Guys, what type of body do you consider 'bones'?

[bombdotcom]

So, a lot of overweight girls like to ask "Curves or skinny and boney?"

What does 'bones' mean?

link

link

link

link

link

[Anonymous]

i know I'm not a guy but none of those girls are boney to me, the first is barely borderline because of the hip ridges but that's it as the rest of her looks healthy and she has curves. I hate when fat girls put down slim people and shove them into the anorexic sack of bones category.

this is boney imo link link I imagine the girls asking those questions to look like this link and think they look like this link

[bombdotcom]

I hate you for posting that 2nd to last pic lmao

[Opinion Owner]

dem curves ;)

[FierceMegan2]

I agree with this answer too.

[FierceMegan2]

I know I am not a guy, and you asked the guys, but I think us girls put too much weight on this subject.

We should all be encouraged to eat healthy and exercise, and lay off the junk.

Anyway, as for your links, technically they all have curves. Their hips bones when out, and they had boobs.

I think high fashion models are the ones without curves because they rarely have hip bones (except the VS models).

[Account]

I will probably get down-voted fir this, but I don't like the first and the last girl. All the others look gorgeous in my opinion. The girl in the first link has a decent AND curvy body type, but I find her way too skinny. The last girl is overweight. The others look awesome.

[Account]

The most gorgeous girl (in my personal opinion), is the middle girl in your forth link.

[TedStar]

Something along these link link link link

Your first link is too skinny. I know girls like collar bones, but that is way too much. She needs to eat lol. I've seen Selena Gomes a lot thinner so this pic is not bad. The crossftitter and the group of girls are very acceptable. The last pic is nowhere near "bones"

[RedThread]

LOL none of those guys are bony or too skinny.

[RedThread]

*girls not guys.. that was weird..

[RedThread]

Thanks for BA lol

[Anonymous]

Fat girls say "bones" because they don't realize--yes, there's something wrong if all your bones are hidden in rolls of fat. And

And aside from link 5, and the girl with the big stomach in link 4, they're all in great shape.

Girls need to look up to fit

link

link

[Opinion Owner]

downvoted by a chick so fat you can't see her collarbone. xD

[Luv2run]

Haha I agree!

[Opinion Owner]

yep, fatties would rather try to make the world love obesity than get their asses in shape and be sexy, lmao.

[cavmanier]

I think that girl with the tiny stomach in link 4 is hot. She just has assets

[Opinion Owner]

Hmm, I wouldn't kick any in link four out of bed, lol.

[CasaNorba]

nah man. I think I'll pass on those links

[Eiffelgirl21]

I am no fattie :) and I downvoted because link 4, the girl doesn't have a big stomach!

[bubbiexo]

@ Eiffel, same reason I downvoted!

[MrOracle]

The first girl is right on the border of unacceptably thin. She is somewhat *naturally* super-slender (what I call a "greyhound" build), but she has clearly dieted/exercised her way to be even smaller than she would normally be. She's not over the line, but she's right up against it.

Some girls ARE greyhounds, and they're going to be tall and thin no matter what, and that's fine. What isn't fine is girls who diet and exercise to excess, to the point that they look either "hard and stringy" with Madonna arms, or they look emaciated. The first girl is starting to be a bit of both - if she was 5-10 pounds heavier, she'd be totally fine. As is, she's in the danger zone.

[MyNameIsJonas]

All of the girls in link 4 are hot (curvy and hot)

Link 3, Selena has a nice body and I woundlnt consider her boney or bones.

Girl in link 2 has huge legs. I would consider her athletically built.

Girl in link one is rather skinny/boney.

link < Miley is a good example of a skinny/boney looking girl.

As for link 5 that's random.

[Anonymous]

Boney:

link

and maybe

link

Regarding your links, I'd consider #1 and #2 to be about the same and ideal. #3 is probably closer to average, but can still be attractive! #4, the group pic, the one on the left is curvy, the middle one is slightly curvy, and the one on the right is thin. #5 is beyond curvy, but would probably describe herself as "kind of curvy" on a dating website.

[FierceMegan2]

I have to agree with this answer.

[Opinion Owner]

#1 is close to getting some definition in her ab muscles. Just a few more crunches!

[Shyguy_1988]

Link one has a small frame and is skinny but still has curves. Waist goes in hips go out, so I find that attractive.

