
Should private filming for social media be banned in gyms? Why/why not?


So, when I am at work, I either use this site or YouTube, which are only two sites I can access from work. So, if you banned filming in the gym. Where would all the epic gym fail shorts, and videos come from?
I am just saying I get it; some random person does not want to be in you video, and sure there are crappy dude and dudettes out there just filming people, and its creepy.
But just think about all the joy and happiness that these epic fails videos bring into people lives! The humanity!!!
I mean if I wanted to see some chick completely destroy her nether regions with a exercise band snap back to the to crouch... how else would we achieve that without gym videos?
Yes. You're in a public place, they didn't agree to be filmed by you. It isn't security footage.
Depends on state law.
"This may seem odd but if you record someone else in Massachusetts without their consent and you capture audio of that person then it violates our state wiretap statute. If you recorded video only and no sound absent ambient background sounds that does not violate the statute. If the person has been audio recorded and does not remove him or herself from the area then you may have implied consent. It is rather fact specific and depends on what you are using the recording for and whether there is some form of consent."
- Emma Kramer Litigation Lawyer, Boston Ma
www.avvo.com/.../...e-in-public-in-ma-1203069.html
As long as they find out and leave, they can use.
Then why have them at all? What's the point of making a state law that you can't use?
I'm saying if they do contract not if they don't.
Contradict
And at that point I'd just quit the gym as I wouldn't like that at all.
Oh well that's the fuck up of the state and sometimes they end up getting away with it. Like marijuana, states are deciding for themselves what to do about that even though technically they should have been rated and severely punished on day 1. Marijuana is a schedule 1 controlled substance.
I personally think marijuana should be legal but what I think is irrelevant when it comes to legal technicalities.
Anyway, thanks for the legal lesson. Have a good day.
I think so. I understand wanting to film your own workout routine for whatever reason, but when you're in a gym, you're most likely not the only person there. I'm sure other people wouldn't want some random person filming, even if they're not trying to film other people. Sometimes you get random people in the background or maybe someone wants to use certain equpiment, but there's some person filming right by the equipment that you want to use. I can see how that would be annoying.
Yes.. I wouldn't want someone filming me while I am trying to work out..
LMAO I just watched the video she got kicked out and her membership revoked.. LOL idiot..
Opinion
37Opinion
I think a little common sense is what is required. These "influencers" need to realise that they are in a public gym with other members who pay their membership just like them. It's not right to make false allegations and dox other gym goers so you can make click bait content.
If you want to video and post shit on your social media that's fine but have manners about it and don't video other people against their will and don't throw a hissy fit just because someone at the gym walked across your shot.
Not at all. That's a terrible idea. It would make people more insecure, less confident in themselves.
If we live in a world where you never have to come to terms with anything then there will be no motivation to hold yourself to any kind of physical or emotional standard.
The gym is a place for working out. People are listening to music, catching up on their news feed in between sets, sending memes to their buddies, asking their PT buddies about proper form.
A person's ability to do all of that would have to be impaired if you wanted to ban phones in gyms. I honestly can't believe people are just not embarrassed to say stuff like this out loud. It's so obviously counterproductive to society in exchange for such a minor convenience to a group of people who refuse to mature themselves in any way.
@DaveJord so the plan is to just ask people nicely to not record other people? What happens when someone is taking a selfie and no one worries about the girls doing it but when a guy does it, because some chick in the background happened to be there what do you think is going to happen to that guy?
It's a stupid idea if you think about it for more than 5 seconds
@DaveJord I'm sure it wasn't just a selfie too. It sucks people are like this but the reality is, there's always going to be someone snapping a salatious pic be it in the gym or the beach or walking down the street. Instead of trying to change society by coming up with more rules, maybe we should work on confronting these people. This is why it should be less illegal to attack people lol
There is no such thing as privacy anymore. Keep in mind that the gym probably has a dozen cameras up for yours and their safety. That video can be used for anything the gym wants.
Now do I think someone should be allowed to harass individuals while working out with cameras in their face… No they shouldn’t.
Only if it’s done without the knowledge and consent of the gym goers around you, yes. There’s a gym content creator that I watch sometimes, can’t remember her name but she’s a very kind and considerate lady, and EVERY video she does, she puts herself in a non-busy area of the gym, and if anyone walks into her cameras shot, she kindly lets them know that she’s recording herself, and that they’re welcome to stay in the video if they want to, but there’s no pressure.
