Do you believe in an all-white ethnostate?

[Anonymous]

And would you like to live there?

Yes

No

[nightdrot]

First of all, the terminology is wrong. Ethnicity is not the same as race.

Portuguese, Spanish, Russian, German, Italian, French. All of these are different ethnicities or nationalities, but they all of one race - white. Thus, an all white "ethno-state" is somewhat contradictory. You can - and there have been - states in history that were all of one race but split over ethnic, or indeed tribal, religious, or other identities.

As far as creating an all-white racial state, in theory it is possible. In practice it has a very ugly pedigree and history and would not be a good idea. Indeed, it was, boiled to its essence, what the National Socialists argued for in Germany. They adhered to the idea that the driving force in History - with a capital "H" - was the competition of the races and that destiny pointed to the triumph of the master race.

It is, at least in theory, possible to have an all white or black or Asian state. A simple accident of geography or history. However, in practice to so define the state is to set the stage for the ugliest of tyrannies.

Once race becomes the defining attribute of the state, the state will do all in its power to assert the primacy of the race. It will not, indeed by definition cannot, lay back and take a "live and let live" attitude to other subordinate races but must, rather, organize the law, the economy and the culture to give preference and privilege to the dominant race. That must, in turn, become inherently autocratic and brutal.

Suffice to say, that is something best avoided. As, to repeat, history has amply and quite brutally demonstrated.

[ZeussLightningBolt]

I wouldn't have a problem with it, and of course I wouldn't mind living in one.
They have one in South Africa, and it has the lowest crime rate in the entire country. But crime aside, societies function best when its inhabitants share the same culture and values.
And I wouldn't care if other races/ethnicities had their own state. In fact, this is the very reason Yugoslavia and the Soviet Union broke up. When you have too many opposing ideologies and traditions, there tends to be conflict.

Personally, I support the creation of a White state in Western Cape, but I'm not for excluding other minorities, but I would like certain parts of the world to maintain a LARGELY white majority.
Africa and the Caribbean have a black majority. Arabia has an Arab majority. Asia has an Asian majority. Why can't Europe, Australia and New Zealand have a WHITE majority?
Why does it seem like there is a place for everyone on this planet except whites?

[littleloren02]

People should have the right to set up their own communities. Do what you want, so long as it doesn't infringe on other people's freedoms

[littleloren02]

Feel free to message me OP

[MackToday]

Ethnic states are the answer to so many of the social problems that plague us.

[littleloren02]

True. Saw a video of a black women bitching about how there were too many white people at the university she was attending. Like wtf. Fuck off and start your own one then, racist bitch.

[MackToday]

That girl is a tool of globalists she has no idea what she's even saying. They took someones daughter and turned her into that. Now she spouts racist crap and gets pats on the back from her comrades for doing it. It could be anyone's child at those Marxist universities that happened to.

[Trolloween]

I wouldn't mind living with only white people but I wouldn't move to an ethnostate for that reason. Also who would make all the curry and Chinese food? It just seems pointless and segregation only breeds hatred

[MackToday]

Segregation causes peace, you don't hate who you don't even know or only read about. It's when people from different races and cultures are forced to live together that trouble starts.

[Trolloween]

I think people only knowing about other people from the Internet is exactly what causes hatred. Many members of the kkk quit after they actually meet black people in real life instead of basing everything off their echo chamber with preconceived ideas.

It seems the biggest causes for conflict right now are political, nothing to do with race.

[msc545]

All white areas are really *boring*. Other cultures and races add so much to the quality of life in terms of great music, food, art, customs, intelligence, and conversation, among many other things. I feel very lucky to live and work in a very multicultural and multiracial environment.

[LordJesus5Ever]

Depends where is it located. Some dude a while ago commented that he wants to build this ethnostate in the god damn Sahara, like dude, that is one helluva hot place to live.

[MackToday]

I believe in ethnic states for all races I think that's how we evolved and what's natural and healthy.

[tartaarsaus]

I’m not white so no by default? Also, racial segregation is stupid

[7771999]

I wouldn't mind living in one. But they don't exist.

And tbh, it's super unlikely to exist. What we do need, is a white super majority in every Western country.

[ZeussLightningBolt]

Oranja, though it's not a state

[Pipeliner87]

Like how Black people only want black people schools and their own black people safe spaces in schools. I think white people should have their own white people schools and area's.

[Usernamesrdumb]

I dont want an all anything. Although hate the way the monocultures of the world, judge the USA, in what is actually an experiment in grand scheme of history of the planet.

[Plitty-Tank]

No. I don't want to live in a place where there is all white people. I like diversity of race and sex.

[Dchrls78104]

Wasn't apartheid enough?

[EnglundUberAlles]

An all-night what now?

[Nachowedgie]

No and no