Which of the sandwiches would you order?

[OtterMan68]

If you had to choose one of these seven

Muffuletta

Rueben

Turkey club

Hot roast beef

Shrimp po-boy

Monte Cristo

Tuna melt

Updates

10 d

Being from Louisiana, I'd take the Muffuletta or po-boy, but without the tomato on the po-boy

Updates

8 d

More people need to try a muffuletta

[Rosexøxø]

Tough choice but I voted Reuben. Love it. Best one I had was at some joint run by Jewish people and we had went after a meet with a holocaust survivor and visiting a holocaust museum. Was so memorable. Yeah, it’s not kosher and people will say what they want but Reuben is a definite classic from New York made by them in the delis and I’m sure some may have survived the holocaust and learned to eat that since the sauerkraut is a feature and I believe that’s German.

Who knows maybe some were his by Germans and they grew up or adapted to that kind of diet and brought that “tradition” over in America. No idea but definite Jewish history to it. An enjoyable meal if they get their meats from a good brand as well.

[Rosexøxø]

I would say C; D, and F; G were also good ones and tough to choose from.

[Rosexøxø]

Reubens are a ny fave

[OtterMan68]

not a fan of louisiana sandwiches?

[Rosexøxø]

Omg thanks for mho 😂 I didn't think I would cause of my selection. Yeah, I don’t like shrimp cause of the poop line. I get you can de-vein them, but it just traumatized me hearing and seeing it. I saw some in store bought. My mom said “wellll it’s de-veined” not paying attention and that “it’s fine. It’ll get cooked.” Or “just don’t eat that one.” And I saw actual dark poop in the shrimp. A piece. It GROSSED ME OUTTTT. I used to like shrimp cause it tasted like a clean feathery chicken. Not any more though!

I just don’t like the add ons to those options. Like black olives, shrimp, banana pepper, and tomatoes. If those sandwiches didn’t have that, I could eat them. Tbh the first I would eat without the olives cause the meat looks good. That’s some good salami. The bread just didn’t look too good. The second one I can’t eat cause the main meat IS SHRIMP 😂 and the sides on it or whatever (the word escapes me) I can’t bring myself to eat either.

BUT this question inspired me to get myself a nice pastrami and Colby cheese sandwich. Toasted bread. 🥖 and given my new state it’s the closest feel to New York subs for me. The pastrami IS ALL I EVER ATE in New York 😂 def need to visit but I enjoyed the question. 🙋‍♀️

[OtterMan68]

A muffuletta without the olive mix is not a muffuletta! It's my favorite part

[7Phoenix7]

They all look good. I'm hungry. Give me the first or second one

[7Phoenix7]

Update: I've had the muffuletta it's delicious 🤤

[OtterMan68]

in Louisiana?

[7Phoenix7]

Yes, I have family there.

[OtterMan68]

good!

[WhiteSteve]

Any self-respecting Masshole is going for the roast beef☘️🍖

https://www.youtube.com/embed/omSzHsq0UOg

Kelly’s is actually cheeks though, despite having the most name recognition. Harrison’s in North Andover or Nick’s in Boogie Down Beverly are my go-to spots for a North Shore Beef, but MAN, it’s a long drive, lmao. Worth it when I make it though👍👍

[FatNeville]

I voted the turkey club, but in actuality I might order the muffuletta because I don't think I've ever had such a thing before and it would be interesting to try.

[PBandJ_Nerd]

Definitely the turkey club sandwich. 🥓

[jamesgoldman]

The Reuben is my favourite, I only get them when I go to Hatton Garden

I like the club without tomato and the roast beef as well

[OfMiceandMen]

I like the rueben with lots of sauerkraut and mustard.

[b_lova]

Can I get one of each? They all have their strengths.

[b_lova]

Agreed about the muffuletta. It's a highly underrated sandwich when prepared correctly.

[LaurenM1997]

Monte cristo only cause I like ham and cheese 🤤

[Imsmurter1]

They're all great. Well except beef dip, it's only good if the beef isn't chewy. I chose Monte Cristo but mind can change next week easily. Would like to tray Muffaletta.

[Iron_Man]

The turkey club, but I want Swiss cheese, ham and bacon in it

[12karen]

I'm so hungry rn so I'm gonna choose rueben

[82lynx]

It’s a toss-up between turkey club and hot roast beef. Incidentally I don’t need an entire turkey dinner; just give me the bird and I’ll devour it on its own.

[RedInnocent69]

Any of the bottom six anytime. Have to be in the right mood for a Reuben. Muffuletta, blech 🤮

[OtterMan68]

blasphemy! Ham, salami, olive mix, provolone cheese, fresh made italilan bread!

[RedInnocent69]

You’re seriously making me nauseous.

[AviatorTom]

I'd take the tuna melt. Not only is it tasty, the fish and its omega-3's are good for you.

[exitseven]

hot roast beef.

[NathanDavis]

all of them... I'm in that mood

[Pterodon]

Muffuletta for me

[avery58]

Monte Cristo

[Agape93]

Ruenens. I love em

[Nikki1989]

They all look disgusting.

[legalboxers]

What? No BLTs :(

[OtterMan68]

GAG only gives you seven choices. I could have included ham & cheese, PB&J, corned beef...

[LavLavLuv]

Monte cristo

[strateguy632]

4th.