The problem is that gym owners love the free publicity they get from a "guru" with 100k followers when their gym is shouted out. And so gym security will side with the influencer acting all entitled which makes them bolder.
I'm not a fan of relying on the government for menial things but in this case there should be a law that protects the average gym goer from having to be kicked out over this
Yes and no. Yes - when its violating anyone's privacy or annoys/distracts people from doing their excercise. No - when its done in dedicated area for such purposes. Gyms should probably consider some small special areas for "influencers". Like we have smoking areas for example.
There’s so many old perverts at the gym. Look at this… 🙄 GROSS!

What they need to do, is go suck each-other’s d**k!
Don’t believe me?
👇👇👇Watch this👇👇👇
https://www.youtube.com/embed/DhKPHsFmTBghttps://www.youtube.com/embed/0GXOVg5-HGQYeah i've got a pretty good gym at home but i'd "join" one that banned cell phones just to show support.
hmmmmm! i have an idea. why not instead of banning it, seeing as people will break that kind of rule/law no matter what making gyms have to kick people out and thus loose money (i hear gyms often struggle finacially) . make it cost money, and not as a small fee. i would suggest $1000.00 minimum per filming (as a fine) and if it is a habit, it increases on subsequint times (5k, 10k, 30k, 50k, 100k)
yeah it should because it violates the privacy of other gym-goers
Yes if I ever decide to go to a gym I don't want my confusion on how to use a machine in the background of someone's squat video
No, but people trying to set up strangers for attention should be banned. They should be recorded, so the world can see both sides.
Any public filming may show things/people in there that one may not want to see. I can be filming myself and my friends at a bar and some married guy may be there with his girlfriend who she cheats on the wife with. I am sure he would not want my video to go viral.
She did it on purpose just to set the poor guy up. Everyone would stare at everyone. It's human nature. So the gym facility should be looking into that. Making whatever policy necessary.
Yes. if somebody was taking a video of me I would confiscate the cell phone.
I’d be like “the f*ck you recording me for”
Yeah, it mostly is banned where I live. The only exception is trainers using video or photos to help clients with form.
I'm all for it, mostly women that do that bullshit, and it's almost entirely for clout, and to prove a non existent point. Most men I know avoid women at all costs in the gym, they refuse to help or even spot for them lest they end up on some tiktok bitches video list. Interacting with women at these things is just not worth it.
Do it. The only people that should be filming are the ones running courses and doing it for instructional purposes. Too often it's to try and get popularity on social media/tik tok and fuck that lol
Yes. There is not justification for it - people are there to work out no to make tik toks. Video'ing other people is just wrong.
Yeah, I don't think people want to be recorded by other people. It's a creep move. If you are just recording yourself, that's fine but how are the staff going to know the difference?
Yeah, it tends to get out of hand these days. Not to mention being a target for drans. Everyone is recoding a video.
Guys... typing is hard ok. :)
Absolutely. This is how many people shame others for their weight. Also, it’s obnoxious and an invasion of privacy.
I rmbr that weirdo chick made up voices in her head say damn and she had no ass at all, so daaamn at what? She tripping hahahaha
Just wait for someone to punch their face in and break their phones. These things tend to fix themselves.
Yes. The gym is not being compensated for the use of their facilities. Go home and take your videos:
In my uni’s gym filming is banned everywhere from obviously locker/changing rooms to equipment rooms and I appreciate it.
I'd throw the phone on the ground and drop a few hundred pounds on it if someone was recording me at a gym
I think the gym should make their own rules. They could put a sign up.
i don’t understand people filming themselves working out unless they’re like a pro bodybuilder.
Yes. All filming should be banned. Especially in the gym. If people want to do there weird flexes in the gym on social media, do that at your home gym. Idiots like that take up time and energy from people like us that want to get this work in.
It should be. Because it’s irritating and inconsiderate to other people
Yes.
You get in the way, get on peoples' nerves and you film background people against their will.
We should not ban it, we should address the toxic nature around it. A bunch of narcissistic people who want to be Instagram whores should stop being glorified.
The video won't play.
But yes. Filming should stop. Security cameras are 1 thing. But on private phones, no.
Absolutely. You're there to work out so work out.
Should not be banned
Yes it should, especially if persons are in gym
You should have made this a poll.
Yes it should be. It’s just dumb.
Nah as a guy I don't mind...
It should.
Or you ladies dress better lol
yeah
Yes for sure
You can also add your opinion below!
Most Helpful Opinions