Are the Elemental signs of masculinity and femininity outdated?

[StormMistress]

Ie Fire is masculine because it’s hot, strong and passionate. Air is also Masculine because it’s logical, free and expressive. Earth is feminine because it’s grounded, stable and nurturing. Water is feminine because it’s emotional, flowing, sensitive etc.

Whilst I love astrology for fun I do feel the whole definition of masculine and feminine is abit outdated. Somethings I can see as more masculine like passion, strength where as feminine is more nurturing and emotions. But things like logic, freedom, stability etc feels more neutral.

Honestly I feel it should be Fire and Water are very masculine/feminine where as Air and Earth have a more neutral energy to them.

What are your thoughts?

[EmbraceThePain]

I just want to say, just because something is “logical” doesn’t mean it’s good.


Also, if something is “emotional” it’s bad.


Popularly, masculinity is known to be logical
Femininity—emotional


I think there’s pros and cons to both.


Personally, I feel like I’m a lot more emotional than logical.

[Sixgunsound]

Can’t you just make up a new system as you go along?

[Djaay]

Everything but a woman herself is masculine. BC GOD designed it all. Feminitity was GODS intention for a woman made from man for man to submit to a man.

[msc545]

My thought is that in the real world none of this makes the slightest bit of difference.

[StormMistress]

Yes I know but I love astrology and would love a more updated modern look at the concept.

[msc545]

I see - ok.

[NathanDavis]

I am all of those... and a lot more

[OmegaSTC]

Those elements are just metaphors