Why do we consider celebrities who are of average or below-average attractiveness to be great beauties?

Anonymous
I don't understand why celebrities of average or below-average levels of attractiveness are considered physically beautiful by people. Some examples of average looking celebrities, to me, would be: Blake Lively, Alyson Hannigan, Gwyneth Paltrow, Penelope Cruz, January Jones, Jennifer Lawrence and Reese Witherspoon

I find Reese Witherspoon, Jennifer Lawrence, and Alyson Hannigan kind of cute, but not exceptionally attractive. Blake Lively is ugly, to me, except for her figure. January Jones is simply average, as well as Gwyneth Paltrow, and Penelope Cruz isn't that attractive.

Emma Watson is pretty and kind of cute, I believe, but I feel like memes and the internet have sexualized her so much that she is considered some sort goddess, and way more beautiful than she actually is. She isn't super attractive. I feel like if I passed her on the street, I wouldn't stare.
Why do we consider celebrities who are of average or below-average attractiveness to be great beauties?
20 Opinion