Link 2 has more of an athletic build which is another body type I find attractive. Nice legs, still has curves.

Link 3 looks like your average female body type

Link 4 girl in the center has a nice shape. One to the left is nice as well, girl to the right isn't quit as curvy but still looks pretty good.

Link 5 girl is a bit big for my tastes but hey if we hit it off maybe! Personality means a lot!

[confugirl]

I'm gonna say when they've got no muscle definition AND you can see most of her ribs. Because if she has muscle definition, but you can see her ribs, then I would call that lean, not bony. Bony is when they've really got a thin layer of skin tightly over their bones.

[TedAllen]

The first girl looks too skinny to me. I can see the bones sticking out of her chest and shoulders. The last girl is fat. Being too skinny is not the real problem in America. Obesity is the real problem. The obesity rate in America is as high as the divorce rate. It's about lifestyle. Anyone that eats hamburgers and fries and drinks sugar-filled sodas every day is going to have health problems.

[torikoryn]

On what realm are any of the last girls fat? lmao

[bombdotcom]

The last pic is fat

Just because it's the norm in America doesn't mean it's the norm everywhere else

[Eiffelgirl21]

I wouldn't say she is fat. I would say obese maybe. but fat...to me is like HUGE

[TedAllen]

I weigh about 137 pounds. I'm built like the average Japanese man. The average American woman that's my age weighs 160 pounds or more. Sixty percent of American men and women are overweight. The last girl has big legs. That's what makes her look fat to me. She probably weighs at least twenty pounds more than me.

[Eiffelgirl21]

but how tall are you? I weigh 155 and I am NO where near fat! I am 5'10/11 and very lean and athletic

[TedAllen]

The average Japanese man is 5' 7". I'm less than 5' 8". You're not a big woman to a man that's 6' 2" and weighs 200 pounds. Most of the girls in these pictures look like they weigh less than 125 pounds with the exception of the last girl. The problem in America is not that most women are 5' 10" and weigh 155 pounds. The problem is that many of them are 5' 5" and weigh 155 pounds or more. Women like that are not attractive to a man that's 6' 2". They aren't attractive to me either.

[TedAllen]

Most American women are less than 5' 5". Any woman that's less than 135 pounds looks fine to me if she's 5' 5" or less. The first girl in these pictures is very skinny, but I wouldn't say she's anorexic. I can't really complain about her weight because I know she's probably going to weigh at least twenty pounds more by the time she's my age.

[Meedo]

The first one need to put a little weight on. May be not too much . The Last needs to loose a bit .. but not much ... because with her lovely round ass.. I am sure she will give a great feeling on my lap. I don't want her to loose those boobs too. yum..

[Anonymous]

The first one is verging on too thin, but the other look fine. The girl in the middle of the group shot probably has the most ideal body, since she has a small frame, but an hourglass shape and decently full breasts. If only mother nature was so kind to us all!

[celestialdaeva]

Why are all your skinny examples of girls who look athletic?

link

[bombdotcom]

None of the girls I linked look athletic. Of course, compared to the average American female they might. American women usually have an unhealthy perception of what thin is in order to justify being fat

[celestialdaeva]

Wow I can smell your body image issues from here.

[bombdotcom]

No body image issues here. But the average American woman has body issues

[celestialdaeva]

Thank you for telling me what all the other women in the country think. I wasn't aware. But now I know.

[CasaNorba]

OUCH!

[Eiffelgirl21]

please be nice girls! :)

[thetundrawolf]

The first one is kinda near that, but I would say the anorexic model type of today is what I would consider bones. I like a little meat on the legs, I found all the other women to be attractive, even the last one.

[sean1234]

Well the first link, that girl is the thinnest, but I've seen thinner. The rest look good, personally I like the 2nd link girl. It's good to have some muscle, I respect that.

[Phoenix1991]

None? I like them all.

I guess bones would be to the point when you see all of the girls ribs and bones more easier than other body types. From what I seen, those girls look healthy in shape.

[Cobalt]

First girl is skinny, second is fit, third I wouldn't categorize except maybe normal or average, and last is curvy. Honestly the second and third both look like they keep in shape whereas the third looks soft and the first looks to simply be thin.

[iluvchewbucca]

I've never heard of anybody referring to someone else as "bones"... that's weird!

From the links the second link looks pretty fit! the rest they all look normal/average too me...

The last link looks overweight.

