Experiment: can you guess which girl is wearing the MOST makeup?

[InsertNameHerex]

I feel like lots of the users on here always get mad when a woman wears too much makeup but from what I’ve seen in real life, so many people can’t even tell the difference between a lot and a little and they just assumed based on some factors. I’ve seen people bash girls for wearing too much makeup when they weren’t wearing any at all, and I’ve seen people compliment a girls “natural” beauty when they’re all caked up. Just wanna see if anyone can genuinely tell.

Guess who’s wearing the most makeup, and who’s wearing the least.

Girl 1

Girl 2

Girl 3

Girl 4

Girl 5

Updates

+1 y

Ok so my point has been proven since barely anyone got it right. from LEAST to MOST:

Girl 5 & 3 are tied at least amount of makeup

Girl 1

Girl 2

Girl 4 has the most makeup on and looks the most different without it. (Full face foundation + concealer + eyeliner + lashes + lip) thanks for participating.

Updates

+1 y

Ok so my point has been proven since barely anyone got it right. from LEAST to MOST:

Girl 5 & 3 are tied at least amount of makeup

Girl 1

Girl 2

Girl 4 has the most makeup on and looks the most different without it. (Full face foundation + concealer + eyeliner + lashes + lip) thanks for participating.

[Jamie05rhs]

Girl 2 is definitely wearing makeup.
Probably Girl 4 as well.

[Jamie05rhs]

Haha! I was right!

[InsertNameHerex]

They’re all wearing makeup, all I asked was who’s wearing the most lol. Anyway Ye it’s 4.

[Jamie05rhs]

Cool. Good post. 👍

[Jamie05rhs]

Thanks for the MHO!

[Wise4myage]

Girl 4.

[TommyMountainFigure]

There is a common misunderstanding here. 'Too much' makeup is subjective.

The point is, for me at least. make up is supposed to enhance your look, not hinder it.
If it is tastefully done, and worn correctly it can look great. but so often it isn't and looks terrible.

[InsertNameHerex]

Yes I know, but when I refer to “too much” I mean like caked on to the point where it looks like there could be a whole different person underneath. My question was just to prove that most people don’t know what they’re talking about when it comes to the amount of makeup a woman is wearing.

[TommyMountainFigure]

I see my g/f sometimes when we go out for a function take AGES putting this stuff on.. Foundation followed by this other stuff, then when it comes to eyeliner I'm not allowed to talk because it is my fault if she stabs herself..

Women lol!!!

[InsertNameHerex]

Quite honestly it’s just fun to put on 😂 I never wear a lot out but I love putting on foundation and eyeliner and blush at home when I’m bored, but like never to the world lolllll it’s just a form of art and a cure of my boredom

[HugoThe2nd]

Girl 2 has the most makeup, then girl 1, 4, 5 and finally 3 with the least amount.

Also, it's not really the question of how much make up is there, it's a matter of how it looks like.
The makeup on girl 2 is by far the worst in here, it looks the most fake and unnatural, and will result in the biggest difference once she wipes it off.

Girl 1 or even girl 4 may have more makeup than girl 2, but theirs simply looks better, girl 2 just looks like a bad Instagram filter.

[InsertNameHerex]

Nearly no one got it right which further proves my point. Anyway, the one who has the most makeup on is the only girl of the group who looks different after wiping it off, and I’ll give you a hint, it’s not girl 2 lol. She looks pretty naturally and she looks great in the photo as well. “Looks most fake and unnatural” well is it bad to look like herself? Is her face overall just fake and unnatural then or? Because she’s not wearing a lot I’ll say that much. I’ll reveal the person who’s wearing the most later.

[HugoThe2nd]

If she looks unnatural naturally?
Well, yes it is an issue. You can see most guys voted 2.
Because she looks, by far, the most fake.
Everything on her face looks contoured and drawn in.

[InsertNameHerex]

So being naturally pretty is an issue now? Yikes lol and no she’s never had cosmetic surgery either.

[HugoThe2nd]

She is not naturally pretty, she looks caked in makeup.
And by going to her insta and being able to confirm this, I'm declaring that you are simply just blind.
She is a cakeface on every single one of her pictures.

[HugoThe2nd]

Naturally pretty, eh?
Are you high?

[InsertNameHerex]

If you simply look at her makeup tutorials from this year ( like what I did with all these women) she applies the least on and looks the same without it. Also you’re taking a picture of her from her teen years where everyone was obsessed with looking caked up. Yes she’s naturally pretty, that’s her insta bro, everyone wears makeup on insta, it’s an art form. But she has tons of pics and videos without makeup and she looks the same. Nice try though.

[InsertNameHerex]

Also I only put one pic up cuz I’m only talking about this pic, not all of them. Everyone wears more makeup at times and sometimes way less.

