Happy Monday! If it's a stormy one for you, this is for you. Which version of "Stormy Monday" do you think is better?

[FunkyMonkee]

A year or two before I joined my band in 1980, I put together a tape of really hot music that I'd playing drums along with and the last song on it was The McCoys version of, "Stormy Monday Blues" By the time the half-hour long tape was over, I was so wound up I'd continue playing solo for a good 20:00 or better.
When I was auditioning for the band 45 years ago, they asked me which song I'd like to try. They were heavily into eclectic and off the wall songs that they'd do covers of so, I figured they'd know this version and I could show them how good I am. So, they started the song and, much to my dismay, they started playing the very slow and boring Allman Brothers version!!
When I told them that's not the one I knew and let them hear the McCoys version, they said it was too dramatic!!
Which one do you think is the better of the two, and why?
Allman Brothers.

The McCoys.

Allman Brothers

McCoys

[AI Opinion]

I can see why you'd have a strong connection to The McCoys' version, given your personal history with it. Both versions of "Stormy Monday" have their unique charm—the Allman Brothers' version is more laid-back, with a bluesy, soulful feel, while The McCoys bring a more dramatic energy to the track. It ultimately depends on the mood you're in. If you're looking for something to get you energized, The McCoys might be your pick. For a slow, introspective vibe, the Allman Brothers' rendition is perfect. 🎵

[Dongie]

Although I like many songs from the Allman Brothers I didn't particularly like this one. Im not into blues very much. But I did like the McCoys version. I need a little momentum in my jams. I'm discovering that Sloopy boy Rick did way more in the music industry than I would have ever guessed. He had some talent across the board with writing, instruments, some producing, and good singing. I didn't know his brother was a member of his band. Randy thrashed those skins in this one. I bet you did too.

[FunkyMonkee]

I sure did!!
I'm not huge into the blues, either but some of it's cool.
Rick was also in The Edgar Winter Group and had a few solo hits, too. He just died a couple weeks ago.

[Dongie]

I know. I read that yesterday. I remember his passing May 26

[Anonymous]

Not really my genre of music, but I voted for the McCoys.

[FunkyMonkee]

Thanks.

[Opinion Owner]

You're welcome, and Happy Monday to you too :)

[FunkyMonkee]

Thank you! Except for the possible scammer I had to deal with upon waking up, it's not been bad.
Still listening to Woodstock. C., S., N. & Y. are on, now. They're about to do, "Mr. Soul".