5/10 Girl cheats on beta boyfriend, sees Chad in her bed and kills them both. Was he in the wrong?

[Anonymous]

An upstate college basketball player and a young male, who plays on the hockey team, were slaughtered by the young woman’s lover when he found them in bed together at their off-campus home near SUNY Geneseo, authorities said on Monday.

Dead Girlfriend:

Killer Boyfriend:

Dead Chad

Kingtson, 24, let himself in through the back door and found Kesley Annese,21 and Matthew Hutchinson, 24, in an upstairs bedroom at their rented home. He then left and bought a “large knife” at a nearby store and returned home, some time between 5:30 a. m. and 6:21 a. m. Sunday, Geneseo Police spokesman Jeffrey Szczesniak said Monday.

He murdered them “quickly,” cops said. There were no signs of a struggle and the victims may have been sleeping, he said.

THE "VICTIMS"

Yes

No

[D_Bone_Steak]

I put no because the repercussions are now greater and no turf was possessed and ceased for it's vital resources (in this case the girl)... the point of war acts like murder.

She looks like the average friends with benefits I could pull and he looks like the average new boyfriend that steals them away... yeah, she was in the wrong... but he should've been ready for that coming and mature enough to know 2 wrongs won't make a right. There's that maturity, emotional maturity level that knows this is effed up, but responding with more effed up shiznit isn't a better choice than cutting your losses. It's like losing at the casino with odds you should've guessed weren't in your favor, leaving and buying a big knife, then going back to the Casino and try to rob the place... I'm not going to come out on top like that. So IMHO, it's the wrong phucking choice.

[serp777]

Adultery doesn't warrant murder by any stretch. It warrants getting pissed, depressed, and very drunk but murder is too much. he should have just realized how freaking beta he was an to only go after girls who couldn't get someone to cheat with them or to just avoid women altogether.

At least he had a hot girlfriend for a while--I mean what about guys who just get straight up rejected all the time? They don't even get a chance. Clearly that's worse and yet that also isn't a justifcation for murder.

[Lioness]

You have a really warped sense of women, people in general. Shame on you for rating someone's DECEASED young daughter, sister, friend, etc. That in itself is DISGUSTING. And all this beta, alpha nonsense you do know people get old and lose there looks, right? Murder is wrong, doesn't matter about looks or rankings. You need to delve a bit deeper and find your heart buried somewhere amidst all your judgement, sad.

[israelisevil]

you can beat the guy for being in your house and throw your gfs shit out her house you dont got kill anybody. usually just shooting off a few bullets and pointing guns at peoples gets them do what you want and make them leave naked or some harmless shit. this overboard and screams incel loosers

[fauchelevent]

Yes, he's in the wrong. No one is in the right in this situation - the girl was wrong for cheating, so was the guy who was with her, and they shouldn't have been allowed to get away with it without repercussions. But the appropriate response would have been to break off the relationship with her, not murder her, so he's still the one in the wrong here and what he did was worse.

[Prettygurl12]

Lol fun story... so if you kill both of them in Ohio, it's called heat of passion and isn't deemed murder necessarily. But if one of them lives then it's murder haha

But no, that's straight up a double homicide and dumb ass boyfriend needs to go away for life.

[jacquesvol]

Ohio Sharia Law?

[Prettygurl12]

@jacquesvol I'm spacing on what it's term is, but I remember my law professor talking about it. I'm not sure this situation would qualify (since the boyfriend left and returned and I'm not sure it's in Ohio) but it's an interesting loop hole, don't you think?

[Asker]

This was in New York

[Prettygurl12]

Then it doesn't qualify. He'll go to prison for life.

[Anonymous]

Didn’t deserve to be killed. Voluntary Manslaughter. When you see too much real shir. You loose sympathy for so many people. You really do and I hate to say it.

A lot of people are dead because of the choices they make and I’m not even defending the killers most of them are stupid in their own right. It’s sad someone’s dead. It’s sad they have a family.

But there is SO much stuff that families don’t know about their dead loved ones. Not in all cases. But it’s not like TV where someone’s a completely innocent victim. There are cases like that yes. It’s just sometimes best for the families not to know

[beccaboo2]

First things first, I read this story online and he did NOT catch her cheating on him. They had already broken up before the night of the murder.
Second, there is no justification for cold blooded MURDER. Even if they were still a couple during the incident, cheating does not warrant a death sentence.

[DonkeyKong1979]

Of course he wasn't in the wrong, double homicide was a totally reasonable and proportionate response to the situation...

[Chief16]

Dude... He killed himself too. Add the detail. Also, they'd broken up. The guy was definitely in the wrong.

[jacquesvol]

" He then left and bought a “large knife” at a nearby store and returned home."
That's murder one: intentional murder that is willful and premeditated with malice aforethought. Maximum penalty.

[tzdc21]

He was right to be extremely pissed off because the girlfriend was a piece of shit. But killing them because of that... no

[Anonymous]

The number of sick fucks on this site masturbsting over stories like this disgust me.

He was her ex boyfriend... She probably dumped him for being abusive.

[LittleSally]

Of course he was wrong! o. O

He's unstable and a psychopath.

[Waffles731]

WHAT THE FUCK IS WRONG WITH YOU RATING A MURDER VICTIM BASED ON HER LOOKS.
THATS HOW YOU CALL THIS POUR WOMAN 5/10 GIRL.
SHE HAD A FUCKING NAME

[Anonymous]

Yes anon it's wrong to kill someone even if they're cheating on you.

[Anonymous]

no he has no right to kill her... and no alpha and beta are not real cathegories, please educate yourself and don´t use dumb words that embarrass yourself.

[Anonymous]

Crime of passion, maybe if she wasn't a slut she'd still be alive.

[Anonymous]

No not wrong. Obsession and the idea of owning another human being is ahem cough cough normal.

[Lolomon]

NOTHING justifies murder!

[Anonymous]

I would have done the same. they both deserved to die. especially her.

[January_Sixth]

Just give me xper points

[AngelLily]

Yes definitely wrong.

[HentaiMaster23]

Murder is Bad, he was wrong for killing people

[mentor]

Killing I always wrong It is never the solution

[microcephalicguy]

you are roostah, aren't u? lol @5/10 girl,

[Octavius]

You're disgusting.