[HugoThe2nd]

No, I didn't take a picture from her teen years.
I took a picture that is less than half a year old on her Instagram.
I checked social media of all these women, and she is by far the most caked in her pictures out of all of them.

So not sure what you are trying to prove here, maybe you are just blind or maybe you are trying to validate some bias of yours.
She looks the most overdone from all these women, period.
And the male votes confirm this for you, it doesn't matter if she has technically "less make-up" than the others, her make-up looks the fake and unattural and that's what matters.

[InsertNameHerex]

Like I said she looks the same without it, did you bother watching all their makeup tutorials or see them em without makeup or are you just looking at their instagrams? It’s not her fault her skin is naturally glowing bro. I don't know why you’re so mad either, it’s just factual that she doesn’t wear much unless it’s for photos and all I’m trying to prove here is that y’all can’t tell the different between a lot and a little. And y'all assume that if a girl looks pretty, she must be wearing a ton of makeup and she must look completely different without it. She looks the same without it is all I’m saying therefore naturally pretty. And if you’re only using Instagram as a judgement then maybe you’re the blind one. Also she’s a makeup artist of course her insta is gonna have makeup pics, doesn’t mean she wears it all the time or looks completely different. Smh.

[HugoThe2nd]

No she doesn't look like that in real life, girl 2's face is all contoured.
She has her cheeks, nose, chin and everything painted in, that's what makes her look very fake.

And, lol. Girl 2 is by far the least pretty, so it is definitely not her "looking naturally pretty" that's the issue here.
This is how she looks like in real life:


She looks like shit without makeup, nothing at all like she does in her make-up.
All you did is prove the men right, you are biased as hell.

[InsertNameHerex]

She looks exactly the same without it, I’d link you an image but I literally can’t because of my low xper level. Biased with what exactly? It’s not like she’s me LOL why would I care? I’m just stating she looks pretty with and without it and many people would agree. After a few more hours when I can actually post another question, I’ll literally put a poll up about this if you want. “By far the least pretty” is your opinion lol beauty is subjective. And she definitely doesn’t look like “shit” without makeup at all. Her skin is literally perfect like what- all I did was prove myself right, y'all men can’t tell when a girl is wearing makeup or not.

[HugoThe2nd]

Well, if it makes you feel vindicated, I'm not going to take away that from you.
But I have to disagree with your deduction.

In reality, men are simply the MOST likely to excuse makeup on naturally pretty girls such as Cindy Kimberly and Thalia Crawford and they are the most biased against not so pretty girls with make-up because they feel cheated the most in that case (like with girl 2).

And in case of women, well you are the most biased against the pretty girls (1 and 4) because you are jealous, and you excuse the less pretty girls with make-up because the average girl is in the same boat with them.

[InsertNameHerex]

What? They’re all beautiful women lol girl 2 is far from average. I’m frankly jealous of every one of them. Just because you think 2 is least attractive doesn’t mean everyone does. Girl 2 looks pretty without it too. Plus I don't know I made a question about Cindy before and all the men kept saying how she wore too much makeup so I don't know if you’re right about that. Since when was a biased against 1&4? I don't know what made you think that? You’re the one who commented about 2, so I defended 2. I woulda defended any one of them because the majority of them are wearing barely any makeup and they look the same without it. Like I said beauty is subjective, not everyone is gonna think like you at all. It’s not a male female thing, it’s an eye of the beholder thing

[NathanDavis]

I feel like number 2 has the most make up, based on the contrast with the chest area... but that's just a guess

[InsertNameHerex]

I’ll reveal it later, who do you think is wearing the least?

[NathanDavis]

assuming there's no tricky filters or something, I would think the freckled girl, number 3

[pink_and_inlove]

I picked girl 5 because she looks like she had contour the other ones don’t i think

[InsertNameHerex]

The other girls lighting has less shadow in it so I guess I could see why you’d think that, however that’s incorrect lol, I’ll reveal the answer after a few more votes

[pink_and_inlove]

It’s either her or girl 1 I believe

[Nick473]

It looks the heaviest on the first girl last girl looks like filter

[Nick473]

4 i mean

[Robert_]

Thaymt would definitely be the first.

[InsertNameHerex]

I’ll announce it later but so far, no one is correct :)

[Static_In_The_Attic]

I’ll have to say girl three.

[alice55]

1 and 2 seem to wear the most make up

[athlete_for_lyf]

2 i can see highlighter.

[LoveYourself24]

At first glance I’d say either 2 or 4

[LoveYourself24]

Follow me? :)

[Anonymous]

Bullying me?
I hate make up

[S3ntnl]

first girl

[InsertNameHerex]

Nope

[Joker_]

I can't

[lycanthrope3]

Girl 2

[lycanthrope3]

Love 3s freckles

[InsertNameHerex]

It’s not 2, and yeah I wish I had freckles like that, they’re so nice