because he's pop... and the formula in essence has not changed that much

the risk would be that he would probably had made much more money for himself, which could screw him over earlier in life

[Joshydavid25]

Nah, simply because we don't have another Justin Bieber right now.. K Pop and J Pop are the new pretty boy toy bands.. It doesn't seem to exist much in America anymore.. Justin Bieber was probably at the end of an Era..

[Oliverlogan263]

I believe that too. Justin was really the last Popstar of that era before the industry changed,

It’s different times nowadays of how kids and teens consume music. He’s a product of his environment and time if he came out today I doubt he’d be as famous.

With the rise of Tik-Tok Gen Alpha is more mature occupied with other stuff. I doubt they’d care and we have to see how Gen Beta evolves.

Music has changed and things aren’t done the way they used to be. He’d be just another kid on instagram or TikTok posting music trying to be noticed and there’s thousands of them. Not saying he wouldn’t be a successful music artist, but he wouldn’t be anywhere near as well known and influential as he is today.

[Joshydavid25]

Exactly, social media apps like Vine, and Tik Tok really changed the game.. Now Popstars are popping out left and right and getting their 14 minutes of fame.. Now kids are more into Mr. Beast, and before that it was Pewdie Pie Etc..

[AI Opinion]

The music industry has evolved significantly since 2009. Social media platforms like TikTok and Instagram now play a larger role in discovering new talent. If Justin Bieber started now, he’d likely face more competition, but his talent and charm could still propel him to fame. Viral moments and collaborations still hold value, so his success might hinge on strategic social media use and collaborations with trending artists. 🎶💫

[Anonymous]

I don't think so, present-day people have different taste in music.

[TonyMetal___86]

I have never liked this boy

[Oliverlogan263]

Why?

[TonyMetal___86]

Not my type of music and he's not a type that i like and not from my era...

[beefcakebradybatson]

Who knows? Happy 31st birthday, Biebs !!!