In the spirit of Christmas , have you noticed the hypocrisy of atheists?

All year atheists preach two important ideas 'hypocrisy is the worst' and 'people can be good without believing in god heaven Hell' etc but think of the book by Charles Dickens writing, 'A Christmas Carol' about giving due to fear of ghosts and hell but,

I don't see atheists GIVING their own money, to help others , homeless poor etc they wanna give taxes but not GIVE their own money because they don't know to GIVE without god? see the hypocrisy? That they consider the worst?

Is there any athiest homeless help, that I just don't know about? Or did they themselves prove that they can't be good without god?

In the spirit of Christmas , have you noticed the hypocrisy of atheists?
Post Opinion