[kheserthorpe]

The first one. Though I suspect growing up may take care of that.

[bombdotcom]

She's a grown up. I know it's verging on being weird. I wanted to email the admins and ask them to take it away

[kheserthorpe]

I would have guessed she was 14-16. Its not just the body fat its the lack of hips. Like my daughter is 11, she's 5'2" but she's only like 70 lbs, she's a stick still, body of a kid.

Anyway...

[bombdotcom]

I just assumed she was a petite adult

I don't feel comfortable with her picture up there anymore

[kheserthorpe]

Teen models are used for modelling all the time. My wife used to laugh at those 'next top models' shows because she said they were really all too old to start.

[bombdotcom]

I really wouldn't want someone calling her hot if she's underage...

[cavmanier]

My ex girlfriend got scouted to go on that show and I believe she was around 24-25ish.

[bombdotcom]

That show is a joke though

Real models start at around 13/14 and build up portfolios

[kheserthorpe]

That's when most are retired by several years. Don't get me wrong, there is some modelling work for models that age, and certainly some women look great and with the publicity of the show behind them might have a bit of a career, but generally models are in their teens to maybe 22.

[cavmanier]

Yeah it was just a TV show. I don't think she ever thought she would be a supermodel. She is 5' 10", thin with good looks, but they would have told her to lose 15 pounds (she was about 130-135) I bet lol. She declined anyway.

[yaddayaddayadda02]

'Bones'

link

[futureSURGEON]

i like them all, with the exception of the last. I prefer slimmer women, the first 4 links show the ideal body type in my opinion.

[madhatters4]

what does boney mean?

def the 1st link and to some maybe the girl on the far right in the 4th link.

[G-Daz]

The first one looks quite a bit too bony, the last girl look amazing I'd assume some people would claim she is "fat" but her clothes are deceiving

[Jonny_]

I'd say the first and maybe the second... The last picture is beyond my idea of curvy if I'm being honest.

[Dandeus]

1 and the girl on the right in 4 are bony.

2 is kind of bony, but it's because she's extremely athletic, not scrawny.

Selena Gomez and the other two girls in 4 look really good.

[sammy_31]

Out of all of those girls the first is the closest to "bones".

[maiez]

The first girl is too skinny for my taste, but boney is less skinny than her.

[Anonymous]

The only one of the links you posted would be the first one. She is REALLY skinny and is not what I'd find myself having eyes for.

[CasaNorba]

1,2,3, and 4 (especially the one in the lavender; on the right)

[CasaNorba]

oh shit! someone got their account banned once more. I wonder what's the excuse this time

[Anonymous]

Definitely 1.

I don't no what hips shy guy is speaking about, but she is bony and straight down.

[bombdotcom]

She has hips, they just aren't saddlebags

[Opinion Owner]

Sure, in that case then everyone has hips.

[bombdotcom]

Everyone does have hips

Not everyone is fat or thick

[Opinion Owner]

That's not true it's like saying everyone has a butt.

Her hips go straight down, she has a boyish figure.

[bombdotcom]

Everyone, male or female has hips. Again, not everyone has saddlebags that they mistake for the term 'hips'

[Opinion Owner]

If you want to be technical yes.

But by hips, I am referring to those that are a little wider.

[cavmanier]

She has quite a waist to hip ratio.

[bombdotcom]

Not to the overweight girls of girlsaskguys

[Opinion Owner]

U people are blind.

flat shapeless anorexic girls are in I guess.

[Opinion Owner]

5'7 and 125 lbs makes me overweight ? Nice assumption.

[Opinion Owner]

Of course its not because obviously you can't do Math.

[Opinion Owner]

Yeah because 122-125 lbs is way heavier.

Lol! Sad.

[Opinion Owner]

Wow you must be delusional. So you're 5'2 and 115 lbs. I'm 5'7 and 122 lbs and you're saying you're thinner than me.

Short , stocky, and retarded. There's no winning with you.

Sad case here.

[Anonymous]

None of them are too skinny

The last link is fat

[523206720]

None of them are too skinny.

[klalsaleh]

The first one is close to bones

[ihatethiswebsite]

Bones means basically anorexia to me

[ihatethiswebsite]

I would say anything worse than number one is bones. Number one is close looking to being too unhealthy small

[echoaj]

1st

[SaltandVinegar]

the 1st link

[Anonymous]

Only the first one.

[Marduk2244]

maybe first link