Search Results: pick up lines on girls

I got set up with a girl I knew from highschool. Although she lived a few hours away. We talked for about 2 months, as our schedules never lined up because of school for her to let me come up to see her given the time it took to get there.
Over the holidays, she had a month long break, and asked since we liked each other and we wanted a relationship if she could stay the month with me since she didn't want to be at home with family. I said sure.

I went and picked her up and she was oddly quiet. She later said she just had a migraine, and it wasn't anything I was doing. Later we went and took a nap. She woke me up cause she felt worse and asked to go home.

On the ride home she said that although she had a migraine, she also wasn't fully over her ex, and thought she was ready for a relationship with me and it changed when she met me. She realized she wasn't ready.

I dropped her off, and I was pretty disappointed. I tried to sympathize with her, and I checked in on her after a week.

She made plans to come spend time with me, but would then cancel them last minute. At which point I asked her why she's doing that, and she said she didn't have anything to say to me. So I stopped reaching out and I blocked her on social.

A few months later I felt bad for how I handled it. I tried to reach out on social media, but she denied my request. So when I could I just reblocked her.

Should I try again to reach out to her or leave that shit behind?

Imagine the following guy:
Early 20s, 6' tall, well-groomed, well-dressed, attends an Ivy League law school, well-spoken, well-read, but somewhat eccentric. He talks about niche interests that sound like they belong in the 19th century and doesn't really know much about modern media. He's a gamer and sounds quirky and nerdy. His texts are long-winded and overly formal-sounding paragraphs and he doesn't use any puns or pick-up lines.

That, and he's also a bit chubby. He looks like he's got an average body type in all of his full-body photos (and even looks somewhat thin in some), but his face is definitely fairly plump.

Going strictly off the above, would you date him (discounting any other factors); yes or no?